Waller v Davies HC Auckland Civ-2003-404-6843

Link copied
Case Copied 55 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND AUCKLAND REGISTRY

CIV-2003-404-006843

UNDERthe Corporations (Investigation and Management) Act 1989

BETWEENJOHN ANTHONY WALLER AND RICHARD DALE AGNEW

Plaintiff

AND  STEPHEN JOHN DAVIES

First Defendant

ANDDAVIES & CO SOLICITORS NOMINEE COMPANY LTD

Second Defendant

(continued over page

)

Hearing:         29 and 30 November, 1, 2, 3, 17 and 20 December 2004

Appearances: Murray Tingey and James Caird for Plaintiffs

Alan Galbraith QC and John Moody for First Defendant Simon Judd for Second, Third, Fifth and Sixth Defendants Michael Black for Fourth Defendants

Michael Ring QC for Third Party Judgment:   24 March 2005


JUDGMENT OF HARRISON J


In accordance with R540(4) I direct that the Registrar endorse this judgment with the delivery time of 10 a.m. on 24 March 2005


SOLICITORS

Bell Gully (Auckland) for Plaintiffs

Paddy Orr & Co (Auckland) for First Defendant Timothy Carnachan (Auckland) for Fourth Defendants Ladbrookes (Auckland) for Second and Fifth Defendants

Kathryn Webber (Auckland) for Third and Sixth Defendants McElroys (Auckland) for Third Party

COUNSEL

AR Galbraith QC, M Ring QC, J Moody, SRG Judd, MC Black

JOHN ANTHONY WALLER AND RICHARD DALE AGNEW V STEPHEN JOHN DAVIES And Ors HC AK CIV-2003-404-006843 [24 March 2005]

ANDGEOFFREY ANDREW HITCHINGS AND TERENCE RICHARD HITCHINGS

Third Defendant

ANDDOUGLAS WALTER EDWARDS AND DENISE ANNE EDWARDS

Fourth Defendant

AND  QING SHENG SHI

Fifth Defendant

ANDNICHOLAS LOUISE WADEY AND JEREMY ALAN MILTON

Sixth Defendant

ANDQBE INSURANCE (INTERNATIONAL) LTD

Third Party

Table of Contents

Paragraph No.

Introduction  [1] – [7]

Issues  [8] – [10]

Scheme  [11] – [28]

(1)Equitable Interest

(a)Submissions  [29] – [33]

(b)Decision

(i)      Existence of Equitable Interests                 [34] – [42]

(ii)     Extinguishment of Equitable Interest         [43] – [46]

(2)Fraud

(a)Submissions  [47] – [50]

(b)Decision

(i)      Legal Principles  [51] – [55]

(ii)     Davies Law and CH Finance

relationship  [56] – [59]

(iii)   Mr Davies’ knowledge on

29 May 2002  [60] – [74]

(iv)    Mr Davies’ knowledge at

14 June 2002  [75] – [89]

  1. Conclusion           [90] – [96]

(3)Agency

(a)     Facts  [97] – [108]

(b)Submissions  [109] – [115]

(c)Decision

(i)      Introduction  [116] – [121]

(ii)     Imputing Knowledge to Mortgagees          [122] – [151]

(iii)   Attributing Knowledge to DSNC               [152] – [163] Summary     [164] – [170]

Introduction

[1]    This case raises questions about the indefeasibility provisions of the Land Transfer Act 1952. It presents a novel combination of features. First, it is based  upon allegations of defeasible fraud committed by a solicitor when registering consecutive memoranda of transfer and mortgage on a number of separate transactions. Second, with two exceptions for forgery, the vendors who allege fraud signed apparently valid and binding agreements for sale and purchase with and memoranda of transfer to the purchaser. Third, the solicitor acted for the purchaser, the mortgagees and, allegedly, for the vendors on each transaction. Fourth, the solicitor’s alleged fraud was in the nature of wilful blindness towards an identical equitable interest held by each vendor, arising from a right to set aside the agreements consequent upon the purchaser’s earlier and discrete fraud. And, fifth, the vendors claim the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Waller v Davies HC Auckland Civ-2003-404-6843 and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2005] NZHC 1236
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In this case, the court considered a dispute involving the alleged fraudulent activities of a solicitor, Mr Stephen Davies, in relation to the registration of mortgages on several properties. The plaintiffs, John Waller and Richard Agnew, acting as statutory managers, sought to establish that the mortgages were defeasible due to Mr Davies' fraud. The defendants included Mr Davies, his law firm, and several mortgagees. The court examined whether the original owners retained an equitable interest in their properties, whether Mr Davies' registration of the mortgages constituted fraud, and whether the mortgagees could be held liable for Mr Davies' actions.

The court found that the original owners retained an equitable interest in their properties, which was constituted by a right to set aside the sale transactions due to the fraudulent misrepresentations made by CH Finance. This equitable interest survived the registration of the mortgages, and the court held that Mr Davies acted fraudulently by registering the mortgages, thereby defeating the owners' rights. However, the court determined that Mr Davies' fraud could not be imputed to the mortgagees or his law firm, DSNC. Consequently, the court dismissed the application to cancel the mortgages but suggested an alternative direction to set aside the transfers to CH Finance and restore the original owners' titles, subject to the mortgagees' interests.

The court's judgment highlighted the importance of the equitable interests held by the original owners and the high threshold for establishing fraud under the Land Transfer Act. It also underscored the distinction between imputing knowledge of fraud to agents or associated entities and holding those parties directly liable for the fraudulent actions of another. The court's decision allowed for potential compensation claims by the original owners and addressed the procedural efficiency of the litigation process.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established