Wellington City Council v Aitchison

Link copied
Case Copied 16 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND WELLINGTON REGISTRY

CIV-2015-485-752 [2016] NZHC 167

BETWEEN

WELLINGTON CITY COUNCIL

Appellant

AND

PETER AITCHISON AND SYLVIA AITCHISON

Respondents

Hearing: 5 February 2016

Counsel:

K M Anderson and K E Krumdieck for Appellant
M J Slyfield for Respondents

Judgment:

16 February 2016

JUDGMENT OF ELLIS J

I direct that the delivery time of this judgment is

9.30 am on the 16th day of February 2016

WELLINGTON CITY COUNCIL v AITCHISON [2016] NZHC 167 [16 February 2016]

[1]      Mr and Mrs Aitchison and Walmsley Enterprises Limited (WEL) have been embroiled  in  what  loosely  may  be  termed  a  fencing  dispute.    The  dispute  has received considerable media coverage and has been the subject of two recent Environment Court decisions.1   This judgment concerns a procedural point about the role of the Wellington City Council (the Council) in the appeal by WEL against the earlier of them.  Although technical in nature the point is of some moment to both

the Council and the Aitchisons.

Background

[2]      In 2011 WEL built a 1.8 metre high fence on the boundary between  its property in Roseneath and the property belonging to the Aitchisons.  The Aitchisons say the fence had “gross adverse effects” on their apartment.   Following failed negotiations  the Aitchisons  issued  proceedings  under  the  Fencing Act  1978  but before these went to trial WEL removed the fence.

[3]      But in 2014 WEL built another structure on the same boundary which was termed a “children’s play facility”.  The structure was large and, at least from the Aitchisons’ side, very ugly.  It completely obscured what had previously been their commanding views over Wellington harbour.   The fort had been built without a resource consent and on a non-notified basis because the Council was of the view that it complied with the rules about building recession planes in the District Plan.

[4]      The Aitchisons applied to the Environment Court for declarations about the proper interpretation of the relevant part of the District Plan.  They contended that the Plan did not permit the structure which had been erected by WEL.  The Council was  named  as  the  first  respondent  and  took  an  active  role  in  opposing  the declarations sought.  WEL was named as an “interested party”.  Mr David Walmsley appeared in person on his company’s behalf.

[5]      On 17 September 2015 the Environment Court issued a decision granting the declarations sought by the Aitchisons.2   On 8 October 2015 WEL filed an appeal in

1      Those decisions will be discussed later in this judgment.

2      Aitchison v Wellington City Council [2015] NZEnvC 163.

this Court in accordance with pt 11 of the Resource Management Act 1991 (the

RMA).3  A chronology of what then occurred is as follows: (a)          on 21 October 2015 the Aitchisons filed:

(i)a notice of intention to appear and be heard on the appeal under s 301 of the RMA;

(ii)      an application to strike out WEL’s appeal;

(b)on the same day the Council also filed a notice of intention to appear and be heard on…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Wellington City Council v Aitchison and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2016] NZHC 167
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Wellington City Council v Aitchison involved a long-running dispute over the construction of a fence and subsequent play facility by Walmsley Enterprises Limited (WEL) on the boundary of its property with that of Mr. and Mrs. Aitchison. The Aitchisons had initially taken legal action under the Fencing Act 1978, but the matter evolved into a more complex issue concerning the interpretation of the District Plan and the Resource Management Act 1991. The Wellington City Council, as the respondent in the Environment Court proceedings and an active participant in the appeal process, sought to continue its appeal after WEL discontinued theirs, raising questions about the Council's standing and the procedural implications of such a move.

The court had to determine whether the Wellington City Council could proceed with its appeal after Walmsley Enterprises Limited abandoned theirs, and if the Aitchisons were required to participate in the Council's appeal. The central legal issue was whether the Council's filing of a notice under s 305 of the RMA constituted an independent appeal, akin to a cross-appeal, and if so, whether it could continue despite the discontinuance of the original appeal by WEL.

The court concluded that the filing of a notice under s 305 did indeed signify the Council's intention to take an independent position, similar to a cross-appeal. This was supported by the language used, the circumstances of the filing, and the statutory incorporation of certain rules. Even though the requirement to specify relief was not included in s 305, the court found that this omission did not preclude the Council from having substantive and independent standing in the appeal. The court further held that the Aitchisons' earlier reliance on the Council's potential passive role did not disadvantage them legally, and the Council's legitimate interest in the matter justified allowing the appeal to continue. The court vacated the scheduled hearing date, giving the Aitchisons time to decide whether to participate and allowing for potential amicus representation.

The court's decision allowed the Wellington City Council to proceed with its appeal, independent of the discontinued appeal by Walmsley Enterprises Limited. The Aitchisons were given the option to participate in the Council's appeal, and the hearing date was vacated to accommodate these developments. The court's ruling preserved the Council's right to seek clarification on the interpretation of the District Plan, balancing the interests of all parties involved.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.