Williamson and Williamson v Selwyn District Council

Link copied
Case Copied 10 min read

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF NEW ZEALAND

CA662/2007
[2008] NZCA 147

BETWEENDOUGLAS JOHN WILLIAMSON AND JOHN BLACKWOOD WILLIAMSON


Appellants/Respondents in strike out application

ANDSELWYN DISTRICT COUNCIL


Respondent/Applicant in strike out application

Hearing:19 May 2008

Court:William Young  P, Glazebrook and Baragwanath JJ

Counsel:K Foley for Applicant


D Williamson in person

Judgment:5 June 2008 at 10.00 am

JUDGMENT OF THE COURT

A        The application by Selwyn District Council is allowed.

B        The appeal is struck out.

CCosts of $1,200 plus usual disbursements are to be paid to Selwyn District Council by the Williamsons.

____________________________________________________________________

REASONS OF THE COURT

(Given by Glazebrook J)

Introduction

[1]       On 9 November 2007, Associate Judge Christiansen gave summary judgment in favour of the Selwyn District Council to enforce the provisions of a lease entered into between the Council and the Williamson brothers.  The Williamsons have appealed against that decision.  The Council applies to strike out the Williamsons’ appeal pursuant to r 37(1) of the Court of Appeal (Civil) Rules 2005, which provides that the Court may make an order striking out an appeal if security for costs is not paid by the due date.

[2]       In this case, the appeal was filed on 7 December 2007 and the Court set security for costs at $4,740.  This should have been paid 20 working days after the notice of appeal was filed in the Registry, namely by 28 January 2008.  Security was not paid at that date.  At the time of the hearing of the Council’s application, security remained unpaid.  The Williamsons have since offered to pay part of the security for costs and have indicated that they should be able to pay the rest shortly.  The Council, however, maintains its strike out application.

Background

[3]       The lease, which was the subject of the summary judgment, formed part of an agreement dated 28 July 2003 for the sale and purchase of land owned by the Williamsons, on which they operated a horse training facility.  The reason for the purchase of the property was that the Williamsons were unhappy at the industrial development that the Council proposed to undertake near their property and were challenging various resource consents associated with it. 

[4]       Negotiations between the Council and the Williamsons extended over more than a year.  In the event, the Council agreed to purchase the property from the Williamsons for $800,000 plus GST.  The Williamsons were to remain on the property pursuant to a lease for three years at a cost of $1 per annum.  The Williamsons did not vacate the property when the lease came to an end.  Rather than relying on the provisions in the lease to remove the Williamsons, the Council issued proceedings to recover possession of the property.  This led to the grant of summary judgment.

The parties’ contentions

[5]       The Council’s main submission is that the appeal is entirely lacking in merit. It also points out that security had not been tendered even at the time of the hearing and there has been no proper…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Williamson and Williamson v Selwyn District Council and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2008] NZCA 147
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the Court of Appeal of New Zealand, Selwyn District Council sought to strike out the appeal brought by Douglas John Williamson and John Blackwood Williamson. The Williamson brothers had appealed against a summary judgment granted in favour of the Council, which sought to enforce the provisions of a lease entered into between the Council and the brothers. The Council applied to strike out the Williamsons’ appeal pursuant to rule 37(1) of the Court of Appeal (Civil) Rules 2005, which allows the Court to make an order striking out an appeal if security for costs is not paid by the due date. The appeal was filed on 7 December 2007, and security for costs of $4,740 was due 20 working days after the notice of appeal was filed, or by 28 January 2008. Security was not paid at that date or at the time of the hearing of the Council’s application. The Williamsons have since offered to pay part of the security for costs and have indicated that they should be able to pay the rest shortly. The Council, however, maintains its strike out application. The Williamsons argued that money owed to them by the Council should have been available by way of offset to satisfy the obligation to pay security for costs. The Court held that the money allegedly owed to the Williamsons by the Council was, however, owed only contingently. The Council has agreed to pay a sum to the Williamsons with regard to their removal expenses. If the Williamsons use a removal firm, then the Council will pay the costs to the removal firm. It is only if the Williamsons themselves remove their assets from the property personally that the Council would make a payment to the Williamsons. The Court accepted the Council’s submission that this cannot be taken into account. There is an obligation to pay security for costs by the due date. In this case, there is currently a continuing failure to meet this obligation. While there may have been some confusion on the part of the Williamsons in relation to the obligation to pay security for costs initially, it is clear that they now fully understand their obligation but have still failed to pay security. This, coupled with the failure to take further steps in furtherance of the appeal, would be enough to warrant granting the Council’s application. The payment of security is not optional. It is a requirement. The Williamsons essentially raise no new matter before the Court that was not raised before the Associate Judge. The Williamsons considered that they should not be bound by the terms of the agreement or the lease because the whole situation was “unfair” and that they should be able to buy the property back for the same price they were paid for it. The Court held that there was no evidence of any threat or pressure exerted upon the Williamsons at any stage of the negotiations and that therefore duress would not be a defence. The Court also rejected the view that there was undue influence applied. There was no evidence that the Williamsons were in a position of particular disadvantage or that the Council knew of this or exploited it. To the contrary, the Williamsons were represented by lawyers throughout who acted as strong advocates for them. The Judge noted that at the end of the negotiations, the Council paid $300,000 more for the property than its initial offer, as well as a substantial contribution to the Williamson’s legal costs. The Council also allowed the Williamsons to lease the property for three years effectively rent free. The Court held that there was no evidence of misrepresentation and that the terms of the lease were agreed following lengthy correspondence between the parties’ advisers. The Judge also rejected the contention that the Council resiled on a promise to provide a loan to facilitate the purchase of another property. The Court held that the Williamsons took what can be seen as a perfectly sensible commercial decision to drop the resource management challenges in return for being bought out of their property. The Williamsons say that Anthony Harpers had a conflict of interest because it had acted for Councillor Christensen and this means that the transaction should be set aside. The Court held that there was clear evidence of affirmation of the agreement and the lease in full knowledge of the alleged conflict. The Court held that there had also been affirmation through the Williamsons agreeing to pay rent for a period of five months beyond the lease term. If there was a conflict of interest (and the Court made no comment on this or on the Williamsons’ contention that it would have unravelled the transaction if there had been such a conflict), there was clearly waiver of that conflict for the reasons set out by the Associate Judge. The application by Selwyn District Council is allowed. The appeal is struck out. Costs of $1,200 plus usual disbursements are awarded to Selwyn District Council.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.