| IN THE SUPREME COURT OF NEW ZEALAND |
| SC 94/2016 [2016] NZSC 163 |
| BETWEEN | ALEXANDER PIETER VAN HEEREN |
| AND | MICHAEL DAVID KIDD |
| Court: | Glazebrook, Arnold and Ellen France JJ |
Counsel: | D J Goddard QC and D Williams for Applicant |
Judgment: | 9 December 2016 |
JUDGMENT OF THE COURT
A The application for leave to appeal is dismissed.
B The applicant must pay the respondent costs of $2,500.
____________________________________________________________________
REASONS
From 1975 until 1991 the applicant and the respondent, who were based in South Africa but had business interests in New Zealand, were in a business relationship, conducted through companies throughout the world. In 1989 they decided to terminate the relationship. On 18 January 1991, as part of the process of disengagement, the parties signed two agreements:
(a)An agreement for the sale of shareholdings in five South African companies and one Hong Kong company by Mr van Heeren to Mr Kidd; and
(b)A broadly-worded indemnity agreement, which provided for Mr Kidd to indemnify Mr van Heeren against claims by Mr Kidd and purported to be a final settlement of all disputes between them, wherever they occurred.
In 1996 Mr Kidd brought proceedings against Mr van Heeren in the New Zealand High Court seeking various remedies, including the taking of accounts, in respect of assets and profits from New Zealand based companies. Mr van Heeren protested the jurisdiction and also applied to have the proceedings struck out in reliance on the indemnity agreement. The proceedings were stayed on the basis that the indemnity agreement required that any dispute be determined by South African law. [1]
[1]Kidd v van Heeren [1998] 1 NZLR 324 (HC).
On 9 November 1998, Mr Kidd commenced a proceeding in the High Court of South Africa, arguing that the indemnity agreement related only to claims relating to the sale by Mr van Heeren of his shareholding in the companies referred to in the sale agreement or, in the alternative, that the indemnity agreement was void and of no legal effect because he had been induced to enter it by material misrepresentations. Satchwell J found in Mr Kidd’s favour, holding that Mr Kidd had been induced to enter the indemnity agreement on the basis of “misrepresentations which were deliberately made” by Mr van Heeren in order to get him to sign it.[2] The Judge reached this conclusion after examining the nature of the parties’ business relationship closely.
[2]Kidd v van Heeren SGHC Johannesburg 27973/1998, 20 May 2013 [Kidd SA judgment] at [152]–[173].
Satchwell J explained that the indemnity agreement could only be understood in the context of the business matrix within which the parties operated.[3] While acknowledging that the question whether there was a partnership was not addressed in detail in the pleadings, she went on to find (after careful consideration of extensive evidence) that it was “difficult to comprehend the joint enterprise of Kidd and van Heeren constituting anything other than a partnership”.[4] She accepted Mr…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Vivien Judith Madsen-Ries v Darrell Warren Karaneihana Peter... and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2016] NZSC 94
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The primary legal issue the court had to decide was the scope and application of the doctrine of issue estoppel in relation to findings made by the South African court concerning the existence of a partnership between the parties and the identification of partnership assets. Van Heeren argued that the South African court's findings were not necessary for the conclusion that the indemnity agreement was void and thus should not be binding in New Zealand. Additionally, van Heeren questioned the threshold for ordering a summary account in the New Zealand proceedings.
The Supreme Court, after reviewing the comprehensive judgment of the Court of Appeal, found that the issue of whether the parties had a partnership was indeed a necessary part of the South African court's reasoning and thus subject to issue estoppel in New Zealand. The court held that since van Heeren had the opportunity to appeal the South African court's findings and chose not to, he was estopped from challenging those findings in New Zealand. Furthermore, the court deemed the question of the threshold for ordering a summary account as a matter for the lower courts, not warranting the intervention of the Supreme Court in this case.
The application for leave to appeal was dismissed, and van Heeren was ordered to pay Kidd's costs of $2,500. This decision reinforces the principle that findings necessary for the outcome of a previous judgment are binding in subsequent proceedings, barring any exceptional circumstances warranting reconsideration.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi