Wellington City Council v Dallas

Link copied
Case Copied 31 min read

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF NEW ZEALAND

CA148/2014
[2014] NZCA 631

BETWEEN

WELLINGTON CITY COUNCIL
Appellant

AND

COLIN JAMES DALLAS
Respondent

Hearing:

8 September 2014

Court:

French Winkelmann and Asher JJ

Counsel:

D J Heaney QC and A K Hough for Appellant
D A Laurenson QC and J D Haig for Respondent

Judgment:

19 December 2014 at 10.00 am

INTERIM JUDGMENT OF THE COURT

A        The appeal is allowed to the extent described in [59] of this judgment.

BThe parties are to provide further submissions regarding the issue of apportionment, in accordance with [57]–[58] of this judgment.

____________________________________________________________________

REASONS OF THE COURT

(Given by Winkelmann J)

Introduction

  1. This appeal concerns a leaky home built in the early years of the last decade by a construction company, Kingdom Residential Housing Ltd (Kingdom).  The owners of the house, the plaintiffs, sued Wellington City Council (the Council) for compensation for defects in the house’s construction.[1]  The Council in turn sued third parties involved in the construction process including Mr Colin Dallas, the former managing director of Kingdom. 

    [1]Kingdom was by that time struck off the Companies Register. 

  2. Prior to the hearing the Council settled with the owner plaintiffs, paying $670,000 and admitting negligence in inspecting and certifying the original construction.  The Council was then able to recover some of the $670,000 through settlement with other third parties, but proceeded to trial with its claim against Mr Dallas.  It sought a contribution to the balance of its outlay, which by the time of trial was $546,000.  The Council pursued claims in negligence, negligent misstatement and breach of s 9 of the Fair Trading Act 1986 against Mr Dallas.

  3. Mallon J dismissed all of the Council’s claims.[2]  The Council now appeals that judgment, limiting its appeal to the Judge’s finding in respect of the Fair Trading Act cause of action.  It says that the Judge erred in not finding Mr Dallas in breach of s 9 of the Fair Trading Act because statements made by him in a letter to the Council about work done were patently misleading and deceptive, and the Council relied on them and thereby suffered loss. 

Background facts

[2]Derwin v Wellington City Council [2014] NZHC 341 [High Court judgment]. Having settled, there was no appearance for the plaintiffs Patrick Dean Derwin and Rama Diar, or two third parties, Alchemy Engineering and Design Ltd, and Builders Plastics Ltd. This left only the Council, as defendant, and Mr Dallas as first third party, who are the two parties to this appeal.

  1. The house in question was built for Mr and Mrs Craig in 2001, and completed in early 2002.  Mr Dallas was not involved in the construction.  The Council issued an interim Code Compliance Certificate (CCC) on completion.  In January 2004 Mr Craig approached the Council to obtain a final CCC prior to sale.  Following a site inspection the Council identified a number of matters that had to be addressed before the certificate could be issued.  Mr Craig made contact with…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Wellington City Council v Dallas and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2014] NZCA 631
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This appeal concerns a leaky home constructed in the early 2000s by Kingdom Residential Housing Ltd. The owners sued the Wellington City Council (the Council) for compensation for defects in the house’s construction. The Council in turn sued third parties involved in the construction process, including Mr Colin Dallas, the former managing director of Kingdom. The Council’s appeal to the Court of Appeal of New Zealand concerns the Judge’s finding in respect of the Fair Trading Act 1986 cause of action. It says that the Judge erred in not finding Mr Dallas in breach of s 9 of the Act because statements made by him in a letter to the Council about work done were patently misleading and deceptive, and the Council relied on them and thereby suffered loss. The Court of Appeal found that the trial Judge erred in finding that Mr Dallas did not breach s 9 of the Fair Trading Act. The statement made by Mr Dallas as to the kick outs was clear and unambiguous. The Council said that one of the matters it needed to be satisfied of before issuing the CCC was the installation of the kick outs. When Mr Dallas’ letter of 21 February 2005 is read together with the letter to which he responds, the Council letter of 28 September 2004, the second paragraph can only sensibly be read as a statement that the requested kick outs at the end of the apron flashings had been completed by KRH Plumbers. The Court of Appeal considered that the statement “[c]ompleted by KRH Plumber” was sufficiently detailed to be a statement that a reasonable council could rely on. It was a misstatement because the kick outs had not been completed. The Court of Appeal also found that the Council did discharge the onus upon it to prove reliance on the statement. The next issue that arises is whether Mr Dallas’ misstatement as to the completion of the kick outs was the effective cause of the loss, or rather simply immaterial to that loss. The Council accepts that it should have checked the kick outs for itself, that it was careless in not doing so, and that accordingly it should bear part of the loss. However it says that it was reasonable for the Council to rely upon Mr Dallas’ letter and seeks to be awarded 50 per cent of its loss, namely $273,000. It says reliance was reasonable because: (a) councils exercise regulatory oversight, not a clerk of works-type role; (b) the Council performed 18 individual building inspections for this dwelling, and was entitled to make its assessment as to code compliance by reference to those inspections and Mr Dallas’ statements; (c) there was evidence of reliance by the Council and expert evidence that it was reasonable to place some reliance on Mr Dallas’ statements; and (d) the fact the Council admitted negligence when inspecting is not a bar to the Fair Trading Act claim. The Court of Appeal found that doing justice between the parties required some contribution from Mr Dallas to the loss suffered by the Council. The appeal is allowed to the extent that the Court of Appeal is satisfied that Mr Dallas’ conduct did breach s 9 of the Fair Trading Act and that the Judge erred in finding that it did not. The parties are to provide further submissions regarding the issue of apportionment.

