IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND AUCKLAND REGISTRY
I TE KŌTI MATUA O AOTEAROA TĀMAKI MAKAURAU ROHE
CIV-2016-404-510
[2018] NZHC 1860
BETWEEN WENTWORTH RETREAT (2009)
LIMITED and MARES PROPERTIES (NZ) LIMITED
PlaintiffsAND
DELL INC
Defendant
GRAYS AUCTIONS LIMITED
Third Party
Hearing: 25 July 2018 Appearances:
V Wethey for Plaintiffs W R Potter for Defendant
K Burkhart for Third Party
Judgment:
25 July 2018
(ORAL) JUDGMENT OF LANG J
[as to discovery issues]
WENTWORTH RETREAT (2009) LTD v DELL INC [2018] NZHC 1860 [25 July 2018]
[1] This proceeding relates to a claim for damages arising out of a fire that occurred in a lodge in a rural area outside Whangamata. The plaintiffs claim the fire was caused by batteries in a computer manufactured by the defendant and situated in the property. The defendant denies this is the case. The defendant’s briefs of evidence allege the fire began in another room of the address and was not caused by the computer.
[2] An issue has arisen in relation to the discovery provided by the defendant. In the latest version of its affidavit of documents the defendant has included the following information under Part 2, the section relating to documents for which the defendant claims privilege:
Correspondence by Meredith Connell and third parties for the purpose of the
proceeding.
Various Various Section 56
[3] The plaintiffs argue they are entitled to know the identity of the third parties referred to in the passage set out above. They say they are entitled to that information so they can either challenge the claim to privilege or make their own enquiries with the third parties. The plaintiffs believe the third parties may be able to provide information helpful to the plaintiffs’ case.
[4] The defendant resists listing the names of the third parties because it says the claim to privilege is irrefutable.
Decision
[5] It is surprising that this issue has not been the subject of more authority. The only authority the parties have been able to find on the point is the decision of Associate Judge Bell in Guttenbeil v Tower Insurance Ltd.1 In that case a similar situation arose. The Associate Judge held that the identity of witnesses interviewed by the defendants’ investigators was not to be disclosed. His reasoning was as follows:
[24] The plaintiffs object that the defendants have not adequately described statements obtained from witnesses. The plaintiffs seek identification of all potential witnesses interviewed by the defendants' investigators. The defendants claim privilege for witness statements. I uphold that claim for reasons given later. As litigation privilege attaches to those statements, the defendants are not required to disclose the identity of witnesses. The plaintiffs cannot overcome that by insisting on more detailed descriptions which would identify the witnesses.
[6] I propose to adopt the same approach. I see no basis on which litigation privilege in relation to these documents could successfully be challenged. Furthermore, the only use to…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Wentworth Retreat (2009) Limited v Dell Inc and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2018] NZHC 1860
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The central issue before the court was whether the plaintiffs were entitled to know the identity of the third parties mentioned in the defendant's affidavit of documents. The court referred to the decision in Guttenbeil v Tower Insurance Ltd, where a similar situation arose, and the Associate Judge held that the identity of witnesses interviewed by the defendants' investigators was not to be disclosed. The court adopted the same approach, stating that litigation privilege attaches to those statements, and the defendants are not required to disclose the identity of witnesses. The plaintiffs could not overcome this by insisting on more detailed descriptions which would identify the witnesses.
The court declined to require the defendant to list the names of potential witnesses as sought by the plaintiff, as it would be unfortunate if the pending trial was derailed by further enquiries made by the plaintiffs as a result of information provided by the defendant. The court considered that the time for such enquiries had long passed, and the only remaining step was the service of reply briefs. The defendant sought costs in relation to the appearance, but the court decided not to make an order for costs due to the extent to which counsel had been able to reach agreement.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi