Western Park Village Ltd v Baho

Link copied
Case Copied 45 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND AUCKLAND REGISTRY

CIV 2012-404-2727 [2014] NZHC 198

BETWEEN  WESTERN PARK VILLAGE LIMITED Plaintiff

ANDSINAN ABED BAHO Defendant

DARRYLL LAWRENCE HEAVEN First Counterclaim Defendant

EVELYN HEAVEN
Second Counterclaim Defendant

TRUSTEE MANAGEMENT LIMITED Third Counterclaim Defendant

Hearing:                   29, 30, 31 July , 1, 2, 3, 19 and 20 August 2013

Counsel:                  D Chesterman for Plaintiff and Counterclaim Defendants

J E M Lethbridge for Defendant/Counterclaimant

Judgment:                10 February 2014

Reasons:                  18 February 2014

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT OF HEATH J

Solicitors:

Dyer Whitechurch, PO Box 5547, Wellesley Street, Auckland
Grove Darlow & Partners, PO Box 2882, Auckland

Counsel:

D Chesterman, Bankside Chambers, Level 22, 88 Shortland Street , Auckland

WESTERN PARK VILLAGE LIMITED v BAHO [2014] NZHC 198 [18 February 2014]

Contents

Outcome  [1]

Background  [4]

The factual matrix

(a)      The rock-fall problem  [8]

(b)      The November 2005 Annual General Meeting and its aftermath      [11] (c)      The sale of Unit D to Mr Heaven  [23] (d)      The July 2007 Extraordinary General Meeting  [34] Was any misrepresentation made?  [38] Western Park’s claim

(a)      Was there an outstanding requisition? – Clause 6.1(d) of                [56]

the Agreement

(b)      The claim under s 6 of the Contractual Remedies Act 1979             [64] (c)      Quantum  [71] Counterclaim  [76] Result  [86]

Outcome

[1]      In this proceeding, Western Park Village Ltd (Western Park) sought relief against Mr Baho for alleged breaches of an agreement for sale and purchase of land entered into in May 2007.1    Mr Baho counterclaimed to recover moneys said to be owing under a mortgage given in his favour as part of the financing arrangements made for Western Park to acquire the dwelling.  The counterclaim is brought against Western Park (as mortgagor) and Mr and Mrs Heaven, and Trustee Management Ltd (as covenantors).

[2]      On 10 February 2014, I made the following orders:2

(a)       Judgment is entered in favour of Mr Baho on all of Western Park’s

claims against him.

(b)On Mr Baho’s counterclaim against Western Park and the three counterclaim defendants, judgment is entered against each in the sum of $301,698.87, together with interest at the rate of 19% per annum

from 21 December 2011 to today’s date.

1      See paras [4] and [7] below.

2      Western Park Village Ltd v Baho [2014] NZHC 102 at para [3].

(c)      Leave  to  amend  the  Statement  of  Claim  to  include  a  claim  for possession   of  the   property  at   4/30  Augustus  Terrace,   Parnell, Auckland is granted.   That aspect of the claim is adjourned for a telephone conference to be allocated by the Registrar, on the first available date after 4 April 2014.  If the judgment sum is not paid to Mr Baho by 5pm on 21 March 2014, I shall hear from counsel at the telephone conference on whether a possession order should be made.

(d)      Costs are reserved.

[3]      I indicated that my reasons for making those orders would be given in writing as soon as practicable.  My reasons follow.

Background

[4]      Mr Heaven bought a residential unit from Mr Baho…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Western Park Village Ltd v Baho and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2014] NZHC 198
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Western Park Village Ltd (Western Park) sued Mr Baho for alleged breaches of an agreement for sale and purchase of land entered into in May 2007. Mr Baho counterclaimed to recover moneys said to be owing under a mortgage given in his favour as part of the financing arrangements made for Western Park to acquire the dwelling. The counterclaim is brought against Western Park (as mortgagor) and Mr and Mrs Heaven, and Trustee Management Ltd (as covenantors). The court dismissed Western Park’s claims against Mr Baho. The court found that Mr Baho had no liability to Western Park under cl 6.1(d) of the Agreement, which related to the disclosure of requisitions. The court found that no misrepresentation was made by Mr Baho that induced Mr Heaven to enter into the agreement. The court also found that any false statement that Mr Baho may have made did not “induce” Mr Heaven to enter into the Agreement. The court found against Western Park on the basis of liability and it was unnecessary to consider questions of quantum. The court found that even if the court had found in favour of Western Park on the liability question, it would not have found any loss. The court found no diminution in value of Unit D can be established as having flowed from the rock-fall issue, even if a false representation had been made. The court found that the issue of the counterclaim fell to be determined on the basis of the terms of the agreement for sale and purchase and the mortgage themselves. The court found that the amount outstanding on the second mortgage was $301,698.87 together with interest thereon at the rate of 19% per annum from 21 December 2011 to the date of judgment. The court granted leave to amend the Statement of Claim to obtain an order for possession of the property. The court adjourned the proceeding for a conference at a time when the application could be pursued, if necessary.