Westpac New Zealand Ltd v MAP & Associates Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 47 min read

For a Court ready (fee required) version please follow this link

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF NEW ZEALAND

CA193/2009
[2010] NZCA 404

BETWEENWESTPAC NEW ZEALAND LIMITED
Appellant

ANDMAP & ASSOCIATES LIMITED
Respondent

Hearing:31 March 2010

Court:Chambers, Arnold and Randerson JJ

Counsel:R B Stewart QC and M Peters for Appellant
B D Gustafson and S L Stead for Respondent

Judgment:6 September 2010 at 10.30 am 

JUDGMENT OF THE COURT

AThe appeal is allowed, to the extent that:

(a)the order of the High Court in relation to interest is modified so that interest is payable from 2 March 2008 rather than 26 February 2008; and

(b)       the order for indemnity costs is quashed. 

BIf the parties are unable to agree costs in relation to the High Court hearings, they are to be determined by that Court in light of this judgment.

C        The appellant must pay the respondent costs for a complex appeal on a band B basis and usual disbursements.  We certify for two counsel. 

Table of Contents

Para No.

Introduction  [1]
Factual background  [2]
High Court decisions  [25]
The arguments  [28]
Discussion  [34]
         Liability – principles  [35]
         Liability – this case  [48]
         Interest  [66]
         Indemnity costs  [71]
Decision       [75]

REASONS OF THE COURT

(Given by Arnold J)

Introduction

[1]       This is an appeal from two decisions of Keane J in which he found that the appellant, Westpac New Zealand Ltd (Westpac), breached its mandate as banker by declining to act on instructions from its customer, the respondent MAP & Associates Ltd (MAP), to disburse certain funds, and ordered Westpac to pay interest and costs.[1]

Factual background

[1]MAP & Associates Ltd v Westpac Banking Corporation Ltd HC Auckland CIV 2008-404-1373, 10 March 2009 and 1 May 2009.

[2]       The factual background is unusual.  In February 2006 the shareholders of a small Bolivian privately owned bank, Private Financial Fund Prodem (Prodem), gave the Chair of its Board, Fernando Gerrardo Anker Arteaga (Mr Anker),[2] a special power of attorney (POA) to investigate and effect a sale of 94 per cent of Prodem’s shares.  Under the POA, Mr Anker appointed A & L Asset Management Inc (A & L) to assist with finding a buyer and structuring any resulting transaction.  In July 2006 A & L identified a potential purchaser, namely Banco Industrial de Venezuela, CA (BIV), a Venezuelan state-owned bank.  On 8 December 2006, BIV entered into an agreement for sale and purchase of the shareholding in Prodem.

[2]Mr Anker is wrongly referred to as Mr Arteaga in some of the affidavits and in the judgments below, presumably as a result of confusion about the custom in Spanish-speaking countries of using surnames derived from the families of both parents, which Mr Anker explained in his second affidavit. 

[3]       While the search for a purchaser was underway, Mr Fine of MAP, a firm of chartered accountants in Hamilton, was approached by a South American acquaintance, Mr Lara, to see whether MAP would hold the purchase price on the transaction in escrow until…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Westpac New Zealand Ltd v MAP & Associates Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2010] NZCA 404
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This is an appeal from two decisions of Keane J in which he found that the appellant, Westpac New Zealand Ltd (Westpac), breached its mandate as banker by declining to act on instructions from its customer, the respondent MAP & Associates Ltd (MAP), to disburse certain funds, and ordered Westpac to pay interest and costs. The factual background is unusual. MAP had been asked by a firm of lawyers based in Panama, Arias & Arias Consultores, to hold funds pending the sale of shares in a Bolivian bank. In February 2006, the shareholders of the Bolivian bank had given a power of attorney to Mr Anker to investigate and effect a sale of 94 per cent of its shares. The Bolivian bank was eventually sold to a Venezuelan bank, BIV, which assigned its interest in the transaction to another Venezuelan bank, Bandes. MAP received funds from BIV via Westpac and held them on trust pending their disbursement to the Bolivian shareholders of the Bolivian bank. MAP provided Westpac with instructions for the disbursement of the funds on 26 February 2008. However, Westpac refused to disburse the funds because it had concerns about the transaction and the identity of the recipients. The parties disagreed as to whether the position was to be assessed solely as at the end of February 2008 or whether the events of March 2008, in particular the request to pay the funds to BIV, may be taken into consideration. The Court found that Westpac should have acted on its instructions when it was provided with a copy of Mr Anker’s 29 February letter on 2 March 2008. At that stage, the Court did not consider that Westpac would have been dishonest had it paid out. It certainly did not know of circumstances that in fact constituted a breach of trust. So the question was whether the circumstances were among “those relatively rare circumstances” where it would have been dishonest for Westpac to have followed MAP’s instructions without making further inquiry. In the light of the evidence, the Court concluded that Westpac should have disbursed the funds on 2 March 2008 when it received a copy of Mr Anker’s letter of 29 February 2008. Westpac’s concern seems not to have been with its customer, MAP, whose integrity it had no reason to doubt, but with the overall nature of the transaction. Westpac’s concerns were undoubtedly heightened as a result of the conflicting messages it received from the New York and Caracas offices of BIV in February 2008. However, Westpac should not have been communicating with those offices at that time. MAP was its customer and Westpac knew that BIV had been replaced as purchaser by Bandes. The Court concluded that Westpac had breached its mandate. The Court considered that the Judge was entitled to award interest in the way that he did, subject only to the fact that, consistently with the Court’s judgment on liability, interest should have been awarded from 2 March 2008 rather than 26 February 2008. Accordingly, the Court modified the Judge’s order as to interest to that extent only. The Court did not consider that Westpac’s conduct in the course of the litigation could properly be characterised as flagrant misconduct. Accordingly, the Court quashed the order for indemnity costs in the High Court. If the parties were unable to agree costs, they were to be determined by the High Court in the light of this judgment.

