| IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF NEW ZEALAND I TE KŌTI PĪRA O AOTEAROA |
| CA68/2020 [2020] NZCA 581 |
| BETWEEN | MARK ANDREW WRIGHT |
| AND | THE QUEEN |
| Hearing: | 7 October 2020 |
Court: | Gilbert, Mallon and Ellis JJ |
Counsel: | A J McKenzie for Appellant |
Judgment: | 23 November 2020 at 9.30 am |
JUDGMENT OF THE COURT
A The appeal against conviction is dismissed.
BThe appeal against sentence is dismissed.
____________________________________________________________________
REASONS OF THE COURT
(Given by Ellis J)
Following a trial before Judge Garland and a jury, Mr Wright was convicted of three charges of importing a Class A controlled drug (methamphetamine).[1] He was sentenced to nine and a half years’ imprisonment on 17 January this year.[2] The Judge applied the guidelines set out by this Court in Zhang v R.[3]
[1]At the start of his trial he also pleaded guilty to one charge of possessing pipes for methamphetamine use and one charge of possessing methamphetamine.
[2]R v Wright [2020] NZDC 730. The sentence comprised a nine-year starting point with an uplift of six months for past offending.
Mr Wright now appeals his importation convictions on several grounds: insufficient evidence that the drugs were imported, insufficient evidence that he was involved with the importation, and that an “attribution” chart prepared by the Crown was improperly given to the jury. He appeals his sentence on the ground that the Judge ought to have reduced the starting point (or given an appropriate discount) to reflect that the drugs were intercepted by the New Zealand Customs Service (Customs) before he received them.
Factual background
On 15 June 2017, a package from California, United States was received by the New Zealand Post Depot in Christchurch (Package A). The wrapping of Package A recorded:
(a)Sender: law offices of Jean Goldsman, 501W Civic Centre Drive, Santa Ana, US 714 541 3333.
(b)Addressed to: Royce Michael, 44 Rutherford Street, Woolston, Christchurch 8023.
(c)Tracking number: EQ 001 711 449 US.
While in transit, a redirection for Package A had been requested through the New Zealand Post website. The requester asked to collect it from Kiwibank Post Office, Ferrymead and gave the phone number 021 0260 8929 (the 8929 redirection number).
Package A was examined and seized by Customs who found it contained 111.7 g of methamphetamine hidden within legal documents.
On 21 September 2017, Customs officers examined two further packages that had been unable to be delivered by FedEx Christchurch earlier that morning. The information written on the first (Package B) included:
(a)Sender: Chau Lee, 4384 1-2 Bancroft Street, San Diego, California 92104, US.
(b)Addressed to: Mr and Mrs Moore, 260 Innes Road, St Albans, Christchurch. Phone number +64 947 55703.
(c)Tracking number: 787 753 937 381.
And the other (Package C) had written on it:
(a)Sender: Lu Chiu, 4540 Florida Street, Apt 9, San Diego, California 92116, US.
(b)Addressed to: Dan Moore, 219 Innes…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Wright v The Queen and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2020] NZCA 581
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The legal issues in this case were whether there was sufficient evidence to prove that the drugs were imported into New Zealand, that Mr Wright was involved in the importation, and whether the jury was unfairly influenced by the Crown's "attribution" chart. The sentence appeal argued that the starting point of nine years' imprisonment was manifestly excessive, as the importations failed.
The Court found that there was sufficient evidence to infer that the drugs were imported into New Zealand. The markings and stickers on the packages, along with the Customs Officer's evidence, supported the conclusion that the packages had arrived from overseas. The Court also found that there was sufficient evidence to prove Mr Wright's involvement in the importations. The circumstantial evidence, including the use of encrypted applications, text data, and financial transactions, pointed to Mr Wright's involvement.
Regarding the "attribution" chart, the Court found that it was an uncontroversial visual aid to help the jury understand the complex set of relationships in the case. The Court also ruled that the starting point of nine years' imprisonment was not manifestly excessive, as the jury found that all the elements of the importing charge were proved. The Court of Appeal dismissed both the appeal against conviction and the appeal against sentence.
Background
Background to the litigation
Mr Wright was convicted by Judge Garland and a jury of three charges of importing a Class A controlled drug (methamphetamine), and one charge each of possessing pipes for methamphetamine use and possessing methamphetamine. He was sentenced to nine and a half years’ imprisonment. Mr Wright appealed his conviction and sentence to the Court of Appeal of New Zealand. The appeal hearing took place on 7 October 2020 before Gilbert, Mallon and Ellis JJ.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Was there sufficient evidence to prove that the drugs were imported into New Zealand?
2. Was there sufficient evidence to prove that Mr Wright was involved with the importation of the drugs?
3. Was the use of the Crown's "attribution" chart by the jury unfair?
4. Should the starting point for Mr Wright's sentence have been reduced to reflect that the drugs were intercepted by Customs before he received them?
Held
1. There was sufficient evidence to prove that the drugs were imported into New Zealand.
2. There was sufficient evidence to prove that Mr Wright was involved with the importation of the drugs.
3. The use of the Crown's "attribution" chart by the jury was not unfair.
4. The starting point for Mr Wright's sentence should not have been reduced to reflect that the drugs were intercepted by Customs before he received them.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The Court of Appeal dismissed both the appeal against conviction and the appeal against sentence. Regarding the sufficiency of evidence to prove the importation of the drugs, the Court found that the markings and stickers on the packages, along with the Customs Officer's testimony, sufficiently supported the inference that the drugs were imported into New Zealand. The Court concluded that the Judge did not improperly express his own view on the facts and that the evidence before the jury was adequate.
In relation to Mr Wright's involvement in the importation, the Court found that the circumstantial evidence presented at trial, including the attribution charts, phone records, and financial transactions, was sufficient to prove his involvement beyond a reasonable doubt. The Court rejected the argument that the evidence could be explained innocently or that there was a "chicken and egg" problem with the propensity evidence.
Regarding the use of the Crown's "attribution" chart, the Court held that it was an uncontroversial visual aid that helped the jury understand the complex relationships between the various phones and SIM cards. The Court emphasized that both the prosecutor and the Judge made it clear to the jury that the charts were not evidence themselves and that any aspect not supported by the evidence should be disregarded.
Lastly, the Court rejected the argument that the starting point for Mr Wright's sentence should have been reduced because the drugs were intercepted by Customs. The Court found that the importation was complete when the drugs were seized by Customs and that it would be inappropriate to reduce the sentence based on the successful intervention of authorities. The Court distinguished the case from the Zhang decision, where the importation was not complete, and held that there was no failed importation in this case.