Working Concepts Limited v Carlos Concepts Limited (in liquidation)

Link copied
Case Copied 18 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND WELLINGTON REGISTRY

CIV-2013-485-7306 [2013] NZHC 3061

UNDER  Section 290 of the Companies Act 1993

BETWEEN  WORKING CONCEPTS LIMITED Applicant

ANDCARLOS CONCEPTS LIMITED (IN LIQUIDATION)

Respondent

Hearing:                   27 November 2013

Appearances:           S M O'Sullivan for Applicant

G J Toebes for Respondent

Judgment:                27 November 2013

ORAL JUDGMENT OF ASSOCIATE JUDGE BELL

Solicitors:          DLA Phillips Fox (S M O’Sullivan/E Coburn) Wellington, for Applicant

JT Law (Justin Toebes) Wellington, for Respondent

WORKING CONCEPTS LIMITED v CARLOS CONCEPTS LIMITED (IN LIQ) [2013] NZHC 3061 [27 September 2013]

[1]      Working Concepts Ltd has applied under s 290 of the Companies Act 1993 to set  aside  two  statutory  demands  served  on  it  by  Carlos  Concepts  Ltd  (In Liquidation).  In both cases Working Concepts Ltd says that the debts in the demands are the subject of genuine and substantial disputes.

[2]      The first statutory demand is for $20,979.00 said to be “the amount recorded as due to the creditor in the financial statements to 31 March 2009”.  The second demand, for $38,579, is said to be “the increase in the debit balance of the current account due to the creditor as a result of an erroneous transaction crediting the debtor’s current account”.

[3]      If a statutory demand is allowed to stand, then non-compliance with the statutory demand gives rise to a presumption that the company served with the demand is insolvent.   That presumption of insolvency can then be used in a later application for the company to be put into liquidation on the grounds that it is unable to pay its debts.   If a company genuinely disputes its liability to the debt in the demand, it would not be just to allow the presumption of insolvency to arise. Accordingly under s 290(4)(a) of the Companies Act, the statutory demand may be set aside if the debt is subject to a substantial dispute.

[4]      In Link Electro Systems Ltd v GPC Electronics (NZ) Ltd1 the Court of Appeal set out well-established principles for applications under s 290(4)(a).  The company is required to show that:

there is arguably a genuine and substantial dispute as to the existence of a debt;

the mere assertion of a dispute is not sufficient.   Some material – short of proof – is required to support the claim that the debt is in dispute;

if such material is available, the dispute should normally be resolved other than by means of proceeding by way of statutory demand;

1      Link Electro Systems Ltd v GPC Electronics (NZ) Ltd [2007] NZCA 501, (2007) 18 PRNZ 946 at [17].

it  is  routinely  difficult  to  resolve  disputed  questions  of  fact  on affidavit evidence alone – more obviously so when issues of credibility arise; and

it needs to be kept in mind throughout, that the task for the judge is not to resolve the actual dispute, but to determine whether there is a substantial dispute whether or not the debt is due.

[5]      As that case shows, the court may be…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Working Concepts Limited v Carlos Concepts Limited (in liqui... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2013] NZHC 3061
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Working Concepts Limited sought to set aside two statutory demands issued by Carlos Concepts Limited (in liquidation) under section 290 of the Companies Act 1993. The first demand was for $20,979, and the second for $38,579. The basis of the first demand was the amount recorded as due to the creditor in the financial statements to 31 March 2009, and the second was the increase in the debit balance of the current account due to an erroneous transaction crediting the debtor's current account. Associate Judge R M Bell found that while there was arguably a genuine and substantial dispute as to the existence of the debt in the second statutory demand, there was no such dispute as to the existence of the debt in the first statutory demand. The Judge found that the $20,979 in the first statutory demand represented the balance of indebtedness between the two companies, and that Working Concepts Limited had not raised a substantial dispute as to its liability for that sum. The Judge held that the demand for $38,579 should be set aside and that any adjustment on account of that sum ought to be the subject of a separate proceeding as liability was subject to a genuine and substantial dispute. The Judge made an order that the statutory demand for $20,979 was upheld, and the statutory demand for $38,579 was set aside. Working Concepts Limited was ordered to pay Carlos Concepts Limited (in liquidation) the sum of $20,979 less the order for costs made in a previous setting-aside application. No order for costs was made on this application.