Vijayakumar v Manukau Family Doctors Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 27 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND AUCKLAND REGISTRY

I TE KŌTI MATUA O AOTEAROA TĀMAKI MAKAURAU ROHE

CIV-2021-404-1828

[2022] NZHC 1272

UNDER Part 18 of the High Court Rules 2016

IN THE MATTER

of Section 174 of the Companies Act 1993

BETWEEN

SOTHILINGIN VIJAYAKUMAR

Plaintiff/Applicant

AND

MANUKAU FAMILY DOCTORS LIMITED

First Defendant/Respondent

SIVA VASANTHAN

Second Defendant/Respondent

Hearing: 3 March 2022, further submissions 17 March 2022

Appearances:

R Harrington for the Plaintiff/Applicant

No appearance for the Frist and Second Defendants/Respondents

Judgment:

1 June 2022


JUDGMENT OF FITZGERALD J


This judgment was delivered by me on 1 June 2022 at 3.00pm, pursuant to Rule 11.5 of the High Court Rules.

Registrar/Deputy Registrar

Date……………

Solicitors:           Shieff Angland, Auckland

VIJAYAKUMAR v MANUKAU FAMILY DOCTORS LTD [2022] NZHC 1272 [1 June 2022]

Introduction

[1]    This proceeding concerns the management and affairs of the first defendant/respondent, Manukau Family Doctors Limited (the Company). The plaintiff/applicant, Dr Vijayakumar, is a minority shareholder in the Company, holding 120 shares (40 per cent). The other shareholder is the second defendant/respondent, Dr Vasanthan.  Dr Vasanthan  is  the  majority  shareholder,  holding  180  shares  (60 per cent). He is also the Company’s sole director.1

[2]    The Company is the commercial landlord of premises at Great South Road, Manukau (the Premises). The Premises are the Company’s only  significant  asset. Dr Vijayakumar, who has resided in Australia since 2006, is dissatisfied with the manner in which Dr Vasanthan is manging the Company, including the terms on which the Premises are being leased to a company associated with Dr Vasanthan.

[3]    In an earlier application, Dr Vijayakumar claimed that Dr Vasanthan had breached his duties as a director of the Company, and applied under s 165 of the Companies Act 1993 (the Act) to bring a derivative proceeding against Dr Vasanthan (the Derivative Proceeding). In a judgment delivered on 19 July 2021, Associate Judge Bell declined that application, on the basis that Dr Vijayakumar had a more effective alternative remedy under s 174 of the Act.2

[4]    Dr Vijayakumar accordingly filed  these  proceedings,  seeking  relief  under s 174(2) of the Act. Neither defendant has participated in the proceedings, and accordingly the hearing proceeded by way of formal proof.3

[5]Dr Vijayakumar seeks the following orders pursuant to s 174(2) of the Act:

(a)the Company or Dr Vasanthan acquire his shares in the Company at a price fixed by the Court (pursuant to s 174(2)(a));4


1      Dr Vijayakumar was a director of the Company until August 2012.

2      Vijayakumar v Vasanthan [2021] NZHC 1827 [Derivative Proceeding judgment].

3      Dr Vasanthan did participate in the Derivative Proceeding, representing himself.

4      Valuation evidence relied on by Dr Vijayakumar assesses Dr Vijayakumar’s 40 per cent shareholding in the Company, plus his shareholder current account, at a range of $625,663 to

$709,109 (mid-point of $667,386).

(b)the Company or Dr Vasanthan pay compensation to Dr Vijayakumar for direct losses suffered as a result of Dr Vasanthan’s management of the  Company,  in  a  range  of  $103,395  to  $123,121  (pursuant  to   s 174(2)(b));

(c)the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Vijayakumar v Manukau Family Doctors Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2022] NZHC 1272
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This proceeding concerns the management and affairs of the first defendant/respondent, Manukau Family Doctors Limited. Dr Vijayakumar, the plaintiff/applicant, is a minority shareholder in the Company, holding 120 shares (40 per cent). Dr Vasanthan, the second defendant/respondent, is the majority shareholder, holding 180 shares (60 per cent) and is also the Company’s sole director. The Company is the commercial landlord of premises at Great South Road, Manukau. Dr Vijayakumar is dissatisfied with the manner in which Dr Vasanthan is managing the Company, including the terms on which the premises are being leased to a company associated with Dr Vasanthan. Dr Vijayakumar filed these proceedings under s 174 of the Companies Act 1993, seeking the following orders: the Company or Dr Vasanthan acquire his shares in the Company at a price fixed by the Court; the Company or Dr Vasanthan pay compensation to Dr Vijayakumar for direct losses suffered as a result of Dr Vasanthan’s management of the Company; the Company or Dr Vasanthan pay Dr Vijayakumar consequential damages; and costs.

The court considered the legal principles governing unfair prejudice claims, the evidence presented, and the appropriate relief to be granted. The court found that the evidence demonstrated that the affairs of the Company have been and are being managed in a way that is oppressive to Dr Vijayakumar as a minority shareholder. The court found that Dr Vasanthan had been content for the Company to receive a lower than market rent from a company associated with him, and that Company funds were being used for the benefit of Dr Vasanthan himself or companies associated with him and his family. The court also found that the claim for consequential losses was not made out on the balance of probabilities.

The court ordered that Dr Vasanthan purchase Dr Vijayakumar’s shares in the Company for a total amount of $667,386, and pay Dr Vijayakumar compensation for direct losses of $79,281. Dr Vijayakumar’s claim for consequential losses of $610,000 was dismissed. Dr Vijayakumar is entitled to costs on a 2B basis for steps taken in this proceeding, plus disbursements.

Final orders were made as follows: Dr Vasanthan purchase Dr Vijayakumar’s shares in the Company for a total amount of $667,386; Dr Vasanthan pay Dr Vijayakumar compensation for direct losses of $79,281; and Dr Vijayakumar’s claim for consequential losses of $610,000 was dismissed. Dr Vijayakumar is entitled to costs on a 2B basis for steps taken in this proceeding, plus disbursements.