Waiora Trading Limited v O'Sullivan

Link copied
Case Copied 9 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND AUCKLAND REGISTRY

CIV-2013-404-3593 [2014] NZHC 304

BETWEEN

WAIORA TRADING LIMITED

Plaintiff

AND

GREGORY LAURENCE O'SULLIVAN First Defendant

IGOR ALEXANDROVICH M IKITASOV Second Defendant

Hearing: 26 February 2014

Appearances:

R C Mark for plaintiff

No appearance for first defendant (abides decision of Court) No appearance for second defendant

Judgment:

27 February 2014

JUDGMENT OF LANG J

[on application for judicial review]

This judgment was delivered by me on 27 February 2014 at 10.30 am, pursuant to Rule 11.5 of the High Court Rules.

Registrar/Deputy Registrar

Date……………

WAIORA TRADING LIMITED v O'SULLIVAN & MIKITASOV [2014] NZHC 304 [27 February 2014]

[1]      Mr Mikitasov owns a house property in Paihia.  In June 2009, he arranged for Mr John Nicholas to carry out urgent repairs to his property.  Mr Mikitasov was not satisfied with the standard of workmanship of the repairs, and he also considered that he  had  been  significantly  overcharged  in  relation  to  them.    This  has  led  to  a protracted dispute between Mr Mikitasov and Mr Nicholas that remains on foot nearly five years later.

[2]      In May 2010, Mr Mikitasov issued proceedings in the District Court.   He named both Mr Nicholas and the plaintiff, Waiora Trading Limited (“Waiora”), as defendants.     Mr  Nicholas  and  his  wife  are  the  directors  of  Waiora.    Those proceedings became protracted, and on 30 May 2013 Mr Mikitasov changed tack. Rather than proceed to trial in the District Court, he issued an adjudication claim against  both Waiora  and  Mr  Nicholas  under  the  provisions  of  the  Construction Contracts Act 2002 (“the Act”).  The first defendant, Mr O’Sullivan, was appointed to adjudicate the claim.

[3]      Mr Nicholas and Waiora both defended the claim.  Waiora contended that it has nothing to do with Mr Nicholas’ building activities, and that it was therefore never a party to the construction contract between Mr Mikitasov and Mr Nicholas.

[4]      Mr O’Sullivan released his determination on 21 June 2013.  He held that Mr Mikitasov was entitled to be paid the sum of $30,362 inclusive of GST.  He said that that sum was to be payable “by the respondent”.  The adjudicator did not address, however, Waiora’s defence based on the assertion that it was not a party to the construction contract.

[5]      Waiora  now  seeks  judicial  review  of  the  adjudicator’s  determination.    It contends that the adjudicator erred in law in several respects when he failed to deal with its defence to the claim by Mr Mikitasov.   Waiora asks the Court to set the adjudicator’s determination aside to the extent that it purports to render Waiora liable to Mr Mikitasov.

[6]      The adjudicator abides by the decision of the Court.  Mr Mikitasov took no steps  to  defend  the  application  for  judicial  review,  and  the  proceeding  was

accordingly set down for hearing on a formal proof basis.   Two days before the hearing, Mr Mikitasov filed an affidavit in opposition to the application, but he did not appear when the application was called on 26 February 2014.

Scope of judicial review in this…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Waiora Trading Limited v O'Sullivan and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2014] NZHC 304
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Waiora Trading Limited, a company involved in tourist accommodation, sought judicial review of an adjudicator's determination that it was liable to Mr. Mikitasov for construction works. The adjudicator had ruled that Waiora was liable to pay $30,362, but did not address Waiora’s argument that it was not a party to the construction contract between Mr. Mikitasov and Mr. Nicholas. Waiora argued that the adjudicator had erred in not considering this issue. The court had to decide whether the adjudicator's failure to address Waiora’s defence constituted an error of law warranting judicial review and whether setting aside the adjudicator's determination would undermine the objectives of the Construction Contracts Act 2002.

The court considered the scope of judicial review in relation to adjudications under the Act. It acknowledged that judicial review is not limited to instances of jurisdictional error but noted the importance of not undermining the Act’s objectives. The court emphasised that while the Act provides a mechanism to maintain cash flows through preliminary and non-binding assessments, it also allows for the merits of disputes to be resolved through arbitration, litigation, or mediation. The court found that the adjudicator's failure to address Waiora’s defence was an error, which could be described as a jurisdictional error or a failure to consider relevant facts. The court determined that setting aside the adjudicator’s determination would not undermine the Act's objectives as the construction contract in question was concluded, and the adjudicator's determination was provisional.

The court concluded that the adjudicator’s error was potentially amenable to review and that granting relief in this context would not undermine the Act’s objectives. The court granted the application for judicial review, setting aside the adjudicator’s determination insofar as it rendered Waiora liable to Mr. Mikitasov. The issue of Waiora’s liability was remitted to the adjudicator for determination, as it was inappropriate for the court to decide a contested factual issue on the basis of the material before it.

The court ordered that the adjudicator’s determination was set aside to the extent that it purported to render Waiora liable to Mr. Mikitasov. The issue of Waiora’s liability was remitted to the adjudicator for determination. Costs were to lie where they fell.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.