IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND AUCKLAND REGISTRY
CIV 2003-404-6565
BETWEENGARRY STEVE WILLIAMS HELEN WILMAR
Plaintiffs
AND ALAN VICTOR JONES
First Defendant
AND RODERICK BERNARD HARRISON
Second Defendant
CIV 2003-404-1203
AND BETWEEN MICHAEL GRIFFITH JONES
Plaintiff
AND ALAN VICTOR JONES
First Defendant
AND RODERICK BERNARD HARRISON
Second Defendant
CIV 2003-404-6569
AND BETWEEN RAYMOND JOHN CLARK AND
MERILYN JOY CLARK
Plaintiffs
AND ALAN VICTOR JONES
First Defendant
AND RODERICK BERNARD HARRISON
Second Defendant
CIV 2203-404-6577
WILLIAMS And Anor V JONES And Anor HC AK CIV 2003-404-6565 [10 February 2005]
AND BETWEEN DORIS IVY WILLIAMS
Plaintiff
AND ALAN VICTOR JONES
First Defendant
AND RODERICK BERNARD HARRISON
Second Defendant
Hearing: 10 February 2005 Appearances: P Finnigan for Plaintiff
M Black for Defendants Judgment: 10 February 2005
ORAL JUDGMENT OF PRIESTLEY J
Solicitors:
G McKay, McKay Hill, 62 Station Street, Napier
P A Craighead, Duthie Whyte, 6th flr, Duthie Whyte Building, 120 Mayoral Drive, Auckland Counsel:
M Black, Waterloo Towers, 20 Waterloo Quadrant, Auckland
P Finnigan, Level 10, Wyndham Towers, Cnr Wyndham & Albert Sts, Auckland
2
Introduction
[1] Today’s hearing embraces four proceedings. The issues they throw up are complex. Through no fault of counsel the proceedings are in a somewhat unsatisfactory state because of various sequential interlocutory applications made in recent months.
[2] The result has been that judges have made, properly and in a way which cannot possibly be criticised, a number of interlocutory orders which unfortunately overlap. What I intend to do today is make a number of orders and directions which hopefully will enable the Court and the parties to focus on essential but as yet unresolved issues.
Management of files and consolidation
[3] I recommend to the Auckland List Judge, Venning J, that at the expiration of the time period specified in this judgment and prior to the conference, these files be assigned to a judge. This will advance the proceedings in a swift and orderly fashion and without some of the difficulties to which I have just referred.
[4] Counsel agree that the allegations, the factual matrix, and the likely evidence and the legal issues thrown up by these proceedings are all identical and that it is appropriate for me to make an order consolidating all four proceedings. An order for consolidation is accordingly made.
[5] The proceedings in question are all to be consolidated with CIV 2003 404 6565 specifying G S Williams and H Wilmar as plaintiffs.
[6] The Court’s expectation would be that from henceforth, as is normal for a consolidated proceeding, only one fee is likely to be charged.
Background
[7] The plaintiffs’ Statement of Claim is basically grounded in contract. It is alleged that in 2000 the defendants, who were either acting as investment brokers or possibly as representatives of an investment broker, solicited investment monies from the plaintiffs. These investments allegedly were to yield a very high interest rate in the vicinity of 48% per annum. At the end of pleaded terms the defendants did not repay the investments,…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Williams v Jones HC Auckland CIV 2003-404-6565 and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2005] NZHC 1277
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The legal issues before the Court included whether the defendants had adequately complied with previous discovery orders, the applicability of self-incrimination privilege to certain documents, and the necessity for further discovery and interrogatories to clarify the defendants' handling of the plaintiffs' funds. The Court was tasked with ensuring that the defendants disclosed all relevant documents in an orderly and comprehensible manner, while also considering the defendants' rights under the privilege against self-incrimination. The Court needed to balance the plaintiffs' right to pursue their claims with the defendants' rights to protect themselves from incriminating themselves.
Priestley J addressed the issues by ordering the consolidation of all four proceedings to streamline the litigation process. The Court made specific orders for the defendants to provide further and better discovery, detailing categories of documents that should be disclosed, including those related to the terms of engagement, instructions given, and reports on the investments. The Court also directed the defendants to answer interrogatories regarding the transfer and ultimate destination of the plaintiffs' funds, contractual arrangements with the offshore entity, and any reports received concerning the investments. These orders aimed to fill gaps in the discovery process and ensure that the Court and the parties had a clearer understanding of the defendants' actions. The Court reserved costs pending compliance with the orders and resolution of outstanding issues during a future conference.
The Court's judgment included specific time frames for compliance with the new orders and directed a conference to address unresolved matters, including the defendants' application for a stay, the adequacy of previous compliance with discovery orders, and potential modifications to restraining orders. The Court also clarified that the restraining order could be extended to cover additional costs incurred by the defendants in complying with the new orders.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi