X v Director of Proceedings

Link copied
Case Copied 9 min read

ORDER PROHIBITING PUBLICATION OF NAME, ADDRESS, OCCUPATION OR IDENTIFYING PARTICULARS OF APPELLANT. ORDER SUPPRESSING PUBLICATION OF PERSONAL HEALTH INFORMATION OF MRS X.

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND DUNEDIN REGISTRY

CIV 2014-412-0010 [2014] NZHC 1798

BETWEEN

DR X

Appellant

AND

THE DIRECTOR OF PROCEEDINGS Respondent

Hearing: 31 July 2014

Counsel:

A H Waalkens QC for Appellant
A L Martin and H Cook for Respondent

Judgment:

7 August 2014

JUDGMENT OF SIMON FRANCE J

Introduction

[1]      Dr X acknowledged his guilt before the New Zealand Health Practitioners Disciplinary Tribunal (the Tribunal) in relation to two charges of professional misconduct.   The conduct  in  question  involved  intimacy with  a patient  on  two occasions on the same day.  The first occurred in his consulting rooms.  The second, by arrangement, at her place of work.  There was, however, no agreement as to what had happened so a hearing took place.

[2]      At the end of the hearing convictions were entered. The most that needs to be said about the conduct is that it involved sexual intimacy short of intercourse.  After hearing evidence from Dr X about the background to the offending and the various

matters  that  contributed  to  what  the  Tribunal  accepted  was  out  of  character

DR X v DIRECTOR OF PROCEEDINGS [2014] NZHC 1798 [7 August 2014]

offending, the Tribunal imposed a fine of $25,000, and conditions on his practice which were to apply for three years.1

[3]      The conditions are that:

(a)       Dr X  undergo  various  assessments,  and  undertake  any  courses  of action consequently directed; and

(b)that Dr X only see female patients with a chaperone present, and that a notice to this effect be displayed at each of his work places.

[4]      The Tribunal described the case as a very unusual one, and was satisfied these conditions would adequately protect public safety.  The Tribunal accepted that there was a low risk of re-offending in light of the evidence about changes in Dr X, including his mental well-being.

[5]      There  remained  the  issue  of  permanent  name  suppression,  which  is  the subject of this appeal.

[6]      Dr X advanced his case for name suppression on cumulative bases pointing to the effect publicity would have on his own health and also on that of his wife, as well  as  the  impact  on  her  work  situation.    The  submission  was  buttressed  by reference to the Tribunal’s conclusion that there was a low risk of re-offending, and that the public safety component was well catered for.

[7]      Concerning Dr X’s own position, it was clear that a combination of personal circumstances had led to a period of instability around the time of the offending. With psychiatric and other assistance he had made significant progress.  He was still on medication but was considered well able to work, and generally had reached a

much improved place.

1      Re Dr X Decision 591/Med 13/258P, 23 December 2013.

[8]      The concern, therefore, was the impact that publicity would have on him. The psychiatrist treating him had suggested it would cause “irreparable…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read X v Director of Proceedings and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2014] NZHC 1798
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Dr X v Director of Proceedings, Dr X appealed against the decision of the New Zealand Health Practitioners Disciplinary Tribunal, which had imposed certain conditions on his practice and refused to suppress his name. Dr X argued that the publication of his name would have an adverse effect on his mental health and that of his wife, Mrs X, who suffers from a significant health condition that is stress-triggered. The Tribunal had rejected Dr X's application for name suppression but had granted it for Mrs X. The court considered whether the Tribunal's decision was correct and whether the suppression of Dr X's name was necessary to protect Mrs X's health.

The court found that the Tribunal's decision to suppress Mrs X's name was largely ineffective because most people who know her will know she is Dr X's spouse, and the effect of publicity would not be greatly lessened by suppressing only her name. The court concluded that the best solution to this was to suppress Dr X's name to avoid breaching the suppression order concerning Mrs X. The court also found that the factors not satisfied if name suppression is ordered are the denunciation and deterrence components that stem from publicity, the general right of the public to know, and the specific right of Dr X's patients to be able to make an informed choice. However, the court found that these factors were not compelling enough to outweigh the need to protect Mrs X's health.

The court allowed the appeal and ordered that Dr X's name and identifying particulars be suppressed subject to the continuation of the conditions set out in the Tribunal's ruling and a further condition that if asked by a patient, Dr X will confirm he is the doctor who obtained name suppression, and will otherwise provide the patient with appropriate information. The court also confirmed the Tribunal's suppression orders concerning Mrs X's condition, and her personal health information.

This case highlights the importance of balancing the need to protect the health of family members with the public's right to know and the right of patients to make an informed choice. The court found that in this case, the need to protect Mrs X's health outweighed the other factors, and suppression of Dr X's name was necessary to achieve that goal.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.