Unkovich v Bilbe HC Auckland CIV 2010-404-5098

Link copied
Case Copied 15 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND AUCKLAND REGISTRY

CIV-2010-404-005098

BETWEEN  ZELJAN ALEXANDER UNKOVICH Appellant

ANDCARL ROBERT BILBE AND RACHEL ANNE BILBE

Respondents

Hearing:         16 November 2010

Counsel:         P J Napier for the Appellant

D Grove for the Respondents

Judgment:      16 November 2010

(ORAL) JUDGMENT OF WOOLFORD J

Solicitors/Counsel:

P Napier, Keegan Alexander, PO Box 999, Shortland Street, Auckland 1140. DX CP21504. Email:  pnapier@keegan.co.nz

D Grove, PO Box 130, Shortland Street, Auckland 1140. Email:  danielgrove@45chancery.co.nz

ZELJAN ALEXANDER UNKOVICH V CARL ROBERT BILBE AND RACHEL ANNE BILBE HC AK CIV-

2010-404-005098  16 November 2010

Introduction

[1]      The  appellant  is  a  solicitor.     He  received  instructions  to  act  for  the respondents in the purchase of a property described as Unit 15, 46 Carlos Drive, Flatbush, Auckland.  The vendor company was said to be a Blue Chip subsidiary. The respondents signed an unconditional agreement for sale and purchase of the property on 3 May 2007.   The appellant received the agreement under cover of a letter  dated  7  May 2007.    A  solicitor  employed  by  the  appellant  wrote  to  the respondents by email on 9 May 2007 acknowledging instructions to act.

[2]      The agreement had significant shortcomings and did not sufficiently protect the interests of the respondents.  The appellant did not bring the shortcomings to the attention of the respondents.   Nor did he advise the respondents of their statutory right to cancel the agreement under s 225 of the Resource Management Act 1991 within 14 days of the agreement.   The respondents subsequently lost their deposit when the Blue Chip group of companies collapsed.  They also incurred other losses.

[3]      The respondents sued the appellant for negligence.  In a reserved judgment dated 9 July 2010, the District Court held that the appellant had been negligent and ordered the appellant to pay the respondents $5,000 general damages and special damages of $150,113.   In a subsequent judgment as to interest and costs dated

20 August 2010, the District Court fixed costs at 30 percent above category 2B.

[4]      The appellant does not appeal against the primary finding of negligence.  He appeals against the District Court’s secondary finding that the respondents were not contributorily negligent, the quantum of special damages and the uplift of scale costs.

Contributory negligence

[5]      The appellant’s statement of defence specifically pleaded that if he was liable to the respondents then  the quantum of damages should be reduced due to the respondents’ own negligence.  It was alleged that the respondents were negligent in entering into the agreement without properly comprehending it and without seeking

professional advice as to the obligations, benefits and risks arising from the agreement.

[6]      The District Court dealt with the issue of contributory negligence at [79] of the substantive judgment.  It stated:

[79]      In my view the signing of the agreement was not causative of any loss.  The clear cause of loss was Mr Unkovich’s failure to advise Mr and Mrs  Bilbe  on  risk  elements  including  that  Parley  Ltd  did  not  own  the property, the deposit was excessive and that the Bilbes…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Unkovich v Bilbe HC Auckland CIV 2010-404-5098 and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2010] NZHC 2088
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the High Court of New Zealand, Zeljan Alexander Unkovich appealed against a decision of the District Court, which found him liable for negligence in his role as a solicitor for Carl Robert Bilbe and Rachel Anne Bilbe, in their purchase of a property. The District Court held that Unkovich had failed to properly advise the Bilbes of significant shortcomings in the agreement for sale and purchase, which led to the Bilbes incurring significant losses when the vendor company collapsed. The District Court awarded the Bilbes $5,000 in general damages, $150,113 in special damages, and an uplift in costs of 30 percent above category 2B. Unkovich appealed against the finding of no contributory negligence on the part of the Bilbes, the quantum of special damages, and the uplift in costs.

The court considered whether the Bilbes were contributorily negligent in entering into the agreement without seeking independent legal advice. The court found that the Bilbes, who had previously bought and sold property, did not have particular legal or financial experience and that the statutory right to opt out of the agreement within 14 days was a recognition that sales "off the plans" carry an element of risk. The court concluded that the Bilbes were not contributorily negligent, as they had received advice from a Blue Chip investment advisor and relied on the company's expertise in property development.

The court also considered whether the District Court was correct in awarding special damages based on the evidence rather than the pleadings. The court found that the appellant was aware of the extent of the claim for special damages and had been put on notice that the respondents sought interest, which was later specified in replies to requests for further and better particulars and in a witness statement regarding quantum. The court concluded that there were no grounds to disturb the level of special damages awarded.

Finally, the court considered whether the District Court was correct in ordering an uplift in scale costs of 30 percent. The court found that the District Court failed to take into account the fact that summary judgment had been declined when assessing the quantum of costs and that the District Court was wrong to find that an uplift of costs was required to recognise the untenability of Mr Eades' evidence. The court allowed the appeal but only to the extent of quashing the order for an uplift of 30 percent above scale costs. Costs were to lie where they fell.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established