Wairarapa District Health Board v Shirley

Link copied
Case Copied 47 min read

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF NEW ZEALAND

CA43/05

BETWEENWAIRARAPA DISTRICT HEALTH BOARD


Appellant

ANDA J SHIRLEY


First Respondent

ANDS G & M K BENSEMANN


Second Respondents

Hearing:12 October 2005

Court:Robertson, Baragwanath and Heath JJ

Counsel:M G Ring QC for Appellant


C J Hodson QC and A L Credin for First Respondent
No appearance for Second Respondents

Judgment:7 December 2005 

JUDGMENT OF THE COURT

A        THE APPEAL IS ALLOWED.

BThe appellant shall have costs of $5,000 plus usual disbursements against the first respondent.

____________________________________________________________________

REASONS

Robertson J (dissenting)  [1]

Baragwanath J  [36]

Heath J  [62]

ROBERTSON J

Introduction

[1]       The Wairarapa District Health Board (the Board) appeals from a costs decision of Miller J delivered in the High Court at Wellington on 9 March 2005.  The Judge awarded Mr Shirley 30% of costs on a 2B basis against the Board relating to his successfully defending a claim that he had given negligent advice to Mr and Mrs Bensemann, the second respondents.

Factual and procedural history

[2]       In 1998 Mr Bensemann had a vasectomy.  It was performed by Mr Shirley, a surgeon employed by the Board.  Notwithstanding the operation, in 2000 Mrs Bensemann gave birth to a son.

[3]       As a result, the Bensemanns instituted proceedings against the Board.  They did not allege that the operation had been performed negligently, but proceeded on the basis that Mr Shirley had not fully informed them of the risk of recanalisation within 10-12 years.  The  Bensemanns contended that if they had known of the risk, they would not have proceeded with the vasectomy.

[4]       The Board sought to settle the claim in order to avoid the costs of litigation.  After an attempt at mediation failed, the Board initiated an alternative strategy.  It persuaded the Bensemanns to join Mr Shirley as a second defendant and the Board cross-claimed against him.  The purpose of this arrangement was to pressure Mr Shirley into contributing to a global settlement of the case, or, if that failed, to settle separately with the Bensemanns.  When Mr Shirley refused to contribute to a global settlement, the Board made an offer of settlement of $20,000 to the Bensemanns which they accepted.  In August 2003 the Bensemanns discontinued the claim against the Board.  The claim against Mr Shirley continued.

[5]       Following a full hearing, in a decision delivered on 15 July 2004, Miller J dismissed the Bensemanns’ action against Mr Shirley.

[6]       On 28 October 2004 Mr Shirley brought an application seeking an order that the Board, as a former defendant, contribute to the costs he incurred in defending the claim.

The decision of Miller J

[7]       The Judge first considered the jurisdiction to make the order.  He noted that counsel had agreed that he had jurisdiction, but that it had to be exercised in a principled way.  He cited the following High Court Rules:

[46 Costs at discretion of Court

(1)       All matters relating to the costs of and incidental to a proceeding or a step in a proceeding are at…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Wairarapa District Health Board v Shirley and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2005] NZCA 307
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In Wairarapa District Health Board v Shirley, the Court of Appeal of New Zealand considered whether the Wairarapa District Health Board (WDHB) should be liable for costs incurred by Dr. Shirley in defending a claim of negligent advice regarding a failed vasectomy. The Court found that the costs order made by the High Court was not justified. Dr. Shirley's costs were incurred after the WDHB had settled with the plaintiffs and discontinued the proceedings against it. The appeal raised questions about the jurisdiction of the Court to make such an order and the exercise of discretion in awarding costs. The Court held that while the WDHB's conduct in joining Dr. Shirley to the proceedings was tactical and caused him to incur costs, the order for costs was not justified as it would create an unacceptable disincentive to settlement. The Court emphasised the importance of adhering to established principles and rules governing the determination of costs, and it allowed the appeal, quashing the costs orders made in the High Court.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established