W v R HC Whangarei CRI 2007-488-8

Link copied
Case Copied 6 min read

This case has been anonymized

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND WHANGAREI REGISTRY

CRI 2007-488-8

W

Applicant

v

THE QUEEN

Respondent

Hearing:         2 May 2007

Appearances: R Bowden for applicant

M Smith & A L Hyndman for respondent

Judgment:      2 May 2007

Reasons:        3 May 2007

JUDGMENT OF WINKELMANN J

R Bowden, Barrister, Whangarei

Crown Solicitor, Whangarei

W V R HC WHA CRI 2007-488-8  2 May 2007

[1]      Mr W   makes application for leave pursuant to s 169 of the Summary proceedings Act 1957 to vacate guilty pleas in respect of the following charges:

06011004244            Assault Edward Waetford with weapon

06011004245            Assault Louisa Spraggon

06011004247            Assault Louisa Spraggon with weapon

06011004252            Intentional damage with television

06011004256            Male assault female, Roanna Isaacs

06011004257            Burglary

[2]      Mr W   pleaded guilty during the course of a depositions hearing in respect of the charges against himself and other co-accused arising out of the same incident.  The grounds upon which he makes application for leave to vacate guilty pleas are:

(1) That he has a defence to the charges to which he has pleaded guilty.

(2) At the time he entered his plea, he was subject to pressure to plead guilty by reason of an opportunity being  offered  to  the  group  of defendants  that  they  could  plead  guilty  to  reduced  and  altered charges.

[3]      Mr W   has filed an affidavit setting out his account of the incident which forms the basis of the charges.    He says  in very  broad terms that  when walking along Cranley Street, Dargaville he saw a crowd of people on the porch of a house.   He recognised his brother there and saw an object come out of the crowd which hit his brother on the head.  His brother fell and rolled down the steps.   He rushed into the property to assist his brother and a scuffle ensued.  It is his account that he was rendered temporarily unconscious and when he came to he was inside the house, under attack from the occupants of the house.  He then took steps to defend himself.

[4]      Mr  W   says that  the actions he took which  form the  basis  of the informations were taken in self-defence and in defence of his brother.  He therefore has defences under s 48 of the Crimes Act 1961.

[5]      The  summary  of  facts  in  respect  of  which  he  entered  his  guilty  pleas describes Mr W   attacking the complainants Spraggon, Waetford and Isaacs, and doing considerable damage to the house in Cranley Street before stealing beer as he exited the house.

[6]      It is accepted that in general Mr W  ’s account does not match that of the complainants who gave evidence at depositions.  However, his counsel submits that there was evidence at depositions that prior to the entry of Mr W   into the altercation, his brother Matiu was kneed in the head and fell down in the area of the steps.   It is submitted that this at least tends to support Mr W  ’s account of events.

[7]…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read W v R HC Whangarei CRI 2007-488-8 and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2007] NZHC 421
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The High Court of New Zealand, Whangarei Registry, was presented with an application by Mr W, who sought to vacate his guilty pleas on several charges, including assault, intentional damage, and burglary. Mr W's application was based on the grounds that he had a defence to the charges and that he was pressured into pleading guilty by the opportunity offered to a group of defendants for reduced charges. The applicant’s plea of guilty was entered during a depositions hearing in relation to charges arising from an incident in Dargaville.

The central legal issues before the court were whether Mr W could be granted leave to vacate his guilty pleas and if so, under what circumstances. The applicant argued that there was a credible defence to the charges based on self-defence and defence of his brother, and that he felt pressured by the group plea opportunity to enter a guilty plea despite his reservations. The Crown did not oppose the application but noted that courts are generally more willing to allow such applications before sentencing.

The court examined the relevant legal principles under Section 169 of the Summary Proceedings Act 1957, which restricts the withdrawal of a guilty plea except with leave from a judge. The court referred to precedents such as R v Ripia and Kihi v R, which highlighted the discretionary nature of the court's authority to allow the withdrawal of a guilty plea based on the interests of justice. The court found that Mr W had provided a plausible account of events and was likely under pressure from the circumstances surrounding the group plea opportunity. Consequently, the court granted Mr W leave to vacate his guilty pleas to avoid the risk of a wrongful conviction. Mr W was to appear before the court later that day and would subsequently be remanded to the Dargaville District Court.