Background

Background to the litigation

A house was built in Wellington by Kingdom Residential Housing Ltd (Kingdom) for Mr and Mrs Craig in 2001 and completed in early 2002. Mr Dallas was not involved in the construction of the house. The Wellington City Council issued an interim Code Compliance Certificate (CCC) upon completion of the construction. Mr Dallas was the managing director of Kingdom at the time. In January 2004, Mr Craig approached the Council for a final CCC prior to sale of the house. The Council identified several issues that needed to be resolved before it could issue the certificate. Work was carried out by Kingdom to address these issues. The Council inspected the site again in September 2004. Mr Dallas was present at this inspection. On 28 September 2004, the Council wrote to Mr Craig listing further items that required remedial work and documentation to be completed to the Council's satisfaction. Mr Craig contacted Mr Dallas for help in resolving these outstanding issues. Mr Dallas contacted contractors, suppliers, and manufacturers to request producer statements and followed up with his colleague, Mr Ledbury, about the leaking windows. Kingdom then sent a letter to the Council dated 21 February 2005, signed by Mr Dallas as managing director, which is the letter in which it is alleged that misleading statements were made. The Council issued a final CCC later in March 2005. The property was sold to the owner plaintiffs in July 2005. They later discovered their home was a leaky building and that there had been a number of defects in the construction methods employed. These included that the kick outs had not been installed in accordance with the Council's request. The Council sued Mr Dallas for compensation for defects in the house's construction.

The case was initially heard in the High Court of New Zealand. Mallon J dismissed all of the Council’s claims. The Council appealed this decision to the Court of Appeal of New Zealand. The appeal was heard on 8 September 2014. The Court of Appeal delivered its judgment on 19 December 2014, allowing the appeal to the extent described in [59] of the judgment. The parties were directed to provide further submissions regarding the issue of apportionment.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Did the trial Judge err in her factual findings that the 21 February letter contained no misleading statements?
2. Did the trial Judge err in her finding that Mr Dallas' conduct was not a material cause of the Council’s loss?

Held
1. The appeal is allowed to the extent that the Court is satisfied that Mr Dallas' conduct did breach s 9 of the Fair Trading Act and that the trial Judge erred in finding that it did not.
2. The parties are to provide further submissions regarding the issue of apportionment, in accordance with [57]–[58] of this judgment.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Court of Appeal held that the trial Judge erred in her finding that the 21 February letter did not contain any misleading statements, and that Mr Dallas' conduct was not a material cause of the Council’s loss. Firstly, the Court found that a reasonable person in the Council’s position would likely have been misled by the statement that the kick outs had been completed by KRH Plumber, as this statement was clear and unambiguous. The Court disagreed with the trial Judge’s finding that the Council’s reliance on the statement was unreasonable. The Court also held that the statement that the house complied with the Building Act was misleading, as a reasonable council would have understood the statement to mean that the house was weathertight and in compliance with the Building Act and Code, which was not the case.

The Court further found that the Council did rely on the misleading statement in issuing the Code Compliance Certificate, as evidenced by Mr Cody’s testimony that he relied on Mr Dallas' assurances. The Court held that Mr Dallas’ misstatement as to the completion of the kick outs was an effective cause of the loss, and that doing justice between the parties requires some contribution from Mr Dallas to the loss suffered by the Council. The issue of apportionment, however, was not fully canvassed at the hearing and was remitted to the trial Judge for further submissions.