Background

Background to the litigation

In February 2006, the shareholders of a Bolivian bank, Private Financial Fund Prodem (Prodem), appointed a special power of attorney to investigate and effect a sale of their shares. In July 2006, a potential purchaser, Banco Industrial de Venezuela, CA (BIV), was identified. On 8 December 2006, BIV entered into an agreement for the sale and purchase of the Prodem shareholding. In May 2006, a New Zealand firm, MAP & Associates Ltd (MAP), was approached to hold the purchase price in escrow until due diligence was completed and the sale finalised. MAP agreed to act as the deposit agent, and in May 2006, it asked Westpac New Zealand Ltd (Westpac) to receive the funds. On 5 December 2006, MAP opened a foreign currency account with Westpac, and on 8 December 2006, an escrow agreement was entered into between A & L Asset Management Inc (A & L), MAP, and the Prodem shareholders. On 11 December 2006, MAP provided Westpac with sealed instructions to disburse the funds upon receiving authority from MAP. Between 13 and 23 December 2006, Westpac received three deposits totaling US$49,339,953.36 from J P Morgan Chase Bank New York. Westpac credited these deposits to MAP's account and informed MAP accordingly. However, Westpac did not receive instructions to disburse the funds until 26 February 2008. In February 2007, Westpac's Compliance Department received a notice alerting the banking community to large payments being made from Bolivia and the need to treat these with caution. Westpac informed MAP of this, who said they would advise MAP's client but were satisfied that everything was above board. In February 2008, Westpac became concerned about the transaction as a result of the conflicting communications it received from BIV, one of which was that the transaction had been cancelled and the money should not be paid out. On 26 February 2008, MAP provided signed telegraphic transfer forms to Westpac to enable the disbursement of funds to Prodem's shareholders. However, Westpac did not consider the material provided gave greater clarity to the situation and was not willing to disburse the funds. MAP filed an originating application in the High Court seeking an order that Westpac carry out its instructions to release the funds and any accumulated interest without delay. On 2 March 2008, MAP provided Westpac with a letter from Mr Anker, who held a power of attorney from the Prodem shareholders, confirming that the transfer instructions were in accordance with the wishes of the shareholders.

The matter came before the Court of Appeal of New Zealand as an appeal from two decisions of Keane J in the High Court. The High Court found that Westpac breached its mandate as a banker by declining to act on instructions from its customer, MAP, to disburse certain funds, and ordered Westpac to pay interest and costs. Westpac appealed the High Court's decisions, and the appeal was heard on 31 March 2010.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Did Westpac breach its mandate as a banker by declining to act on instructions from its customer, MAP, to disburse certain funds?
2. Should interest be awarded under s 87(1) of the Judicature Act from 26 February 2008 to the date of payment, less interest already paid on the funds over that period?
3. Should indemnity costs be awarded against Westpac under r 48C(4)(a) of the High Court Rules?

Held
1. The Court of Appeal found that Westpac breached its mandate as a banker by declining to act on instructions from its customer, MAP, to disburse certain funds.
2. The Court of Appeal modified the interest award to run from 2 March 2008, rather than 26 February 2008.
3. The Court of Appeal quashed the order for indemnity costs against Westpac.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Court of Appeal held that Westpac breached its mandate as a banker when it declined to disburse the funds in accordance with MAP's instructions. The Court noted that while Westpac had concerns about the transaction, it did not have proper grounds to refuse to accept Mr Anker's authority to act. The Court emphasized the importance of banks honouring their mandates and found that Westpac should have disbursed the funds when it received a copy of Mr Anker's letter on 2 March 2008. The Court modified the interest award to run from 2 March 2008 instead of 26 February 2008, consistent with its judgment on liability. Finally, the Court quashed the order for indemnity costs, finding that Westpac's conduct in the course of the litigation did not amount to flagrant misconduct. The ratio decidendi of this case is that a bank may be liable for dishonest assistance if it has actual knowledge of the circumstances of the transaction such as to render its participation contrary to normally acceptable standards of honest conduct, and a bank may be liable even though it does not have actual knowledge but has a well grounded suspicion about the circumstances, in which case it may be required to make further inquiry. In this case, the Court found that Westpac should have acted on its instructions when it received a copy of Mr Anker's 29 February letter on 2 March 2008, and that Westpac's refusal to disburse the funds was not justified.