Waters v Perry Foundation

Link copied
Case Copied 21 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND HAMILTON REGISTRY

CIV-2011-419-1790 [2013] NZHC 576

BETWEEN  PHILLIPA MARY WATERS Plaintiff

ANDPERRY FOUNDATION Defendant

CIV-2011-419-1791

BETWEEN  VALERIE JOYCE HELM Plaintiff

ANDPERRY FOUNDATION Defendant

Hearing:         12 February 2013

Counsel:         CT Gudsell QC for defendant

EJ Hudson for plaintiffs

Judgment:      25 March 2013

JUDGMENT OF ASSOCIATE JUDGE FAIRE [on application for stay of proceeding]

This judgment was delivered by me on 25 March 2013 at 3:30pm pursuant to Rule 11.5 of the High Court Rules.

Registrar/Deputy Registrar

Date……………

Solicitors:           McBreens, PO Box 1542, Hamilton 3240

Ellis Tanner, PO Box 19 144, Hamilton

WATERS V PERRY FOUNDATION HC HAM CIV-2011-419-1790 [25 March 2013]

CONTENTS

Introduction .............................................................................................................. 3

Background .............................................................................................................. 3

The grounds in support of the applications .............................................................. 4

The grounds advanced in opposition to the applications ......................................... 4

The court’s jurisdiction to stay or dismiss proceedings ........................................... 5

Introduction

[1]      The  defendant  in  both  proceedings  is  a  charitable  trust  that  operates  a retirement village called Perrinpark at Te Kowhai on the outskirts of Hamilton City.

[2]      The plaintiffs in both proceedings are acting in a representative capacity on behalf of two former Perrinpark residents, namely Mrs Jean Waters (now deceased) and Mrs Hilda Murray.

[3]      The  applications  that  I  am  required  to  resolve  are,  for  all  intents  and purposes, identical for each proceeding.

[4]      Following the filing and service of an appearance in which the defendant stated its objection to this Court’s jurisdiction to hear and determine the proceedings, the defendant filed, pursuant to r 5.49(3), an application to the Court to dismiss both proceedings on that ground.

Background

[5]      Mrs Waters and Mrs Murray both owned units at Perrinpark.  The units are respectively referred to as being 21 and 32 Kingfisher Way respectively.

[6]      Both plaintiffs occupied the sites on which their units were located. They had access to certain common areas pursuant to site agreements that they had entered into with the defendant.  The site agreements contained dispute resolution clauses. They are identical in the case of each of the plaintiffs.

[7]      Mrs Waters died in December 2008.  Mrs Murray ceased occupancy of her unit in August 2010.  The defendant sold both units, including the land, to third party purchasers.    The  sale  was  undertaken  pursuant  to  the  powers  reserved  to  the defendant under clause 7 of the site agreements.   There is no dispute as to the defendant’s right to sell.   The substantive dispute concerns an accounting for the proceeds of the sale of the two units.

[8]      The agreements for sale and purchase covered the sale of both the units and the land on which the units were located.   Neither plaintiff had taken up the opportunity to purchase the land on which their units were located.  A number of other Perrinpark residents did take up that option.

[9]      The plaintiffs claim to be entitled to the sale proceeds of both the unit and the land on which the unit is situated subject to certain specific deductions.   The defendant’s position is that the plaintiffs…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Waters v Perry Foundation and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2013] NZHC 576
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Waters v Perry Foundation involved two former residents of the defendant's retirement village, Perrinpark, who sought declarations and orders regarding their entitlements to the sale proceeds of their units, along with general damages. The defendant, a charitable trust, relied on the terms of the site agreements to argue that the dispute should be dealt with under the dispute resolution procedure set out in clause 9.3 of the site agreements or, alternatively, under Part 4 of the Retirement Villages Act 2003, and that the plaintiffs' commencement of proceedings in the High Court was therefore an abuse of process. The plaintiffs opposed the applications, arguing that the Securities Act (Retirement Villages) Exemption Notice 1999 expired on 31 January 2008, precluding a reference of this dispute in accordance with the terms of clause 9.3 of the site agreements. The court found that the dispute resolution procedure set out in clause 9.3 of the site agreement applied, and that the parties had contractually bound themselves to an alternative means of resolving their dispute. The court held that to allow the proceedings to continue would be an abuse of the process of the court. The two proceedings were therefore stayed, and the plaintiffs were ordered to pay costs based on 2B together with disbursements as fixed by the Registrar.