Waho v Ratana

Link copied
Case Copied 10 min read

IN THE HIGH COURTOF NEW ZEALAND WELLINGTON REGISTRY

CIV 2014-485-11177 [2015] NZHC 656

UNDER (in part) the Trustees Act 1956

IN THE MATTER

of Te Kohanga Reo National Trust Deed of
20 December 2013

BETWEEN

TONI JAMES DAVIS WAHO Plaintiff

AND

TINA OLSEN RATANA First Defendant

AND

TE KOHANGA REO NATIONAL TRUST

Second Defendant

Hearing: 1 April 2015

Counsel:

J K Mahuta-Coyle for Plaintiff
M F McClelland QC and V S Kemp for First Defendant
N Russell for Second Defendant

Judgment:

2 April 2015

JUDGMENT OF BROWN J

[1]      The plaintiff, who has been removed as a trustee of the second defendant, seeks an order under s 51 of the Trustee Act 1956 to remove the first defendant as a trustee.   The factual context which I need not traverse is detailed in the earlier judgment  of  MacKenzie J1   and  on  appeal.2      This  judgment  concerns  the  first defendant’s request for further particulars of the plaintiff’s amended statement of

claim dated 19 September 2014.

1      Waho v Olsen-Ratana [2014] NZHC 2729.

2      Waho v Olsen-Ratana [2014] NZCA 612.

The position of the second defendant

[2]      By memorandum dated 25 March 2015 the second defendant signalled its support  for  the  first  defendant’s  application,  noting  that  the  majority  of  the allegations relating to the alleged conduct of the first defendant personally reflect adversely on the second defendant.

[3]      Mr Russell further advised that agreement had been reached with the plaintiff that  prayer  for  relief  (B)  would  not  be  pursued  and  accordingly  would  not  be included  in  the  second  amended  statement  of  claim  which  is  to  be  filed. Mr Mahuta-Coyle having confirmed  that  position,  I granted Mr Russell  leave to withdraw.

Applicable principles

[4]      Counsel  were  in  general  agreement  on  the  principles  applicable  to  an application   for   further   particulars   of   a   statement   of   claim.      That   said, Mr Mahuta-Coyle gave emphasis to the proposition that the general rule, that the inability to give particulars properly required is no excuse, gives way in cases where the party seeking particulars knows that the party from whom particulars are sought does not have them or that the particulars sought are within the knowledge of the

requesting party.3

[5]      For the first defendant Mr McClelland QC submitted that when accusations of fraud (or concealed fraud), misleading and/or dishonest conduct are made then a plaintiff must take “especial particularity and care” in framing such allegations.4

[6]      While the plaintiff contended that his lack of knowledge as to what had transpired justified the Court in exercising its discretion to decline to order the provision of further particulars pending discovery, the first defendant was concerned to obtain a more particularised pleading in order that the task of discovery could be

suitably focused and confined.

3      Prime v Hardie HC Auckland CP 248-SD/01, 15 March 2002.

4      Commerce Commission v Qantas Airways Ltd (1992) 5 PRNZ 227 (HC) at 230.

The particulars sought

[7]      The first defendant itemised in Schedule A to its interlocutory application the paragraphs in the amended statement of…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Waho v Ratana and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2015] NZHC 656
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Waho v Ratana, the plaintiff, Toni James Davis Waho, sought to remove Tina Olsen Ratana as a trustee of the second defendant, Te Kohanga Reo National Trust, under section 51 of the Trustee Act 1956. The first defendant sought further particulars of the plaintiff’s amended statement of claim dated 19 September 2014. The court considered the principles applicable to an application for further particulars of a statement of claim, emphasizing the need for particularity in allegations of fraud, misleading and/or dishonest conduct. The court directed the plaintiff to provide further particulars on several points, including the timeframe of the alleged misuse of roles, the scope of allegations of wrongful acts, the specific Board papers received, and the instances of the plaintiff being excluded from Board meetings. The court declined to order further particulars on other points, finding the existing particularity sufficient for discovery or noting the plaintiff’s lack of knowledge.

The court’s reasoning involved balancing the need for sufficient particularity to enable the defendant to prepare for discovery against the plaintiff’s lack of knowledge. The court required the plaintiff to specify certain details, such as the dates and types of Board papers received, to focus the discovery process. However, the court refrained from directing further particulars where the plaintiff genuinely lacked knowledge or where the existing particularity was deemed sufficient. The court also considered the ethical duties of counsel in pleading court documents and the potential impact of the defendant’s affidavit on the plaintiff’s pleadings. The court concluded that costs should lie where they fell, given that both parties achieved some success on the application for further particulars.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established