IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF NEW ZEALAND
CA28/2008
[2008] NZCA 486BETWEENCEZAR VILCEANU, CONSTANTA CAMELIA VILCEANU AND ADRIAN VILCEANU
Appellants
ANDTHE MINISTER OF IMMIGRATION
Respondent
Hearing:29 October 2008
Court:William Young P, Chambers and Baragwanath JJ
Counsel:D J Ryken for Appellants
I C Carter and R A Kirkness for Respondent
Judgment:18 November 2008 at 3.30 pm
JUDGMENT OF THE COURT
A The appeal is dismissed.
BThe appellants are to pay the respondent costs on a standard basis, band A, and usual disbursements.
____________________________________________________________________
REASONS OF THE COURT
(Given by William Young P)
Facts
[1] Cezar and Constanta Vilceanu and their son Adrian emigrated from Romania to New Zealand in January 2004. Adrian, who is now 12, suffers from a serious blood disorder, thalassaemia major. Treatment for this disorder requires frequent blood transfusions and there is an associated need for iron chelation therapy (to address build up of iron resulting from blood transfusions). Mr and Mrs Vilceanu took the view that the New Zealand health system would provide a better and safer standard of care for Adrian than could be obtained in Romania. This is why they sought residency in New Zealand. But this purpose and Adrian’s medical condition were concealed from the New Zealand immigration authorities.
[2] Within the context of the New Zealand health system, and assuming good compliance on his part with the treatment regime, Adrian has a life expectancy of around 50 years. Assuming that he lives until he is 50, the cost of his treatment will be very substantial, in the order of $5m by one estimate. Effectively the same treatment is available from the Romanian health system. Mr and Mrs Vilceanu nonetheless took the view that Adrian’s life expectancy would be far shorter in Romania than in New Zealand. On the evidence adduced to date, that assessment would appear to be accurate. For instance, the risk of receiving contaminated blood is higher in Romania than in New Zealand. There is also the possibility that access to chelation therapy might be interrupted due to funding shortfalls in the Romanian health system.
[3] Within days of arriving in New Zealand Mr and Mrs Vilceanu sought treatment for Adrian at Auckland Hospital. It soon became apparent that they had not been candid with the New Zealand immigration authorities when seeking residence. Accordingly, on 2 June 2005 the Minister of Immigration revoked the residence permits that had previously been granted to Mr and Mrs Vilceanu and Adrian. They appealed to the Deportation Review Tribunal (“the Tribunal”), which heard the case on 22 and 23 February 2006. The decision was not released until 26 January 2007. In the meantime, on 1 January 2007, Romania acceded to the European Union. This is of at least potential significance in relation to the way in which the Romanian health system can be expected to operate. As well, on the basis of what Mr Carter for the Crown told us, this accession means that Romanians can now have access to the health systems of…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Vilceanu v The Minister of Immmigration and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2008] NZCA 486
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The primary legal issues the Court of Appeal had to decide were whether the Tribunal had correctly interpreted the relevant statutory provisions and carried out the required balancing exercise, and whether the Court of Appeal had jurisdiction to hear the appeal against the High Court's decision. The Court held that the Tribunal had not correctly interpreted the relevant statutory provisions and had failed to carry out the required balancing exercise. The Court also held that it did not have jurisdiction to hear the appeal against the High Court's decision because there is no right of appeal against the judgment of the High Court in such cases.
The Court of Appeal dismissed the appeal and held that the appellants were to pay the respondent costs on a standard basis, band A, and usual disbursements. The Court emphasised that its decision should not be seen as support for the proposition that potential immigrants should profit from their provision of false or misleading information to immigration authorities. The Court acknowledged the public interest factor inherent in such appeals but held that the humanitarian factors in this particular case outweighed any other considerations.
Background
Background to the litigation
The Vilceanus initially sought residence permits in New Zealand based on false information about Adrian's health status, leading to their permits being revoked by the Minister of Immigration. They appealed this decision to the Deportation Review Tribunal, which quashed the revocation. The Minister of Immigration then appealed the Tribunal's decision to the High Court. The High Court allowed the appeal, finding that the Tribunal had failed to carry out a proper balancing exercise of the humanitarian considerations against the policy reasons for revocation, and remitted the matter back to the Tribunal for reconsideration. The Vilceanus appealed the High Court's decision to the Court of Appeal. Additionally, the Minister of Immigration brought judicial review proceedings in the High Court, which were dismissed.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether the Deportation Review Tribunal correctly balanced the humanitarian considerations against the policy reasons for revocation when it quashed the revocation of the Vilceanus' residence permits.
2. Whether the High Court correctly allowed the appeal and remitted the matter back to the Tribunal for reconsideration.
3. Whether the Court of Appeal has jurisdiction to hear the appeal from the High Court's decision allowing the appeal and remitting the matter to the Tribunal.
Held
1. The Deportation Review Tribunal correctly quashed the revocation of the Vilceanus' residence permits when it found it would be unjust or unduly harsh to require the Vilceanus to return to Romania given Adrian's health risks if returned.
2. The High Court correctly allowed the appeal and remitted the matter back to the Tribunal for reconsideration because the Tribunal failed to properly balance the humanitarian considerations against the policy reasons for revocation.
3. The Court of Appeal has no jurisdiction to hear the appeal from the High Court's decision allowing the appeal and remitting the matter to the Tribunal because there is no right of appeal to the Court of Appeal against the judgment of the High Court allowing the appeal.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The Court of Appeal considered whether the Deportation Review Tribunal correctly balanced the humanitarian considerations against the policy reasons for revocation when it quashed the revocation of the Vilceanus' residence permits. The Court found that the Tribunal did not properly carry out the required balancing exercise and instead focused solely on the risks to Adrian if returned to Romania. The Court of Appeal held that the balancing exercise was necessary to properly weigh the humanitarian factors against the policy factors supporting revocation of permits obtained by fraud.
The Court of Appeal then considered whether the High Court correctly allowed the appeal and remitted the matter back to the Tribunal for reconsideration. The Court found that the High Court was correct in allowing the appeal because the Tribunal failed to properly balance the competing factors. However, the Court of Appeal found that it had no jurisdiction to hear the appeal from the High Court's decision because there is no right of appeal to the Court of Appeal against the judgment of the High Court allowing the appeal.
The ratio decidendi of the decision is that the Deportation Review Tribunal must properly balance humanitarian considerations against policy reasons for revocation when deciding appeals against the revocation of residence permits. The Court of Appeal found that the Tribunal failed to properly carry out this balancing exercise in the present case.