Walker v Scott HC Auckland CIV 2008-404-8353

Link copied
Case Copied 10 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND AUCKLAND REGISTRY

CIV 2008-404-8353

BETWEEN  GILBERT WALKER Plaintiff

ANDL M SCOTT Defendant

Hearing:         8 April 2010

Appearances: A S Ross for plaintiff

Defendant in person

Judgment:      8 April 2010

ORAL JUDGMENT OF WYLIE J

Solicitors:

Chapman Tripp, Auckland:  adam.ross@chapmantripp.com

Russell McVeagh Auckland: Malcolm.crotty@russellmcveagh.com

L Scott, 506 McLaren Falls Road, Tauranga

GILBERT WALKER V L M SCOTT HC AK CIV 2008-404-8353  8 April 2010

[1]      These proceedings have been allocated a fixture on 22 and 23 April 2010. The defendant, Mr Scott, has applied for an adjournment.   He also seeks to have them transferred to Rotorua or Hamilton.

Background

[2]      The statement of claim was filed on 15 December 2008.  Gilbert Walker, a firm of barristers and solicitors practising in Auckland, are seeking to recover fees it says are owed to it by the defendant, Mr Scott.   It alleges that it entered into an agreement in writing in October 2007, whereby Mr Scott instructed it to represent him in High Court proceedings against his mother and sisters.  It says that pursuant to the fee agreement the firm agreed to represent Mr Scott on a contingency basis, and the contingency was satisfied on 3 December 2007.

[3]      Mr Scott has filed a statement of defence.   He admits he entered into a contingency fee arrangement with Gilbert Walker.  Inter alia, he asserts that the firm agreed to cap the fees and that it was an implied term of the agreement that Gilbert Walker would provide legal services through to final judgment including any cost related issues.  He denies that the contingency has been met.

[4] The proceedings were stayed throughout much of 2009, because Mr Scott filed a complaint on 22 January 2009 against Gilbert Walker with the New Zealand Law Society. That complaint asserted that the fees charged by Gilbert Walker were unjustified and excessive. Pursuant to s 161(1) of the Lawyers and Conveyancers Act 2006, the proceedings for the recovery of the amount Gilbert Walker says is owed to it could not be progressed until the complaint had been finally disposed of.

[5]      Mr Scott’s complaint was dismissed in October 2009.   The Costs Assessor apparently expressed the opinion that Gilbert Walker’s fees and disbursements were “on the lower side of what is normally charged”.

[6]      Mr Scott then sought to challenge the Cost Assessor’s decision by applying for review by the Legal Complaints Review Officer.  That application was dismissed for want of jurisdiction.  Apparently Mr Scott failed to pay the required filing fee in a timely fashion.

[7]      The High Court proceedings came before Associate Judge Bell on 3 February

2010.  He put in place a timetable order which inter alia required Gilbert Walker to serve its evidence by 19 February 2010, and Mr Scott to serve his evidence by 12

March 2010.

[8]      Gilbert Walker complied with the timetable and served its briefs of evidence. [9]      Mr Scott failed to comply with the timetable.  Rather than file his briefs of

evidence on 12…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Walker v Scott HC Auckland CIV 2008-404-8353 and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2010] NZHC 1012
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Gilbert Walker versus L M Scott, heard in the High Court of New Zealand at Auckland, involved a dispute over unpaid legal fees. The plaintiff, Gilbert Walker, a firm of barristers and solicitors, sought to recover fees owed by the defendant, Mr Scott, under a contingency fee arrangement. The defendant had engaged Gilbert Walker to represent him in High Court proceedings against his mother and sisters, with an agreement that fees would be charged on a contingency basis, contingent upon the satisfaction of a specific condition. The defendant admitted entering into the contingency fee arrangement but contested the satisfaction of the contingency condition and claimed that the fees charged were excessive.

The legal issues before the court were whether the contingency condition had been met and if the fees charged were justified. Additionally, the court had to determine whether Mr Scott's application for an adjournment and the transfer of the proceedings to a different location were justified.

The court found that Mr Scott had known about the documents he relied on to claim fraudulent conduct for some time and that the allegations were not new. Furthermore, the court considered that the alleged fraud was unrelated to the fees charged by Gilbert Walker. Regarding the representation issue, the court found that Mr Scott had contrived to create difficulties in securing legal representation, which was not a valid ground for an adjournment. The court declined the adjournment application and decided that the proceedings should proceed as scheduled. The court also rejected the application to transfer the proceedings to Rotorua or Hamilton, as the cause of action arose in Auckland. Finally, the court imposed further timetable orders for the filing of evidence and opening statements, with a warning that failure to comply would result in Mr Scott being debarred from defending the proceedings.

The court's decision ultimately ruled against Mr Scott's applications for adjournment and transfer and ordered him to comply with the specified timetable for the filing of evidence and opening statements. The costs of the hearing were reserved.