Warahi v Department of Corrections

Link copied
Case Copied 4 min read

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF NEW ZEALAND

I TE KŌTI PĪRA O AOTEAROA

 CA651/2020
 [2020] NZCA 587

BETWEEN

MAUI WARAHI
Appellant

AND

DEPARTMENT OF CORRECTIONS
Respondent

Hearing:

19 November 2020

Court:

Miller, Clifford and Collins JJ

Counsel:

Appellant in person
V McCall for Respondent

Judgment:

23 November 2020 at 4.00 pm

JUDGMENT OF THE COURT

The appeal is dismissed.

____________________________________________________________________

REASONS OF THE COURT

(Given by Clifford J)

  1. The appellant, Maui Warahi, also known — amongst other names — as Jay Maui Wallace, appeals the refusal by Muir J on 4 November 2020 to grant him a writ of habeas corpus.[1]

  2. Using the name Maui Warahi the appellant says he is not the person Jay Maui Wallace and, moreover, that Maui Warahi is not subject to the laws of New Zealand, pursuant to which he is currently remanded in custody on various charges.  Accordingly, contrary to the Judge’s decision, that detention is unlawful, entitling him to a writ of habeas corpus.

  3. The appellant acknowledges that at birth he was given the name, and was subsequently known as, Jay Maui Wallace.  But, he says, he subsequently disclaimed that name.  Materials he filed for the purposes of this appeal included a copy of a document entitled “Certified Copy of birth entry in the Māori Chief Registrar Office”, recording the birth of “Maui Warahi” on 16 December 1974.  Others comprise standard forms of a statutory declaration, an affidavit of identity, and a declaration of rights, all premised on the assertion that the holder is Māori and not subject to the laws of New Zealand which authorise the appellant’s detention.

  4. The respondent, the Chief Executive, has placed before the Court a copy of a warrant to detain Jay Maui Wallace on charges of breach of conditions of intensive supervision, assaulting a person, obtaining by deception and failing to answer District Court bail dated 28 October 2020.  That warrant is directed to every Constable and to the Manager of the Mt Eden Corrections Facility and authorises Jay Maui Wallace’s detention until Wednesday 2 December, when he is to be presented to the Manukau District Court at 11.45 am.

  5. Mr Warahi’s challenge to the prima facie authorisation of his detention that warrant provides is based on propositions of identity, jurisdiction and sovereignty that he has, under a number of names, advanced on many occasions before.[2] 

    [2]See, for example, Warahiv Chief Executive of the Department of Corrections [2020] NZHC 585 (where the appellant gave his name as “Maui Warahi (TM) beneficiary, sole flesh n Blood of Jay Wallace, Natural Person”); Wallace v Chief Executive of the Department of Corrections [2016] NZCA 602 (“Abdullah Maui Warahi”); and Wallace v Ministry of Justice [2011] NZCA 678 (“Hei Rangatira J Maui Wallace”).

  6. As to the specific issue of identity, in December 2016 this Court observed:[3]

    [9]       We note in particular that there is no issue about the appellant’s identity.  He admits that the name Jay Wallace was given…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Warahi v Department of Corrections and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2020] NZCA 587
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the New Zealand Court of Appeal, the appellant, Maui Warahi (also known as Jay Maui Wallace), challenged the decision of Muir J to refuse him a writ of habeas corpus. Warahi argued that he was not the person Jay Maui Wallace and, further, that Maui Warahi was not subject to New Zealand's laws, which were the basis for his remand in custody on various charges. The Court of Appeal was required to determine if Warahi's detention was lawful and if the lower court's decision to deny him a writ of habeas corpus was correct. The Court of Appeal found that Warahi's challenge to his detention was based on propositions of identity, jurisdiction, and sovereignty that had been previously advanced and rejected in earlier cases. The Court held that there was no issue about Warahi's identity, as he admitted to being known as Jay Wallace at birth and that Jay Maui Wallace and Abdullah Maui Warahi were the same person. The Court also found that Warahi's arguments challenging the jurisdiction of the Courts over him on Maori sovereignty grounds and asserting that he was himself sovereign and beyond the jurisdiction of the Courts were without merit. The Court of Appeal dismissed Warahi's appeal and upheld the lower court's decision to deny him a writ of habeas corpus. The Court held that nothing in Warahi's application called into question the legality of his detention. The Court of Appeal found that Warahi's detention was lawful, and the lower court's decision was correct. The appeal was dismissed, and Warahi's detention remained lawful.

