Vincent Ross Siemer v Judicial Conduct Commissioner

Link copied
Case Copied 1 min read
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF NEW ZEALAND
SC 60/2012
[2012] NZSC 95

BETWEEN  VINCENT ROSS SIEMER
Applicant

AND  JUDICIAL CONDUCT COMMISSIONER
First Respondent

AND  SIAN SEERPOOHI ELIAS
Second Respondent

AND  PETER BLANCHARD
Third Respondent

AND  JOHN MCGRATH
Fourth Respondent

AND  WILLIAM YOUNG
Fifth Respondent

AND  ANDREW TIPPING
Sixth Respondent

Court:             Chambers and Glazebrook JJ

Counsel:         Applicant in Person
D J Goddard QC and L Theron for First Respondent

Judgment:      9 November 2012

JUDGMENT OF THE COURT

The application to recall the judgment [2012] NZSC 92 is dismissed.

REASONS

  1. The applicant seeks recall on eight grounds.  None is made out.  The principal ground is that the leave judgment failed to address the grounds for leave.  All were considered, even though not all of them were referred to in the reasons.  Section 16(2) of the Supreme Court Act 2003 permits the Court, when refusing leave, to state its reasons “briefly and ... in general terms only”.  The applicant’s proposed appeal, like his other applications for leave to appeal against Court of Appeal decisions concerning security for costs, does not meet the statutory criteria in s 13 and, despite the further information now provided, we remain unsatisfied “that it is necessary in the interests of justice for the Court to hear and determine the proposed appeal”. 

  2. Accordingly, we dismiss the application to recall the judgment. 

Solicitors:
Gault Mitchell Law, Wellington, for First Respondent

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Vincent Ross Siemer v Judicial Conduct Commissioner and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2012] NZSC 925
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Vincent Ross Siemer has brought an application against the Judicial Conduct Commissioner and others, seeking recall of a Supreme Court judgment. The primary dispute revolves around the refusal of leave to appeal certain decisions related to security for costs. The case was heard by Chambers and Glazebrook JJ, who delivered their judgment on 9 November 2012. Siemer, representing himself, was opposed by counsel appointed for the first respondent, with additional representation for other respondents.

The central legal issues in the case involved whether the Supreme Court's refusal of leave to appeal was justified and whether the Court's reasons for its decision were adequate. Siemer argued that the Court had failed to address all the grounds for leave and that his proposed appeal met the statutory criteria for leave to appeal. The Court needed to determine whether the applicant's grounds for recall were valid and whether the reasons given by the Court for refusing leave were appropriate and sufficient under the Supreme Court Act 2003.

The Court found that Siemer's application did not meet the necessary criteria for recall. It held that the leave judgment adequately considered all grounds for leave, despite not explicitly mentioning each one in the reasons. The Court relied on section 16(2) of the Supreme Court Act 2003, which allows the Court to provide reasons in general terms when refusing leave. Furthermore, the Court concluded that Siemer's proposed appeal did not meet the statutory criteria for leave to appeal, and it remained unsatisfied that it was necessary in the interests of justice to hear and determine the proposed appeal. Consequently, the Court dismissed Siemer's application for recall.

The final order of the Court was the dismissal of Siemer's application to recall the judgment, affirming the earlier decision that leave to appeal was properly refused.

Background

Background to the litigation

Vincent Ross Siemer applied to the Supreme Court of New Zealand for leave to appeal against decisions of the Court of Appeal. These decisions pertained to security for costs, which Siemer sought to challenge. Siemer had previously been involved in litigation where security for costs was ordered against him. He made multiple applications for leave to appeal against these orders, which were all dismissed by the Court of Appeal. Siemer's most recent application for leave to appeal was dismissed by the Supreme Court in a judgment dated 13 September 2012. Siemer subsequently applied to recall this judgment, arguing it was flawed on eight grounds. He contended that the Supreme Court failed to adequately address the reasons for leave to appeal and that the proposed appeal met the statutory criteria for leave.

The matter originated from Siemer's dissatisfaction with the Court of Appeal's decisions on security for costs in his previous litigation. He first applied to the Supreme Court for leave to appeal these decisions. The Supreme Court dismissed his application for leave to appeal, leading Siemer to apply to recall this judgment. His application to recall was heard by the Supreme Court and was ultimately dismissed on 9 November 2012.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the Supreme Court's judgment dismissing the application for leave to appeal adequately addressed the grounds for leave.
2. Whether the proposed appeal met the statutory criteria for leave under section 13 of the relevant legislation.

Held
1. The Supreme Court held that the application to recall the judgment [2012] NZSC 92 is dismissed. The court concluded that none of the eight grounds for recall were made out, particularly noting that the principal ground regarding the leave judgment's failure to address the grounds for leave was unfounded as all grounds were considered.
2. The Supreme Court further held that the proposed appeal did not meet the statutory criteria for leave under section 13 of the relevant legislation, and it was not necessary in the interests of justice for the Court to hear and determine the proposed appeal.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Supreme Court considered the application to recall the judgment [2012] NZSC 92, where the applicant claimed the leave judgment failed to address the grounds for leave. The Court reviewed the eight grounds for recall provided by the applicant, concluding that all grounds were indeed considered, albeit not all were referred to in the reasons. The Court referred to Section 16(2) of the Supreme Court Act 2003, which allows the Court to state reasons briefly and in general terms when refusing leave. This section was used to affirm that the leave judgment adequately addressed the grounds for leave.

Furthermore, the Court examined whether the proposed appeal met the statutory criteria under section 13. Despite the applicant's provision of further information, the Court remained unsatisfied that it was necessary in the interests of justice to hear and determine the appeal. The Court's decision to dismiss the application to recall the judgment was based on the applicant's inability to meet the statutory criteria for leave to appeal and the overall inadequacy of the grounds for recall. The Court emphasised the importance of adhering to statutory requirements and the necessity of a strong justification for leave to appeal, highlighting these points as the ratio decidendi of the decision.