Woolley v Fonterra Co-Operative Group Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 9 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND BLENHEIM REGISTRY

I TE KŌTI MATUA O AOTEAROA TE WAIHARAKEKE ROHE

CIV-2018-406-000014

[2019] NZHC 86

BETWEEN

PHILIP JOHN WOOLLEY

Plaintiff

AND

FONTERRA CO-OPERATIVE GROUP LIMITED

Defendant

Hearing: 28 November 2018 (Judgment: 17 December 2018)

Appearances:

H Rennie QC and M A Robertson for Plaintiff M D Branch and K F Shaw for Defendant

Judgment:

5 February 2019


COSTS JUDGMENT OF ASSOCIATE JUDGE MATTHEWS


[1]    On 17 December 2018, the Court issued a judgment dismissing the defendant’s application for summary judgment against the plaintiff. Costs were reserved. Memoranda have now been received.

[2]    Mr Woolley seeks costs, payable now. He seeks costs on a 2B basis up until 20 July 2018, and on an indemnity basis for steps taken after that date. The reason for this is that on that date Mr Woolley through his solicitors sent an email to the solicitors for Fonterra in which they advised that in their view the application for summary judgment could not succeed and that if Fonterra continued with the application and failed, Mr Woolley would seek an order for solicitor and client costs. On the other hand, if the application were withdrawn then, it would seek costs on scale.

[3]    Mr Rennie for Mr Woolley says that as Fonterra has failed, it should pay costs notwithstanding the ordinary rule that on a plaintiff’s application for summary

WOOLLEY v FONTERRA CO-OPERATIVE GROUP LTD [2019] NZHC 86 [5 February 2019]

judgment costs should generally be reserved.1 Mr Rennie notes that in other cases of applications for summary judgments by defendants it has been recognised that it may be appropriate to award costs at the time. He submits that the application could not have succeeded, and this was clearly articulated in the notice of opposition.

[4]    For Fonterra, Mr Branch says that Fonterra’s application for summary judgment failed on the basis of an implied term found by the Court to be arguable, and thus the plaintiff has had an indulgence, in that no implied term is in fact pleaded. He says that the email relied on by Mr Rennie does not constitute a Calderbank offer, so the principles relating to Calderbank offers do not apply. He does acknowledge, however, that where a defendant applies for summary judgment the principle that costs are normally reserved is not applied, as in the case of applications by plaintiffs. Nonetheless, he says the Court may take into account whether or not it is premature to resolve the issue of costs in the particular circumstances of the case. He notes, however, that where the courts find that a defendant is able to assess the strength of the case before making an application for summary judgment costs are normally awarded against the unsuccessful defendant.2

[5]    Mr Branch says, accurately, that the issue before the Court was essentially what was required before the suspension of Mr Woolley’s supply contract had to be lifted, “and that was found to be an implied term of reasonableness”. He says…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Woolley v Fonterra Co-Operative Group Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2019] NZHC 86
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Woolley v Fonterra Co-Operative Group Limited was heard in the High Court of New Zealand, Blenheim Registry. The plaintiff, Mr Woolley, sought costs from the defendant, Fonterra Co-Operative Group Limited, following the dismissal of Fonterra's application for summary judgment. The legal issues before the court were whether costs should be ordered immediately and if so, the quantum of costs to be awarded. The court found that it was appropriate to award costs against Fonterra for its unsuccessful application for summary judgment. The court determined that Fonterra had failed to adequately assess the strength of its application before filing it, and again after receiving the notice of opposition from Mr Woolley. The court found that it was strongly arguable that the application for summary judgment should not have been brought in the first place.

The court awarded costs on a 2C basis for the period up to 20 July 2018, and indemnity costs for the period after that date. The court found that Fonterra acted unnecessarily in bringing the application, as it should have been clear that scrutiny of the relevant facts at trial would be necessary in order for a court to achieve a just result. The court awarded indemnity costs for the period after 20 July 2018, which included the fees of senior counsel together with the sum of $20,000 for the fees of junior counsel and instructing solicitors, and the reasonable disbursements claimed. The total costs awarded amounted to $41,587.38.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established