Vincent v Lakes International Golf Management Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 19 min read

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF NEW ZEALAND

CA699/2015
[2016] NZCA 382

BETWEEN

HARTLEY CLENDON VINCENT
Appellant

AND

LAKES INTERNATIONAL GOLF MANAGEMENT LIMITED
First Respondent

THE LAKES INTERNATIONAL GOLF COURSE LIMITED
Second Respondent
Hearing:

14 July 2016

Court:

French, Fogarty and Collins JJ

Counsel:

M J Fisher and H L Hui for Appellant
C C Mansell and R W Akroyd for Respondents

Judgment:

9 August 2016 at 3.00 pm

JUDGMENT OF THE COURT

AThe appeal is allowed.  The decision of the High Court dated 23 December 2015 is quashed and judgment entered for the appellant.

BThe costs order made in the High Court is set aside.  The respondents must pay the appellant costs relating to the High Court proceeding calculated on a 2B basis under the High Court scale of costs, together with reasonable disbursements.

CThe respondents must pay the appellant costs for a standard appeal on a band A basis, together with usual disbursements.

____________________________________________________________________

REASONS OF THE COURT

(Given by French J)

Introduction

  1. Mr Vincent owns a residential property in a resort that consists of residential houses centred round a golf course.  A clause in a restrictive covenant registered in 2003 against Mr Vincent’s land provides that the landowner will join the golf club, remain a member of the golf club throughout their ownership of the land and meet all levies imposed by the golf club.  “Golf club” is defined for the purpose of the covenant as meaning “the golf club to be incorporated as an incorporated society to provide for playing rights on the golf course”.

  2. The golf course has been officially open since 2004 but no incorporated society has ever been formed.  Instead, playing rights have been provided by commercial entities, including from 2009 onwards by the first respondent, Lakes International Golf Management Ltd (Golf Management Ltd).  The second respondent, Lakes International Golf Course Ltd (Golf Course Ltd), owns the golf course land.

  3. The respondents contend that, although neither of them is an incorporated society, they are nevertheless entitled to enforce the covenant and to demand payment of levies from Mr Vincent.  Mr Vincent, who has never joined the golf club, has resisted payment.  He argues the covenant is only enforceable at the suit of a golf club that is an incorporated society.

  4. In the High Court at Auckland on 23 December 2015 Heath J held the covenant was enforceable by the respondents,[1] and in a separate judgment awarded costs against the appellant.[2]

  5. Dissatisfied with that outcome, Mr Vincent now appeals both the substantive and costs decisions.

Factual background

  1. The resort in question is known as the Lakes Resort and is situated near Pauanui on the Coromandel.  The residential area comprises 10 hectares and the golf course some 70 hectares.  The titles for both the golf course land and the residential sections were issued following subdivision of a larger parcel of…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Vincent v Lakes International Golf Management Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2016] NZCA 382
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Vincent v Lakes International Golf Management Limited concerns an appeal by Hartley Clendom Vincent against the decision of the High Court of New Zealand, which held that he was liable to pay certain fees and levies to the respondents, Lakes International Golf Management Limited and Lakes International Golf Course Limited. Vincent, who owns a residential property in a resort that includes a golf course, argues that he is not obligated to join the golf club or pay the fees because the club was never established as an incorporated society as specified in a restrictive covenant registered against his property. The covenant, drafted by the developers' lawyers in 2003, stipulates that the landowner must join and remain a member of the golf club, which is defined as "the golf club to be incorporated as an incorporated society to provide for playing rights on the golf course."

The central legal issue before the Court of Appeal was whether the restrictive covenant was enforceable against Vincent despite the fact that the golf club was not established as an incorporated society. The Court considered the arguments from both parties, including the construction of the covenant, the factual matrix in which it was created, and the intentions of the parties at the time of drafting. The Court found that the clear wording of the covenant, which specified that the golf club must be incorporated as an incorporated society, must be adhered to, and that the covenant was not enforceable because the golf club was not established as such.

The Court of Appeal allowed Vincent's appeal, quashing the decision of the High Court and entering judgment in his favour. They also set aside the costs order made in the High Court, directing that the respondents must pay Vincent's costs relating to the High Court proceeding calculated on a 2B basis under the High Court scale of costs, together with reasonable disbursements. The respondents were also ordered to pay Vincent's costs for the standard appeal on a band A basis, along with usual disbursements.

Background

Background to the litigation

Mr Vincent owns a residential property in the Lakes Resort, a development centered around a golf course. A restrictive covenant registered against his property in 2003 requires the landowner to join the golf club, remain a member throughout their ownership, and meet all levies imposed by the club. The golf club was defined as "the golf club to be incorporated as an incorporated society to provide for playing rights on the golf course." Despite this, the golf course has been managed by commercial entities since its opening in 2004, and no incorporated society has ever been formed. The respondents, Lakes International Golf Management Ltd and Lakes International Golf Course Ltd, contend they are entitled to enforce the covenant and demand payment of levies from Mr Vincent, who has resisted payment on the grounds that the covenant is only enforceable at the suit of an incorporated society. The matter went to trial, and the High Court held the covenant enforceable by the respondents.

The case originated in the High Court at Auckland, where the respondents sought recovery of unpaid levies from Mr Vincent. Both parties applied for summary judgment, which was declined by Associate Judge Sargisson. Mr Vincent appealed the decision but it was upheld by the Court of Appeal. The High Court subsequently held the covenant enforceable by the respondents and awarded costs against Mr Vincent. Dissatisfied with the outcome, Mr Vincent appealed both the substantive decision and the costs award to the Court of Appeal.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the covenant is enforceable by the respondents despite the golf club not being an incorporated society.
2. Whether the costs order made in the High Court should be reversed in favor of the appellant.

Held
1. The covenant is not enforceable by the respondents despite the golf club not being an incorporated society. The appeal against the High Court decision of 23 December 2015 is allowed. Judgment is entered for the appellant and the High Court decision is quashed.
2. The costs order made in the High Court is set aside. The respondents must pay the appellant costs relating to the High Court proceeding calculated on a 2B basis under the High Court scale of costs, together with reasonable disbursements. The respondents must also pay the appellant costs for a standard appeal on a band A basis, together with usual disbursements.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Court of Appeal allowed the appeal and set aside the decision of the High Court that the covenant was enforceable by the respondents despite the golf club not being an incorporated society. The Court of Appeal held that the starting point for the interpretation of the covenant must be its actual words, which clearly specified that the golf club was to be incorporated as an incorporated society. The Court rejected the respondents' argument that the context of the development indicated that the golf club was always intended to be run as a for-profit entity, which would not necessarily be an incorporated society. The Court also noted that the drafters had deliberately chosen to specify the mode of incorporation, which undermined arguments that the mode of incorporation was unimportant or immaterial. The Court concluded that to interpret the covenant in a manner that departed from its clear words would be to rewrite it.

With respect to the costs order made in the High Court, the Court of Appeal agreed with the appellant that the amount of the costs should be reduced to reflect the low sum at stake and the fact that the proceeding was a test case for the respondents. However, the Court also agreed with the respondents that the proceeding was appropriately in the High Court due to its complexity, and therefore the costs should be calculated on a 2B basis under the High Court scale of costs. The Court further held that the respondents must pay the appellant's costs for a standard appeal on a band A basis, together with usual disbursements.