Vipassana Foundation Charitable Trust Board v Auckland Council

Link copied
Case Copied 5 min read

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF NEW ZEALAND

I TE KŌTI MANA NUI

 SC 37/2019
 [2019] NZSC 73
BETWEEN

VIPASSANA FOUNDATION CHARITABLE TRUST BOARD
Applicant

AND

AUCKLAND COUNCIL
First Respondent

RAYMOND MYLES O’BRIEN AND VICTORIA MEI SIEN PICHLER
Second Respondent
AUCKLAND SHOOTING CLUB INCORPORATED
Third Respondent
Court:

Glazebrook, O’Regan and Ellen France JJ

Counsel:

S J Ryan for Applicant
N M H Whittington and P I C Comrie-Thomson for First Respondent
J M Savage for Second and Third Respondents

Judgment:

12 July 2019

JUDGMENT OF THE COURT

A        The application for leave to appeal is dismissed.

B         Costs of $2,500 are awarded to the respondents.

____________________________________________________________________

REASONS

Background

  1. An outdoor shooting range was granted a certificate of compliance by the first respondent, Auckland Council (the Council), under s 139 of the Resource Management Act 1991.  The site of the shooting range was about 1.2 kilometres from the meditation centre of the applicant, the Vipassana Foundation Charitable Trust Board (the Trust). 

  2. The Trust sought judicial review of the Council’s decision, claiming the shooting range did not comply with the relevant district and regional plan provisions.

  3. In brief, the High Court found there were flaws in the application and remitted the matter to the Council to be reconsidered but did not quash the certificate of compliance.[1]  The Council duly reconsidered the application and reconfirmed its decision.[2]

    [1]Vipassana Foundation Charitable Trust Board v Auckland Council [2017] NZHC 1457, [2017] NZRMA 339 (Whata J) [Vipassana (HC)] at [76]. Whata J afforded the parties an opportunity to be heard on relief. He issued a judgment two days later confirming that the matter would be remitted to the Council to be reconsidered but that the certificate would not be quashed: Vipassana Foundation Charitable Board Trust v Auckland Council [2017] NZHC 1492, [2017] NZRMA 313.

    [2]The reconsideration took place in two stages: see Vipassana Foundation Charitable Trust Board v Auckland Council [2019] NZCA 100, [2019] NZRMA 380 (Cooper, Gilbert and Williams JJ) [Vipassana (CA)] at [22].

  4. On appeal to the Court of Appeal, the Trust’s appeal was allowed and the certificate of compliance was set aside.[3] 

    [3]Vipassana (CA), above n 2, at [100]–[101].

  5. One of the Trust’s complaints in the judicial review proceedings related to the applicability (or otherwise) of the noise standards in the District Plan to gunfire.[4]  It was also alleged that the acoustic reports of the noise experts (Marshall Day Acoustics) relied on by the Council were flawed.  Indeed, in an amended notice of appeal filed in the Court of Appeal the Trust sought a declaration that the Marshall Day Acoustics reports could not validly certify compliance with the noise limit rule in the District Plan for the sound of gunfire. 

    [4]The Auckland Council District Plan: Operative Rodney Section 2011 (the District Plan).  This has now been replaced by the Auckland Unitary Plan.

  6. The Trust’s arguments on the noise issues were rejected both by the High Court[5] and the Court of Appeal.[6] 

Application for leave

[5]Vipassana (HC),…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Vipassana Foundation Charitable Trust Board v Auckland Counc... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2019] NZSC 73
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the Supreme Court of New Zealand, the Vipassana Foundation Charitable Trust Board (the Trust) sought leave to appeal against the Auckland Council's (the Council) decision to grant a certificate of compliance for an outdoor shooting range. The Trust argued that the shooting range did not comply with the relevant district and regional plan provisions, particularly concerning noise standards. The High Court found flaws in the application and remitted the matter back to the Council, but did not quash the certificate of compliance. The Council reconsidered the application and reconfirmed its decision. The Court of Appeal allowed the Trust's appeal and set aside the certificate of compliance. The Trust sought leave to appeal to the Supreme Court on the basis that the Court of Appeal erred in its assessment of compliance with noise standards and that it was wrong not to grant the declaration sought.

The central legal issues in this case were whether the Supreme Court should entertain an appeal from a party who had succeeded in the Court of Appeal and whether the application met the leave criteria. The Trust argued that the noise standards in the District Plan were applicable to gunfire and that the acoustic reports relied on by the Council were flawed. The Court of Appeal rejected these arguments. The Trust submitted that the issue was of general and public importance because the acoustic rules in question were similar to those in other district plans throughout New Zealand. The Council opposed the application for leave, arguing that the Trust had succeeded before the Court of Appeal and that the relevant part of the District Plan was no longer operative. The Court considered whether the case was one where it would be appropriate to entertain an appeal.

The Supreme Court found that the Trust had succeeded in the Court of Appeal in having the certificate of compliance set aside. The Court accepted that there might be exceptional circumstances where this Court may entertain an appeal from a party who succeeded in the Court below, but did not consider this case to be one of those exceptional circumstances. The Court accepted the Council's submission that the substance of the Trust's case related to the validity of the certificate of compliance, which had been set aside. The Court noted that the issues were narrow points and arose in relation to a particular context: the application of noise standards to gunfire and in the context of a shooting range. The Court also noted that there were concurrent findings in the Courts below.

The application for leave to appeal was dismissed, and costs of $2,500 were awarded to the respondents. The Supreme Court found that the application did not meet the leave criteria, even if the Trust had not succeeded before the Court of Appeal. The Court noted that the likely precedential effect of the Court of Appeal's decision should not be overstated, as how the standards should be interpreted and implemented may differ across plans.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established