Background

Background to the litigation

The appellant, Maui Warahi, also known as Jay Maui Wallace, appeals against the refusal by Muir J to grant him a writ of habeas corpus. Maui Warahi asserts that he is not the person Jay Maui Wallace and claims that Maui Warahi is not subject to the laws of New Zealand, which are the basis for his current remand in custody on various charges. Maui Warahi argues that his detention is unlawful, thereby entitling him to a writ of habeas corpus. Maui Warahi acknowledges that at birth he was given the name Jay Maui Wallace but claims to have disclaimed that name. He submitted various documents to support his appeal, including a certified copy of a birth entry in the Māori Chief Registrar Office, a statutory declaration, an affidavit of identity, and a declaration of rights. The respondent, the Department of Corrections, provided a warrant for the detention of Jay Maui Wallace on charges including breach of conditions of intensive supervision, assaulting a person, obtaining by deception, and failing to answer District Court bail. The warrant authorises Jay Maui Wallace's detention until he is presented to the Manukau District Court.

The appeal was heard by the Court of Appeal of New Zealand on 19 November 2020, with Miller, Clifford, and Collins JJ delivering the judgment on 23 November 2020. The appeal arises from the refusal by Muir J on 4 November 2020 to grant Maui Warahi a writ of habeas corpus. The appellant appeared in person while the respondent was represented by V McCall. This case follows multiple previous instances where Maui Warahi, under various names, has unsuccessfully challenged his detention on grounds of identity, jurisdiction, and sovereignty.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Does Maui Warahi have standing to challenge his detention as Jay Maui Wallace?
2. Can Maui Warahi claim that he is not subject to the laws of New Zealand?
3. Is there any merit to Maui Warahi's assertion that his detention is unlawful based on the grounds of identity, jurisdiction, and sovereignty?

Held
1. Maui Warahi does not have standing to challenge his detention as Jay Maui Wallace.
2. Maui Warahi cannot claim that he is not subject to the laws of New Zealand.
3. There is no merit to Maui Warahi's assertion that his detention is unlawful based on the grounds of identity, jurisdiction, and sovereignty.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Court of Appeal dismissed Maui Warahi's appeal against the refusal to grant him a writ of habeas corpus. The Court held that Maui Warahi, also known as Jay Maui Wallace, does not have standing to challenge his detention as Jay Maui Wallace. The Court noted that Maui Warahi admits that he was given the name Jay Maui Wallace at birth, and on his own admission, Jay Maui Wallace and Abdullah Maui Warahi are one and the same person. The Court relied on its earlier observations that Maui Warahi's claims of a different identity have been rejected in previous cases.

The Court also held that Maui Warahi cannot claim that he is not subject to the laws of New Zealand. The Court dismissed Maui Warahi's arguments based on Māori sovereignty grounds, asserting that there is nothing in the documentation provided by Maui Warahi that provides any support for his claims. The Court noted that similar arguments have been rejected by this Court and the Supreme Court in earlier cases.

Finally, the Court held that there is no merit to Maui Warahi's assertion that his detention is unlawful based on the grounds of identity, jurisdiction, and sovereignty. The Court noted that Maui Warahi's claims are based on propositions that have been rejected in previous cases, and there is nothing in this application that calls into question the legality of his detention. The Court dismissed Maui Warahi's appeal against the judgment of Muir J declining his application for a writ of habeas corpus.

The ratio decidendi of this decision is that a person cannot challenge their detention by disclaiming their legal identity or by asserting that they are not subject to the laws of New Zealand on the basis of Māori sovereignty. The Court followed its earlier decisions and the Supreme Court's decision in rejecting Maui Warahi's claims.