University of Waikato v Benchmarking Services Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 25 min read

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF NEW ZEALAND

CA216/03

BETWEENTHE UNIVERSITY OF WAIKATO


Appellant

ANDBENCHMARKING SERVICES LTD


First Respondent

ANDACCLIPSE ACCOUNTING LTD


Second Respondent

Hearing:26 April 2004

Coram:McGrath J
Glazebrook J
Randerson J

Appearances:  D L Marriott and I Finch for Appellants


D G Jones for Respondents

Judgment:11 June 2004 

JUDGMENT OF THE COURT DELIVERED BY RANDERSON J

Introduction

[1]       On 11 September 2003, Master Christiansen dismissed the appellant’s application for summary judgment against the respondents in proceedings alleging infringement of copyright.

[2]       For some 18 years, the Management Research Centre at the University of Waikato has compiled and published the results of an annual survey entitled “New Zealand Business Benchmarking Survey”.  The survey compiles financial data relating to New Zealand businesses.  It provides benchmark information for a large number of New Zealand industry groups which is then available for use by businesses as a tool to compare operating performance with industry standards.

[3]       The survey comprises three main stages:

a)Data collection;

b)Analysis and calculation;  and

c)Reporting.

[4]       Client accounting firms register with the Management Research Centre (MRC) and provide financial and other data from their clients’ business records on a confidential basis.  The process starts with the completion of a questionnaire developed by the MRC which seeks information from the accounting firms on revenue, expenditure, profitability and other details.  The MRC then analyses the data and calculates various ratios from it.  Examples of such ratios include the percentage of specified overhead items to total overheads, the percentage of operating profit as a percentage of income, and net profit as a percentage of total income.  The results for all participants are also tabulated for comparative purposes under headings such as the 25th percentile, the median, the 75th percentile, average result, and the average of the best three participants in 176 different business classifications.

[5]       After the data is gathered and the ratios calculated, the results are formatted and presented in a printed report and in a CD‑ROM version of it.  The survey is then published for sale each year and provided to the participating accounting firms.

[6]       In late 2002, the manager of the MRC, Mr R J Douglas, received information that a rival benchmark survey known as BenchmarkIT was in the course of development.  He gained access via the internet to a website being operated by the second respondent, Acclipse Accounting Ltd of Christchurch.  The website home page contained a link to BenchmarkIT with a further link to a Sample Business Benchmark Report.  This report had a sample page displayed for a lawnmowing business for the year ended 31 March 2001.  It appeared to Mr Douglas that the report on the website was an exact copy of the layout and ratios used in MRC’s 2001 survey.  Mr Douglas accepted that the data was different but the majority of the ratios used were, he considered, exactly the same. 

[7]       In February 2003, a copy of the BenchmarkIT brochure was obtained.  It is not in dispute that the brochure…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read University of Waikato v Benchmarking Services Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2004] NZCA 90
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Court of Appeal of New Zealand heard an appeal by the University of Waikato against a decision of the Master, who dismissed the appellant’s application for summary judgment against the respondents, Benchmarking Services Ltd and Acclipse Accounting Ltd, in proceedings alleging infringement of copyright. The University of Waikato claimed that the respondents had infringed its copyright in the New Zealand Business Benchmarking Survey by reproducing a substantial part of the work. The respondents denied the allegations. The Court of Appeal allowed the appeal and granted the appellant relief in the form of a declaration that the respondents had breached the appellant’s copyright and an injunction against the respondents. The court found that the respondents had copied a substantial part of the appellant’s report in the printed and electronic versions, but the appellant had not shown there was no defence to the claim for copyright in the questionnaire.

The legal issues the Court of Appeal was required to decide were whether the respondents had infringed the appellant’s copyright and whether summary judgment was appropriate in this case. The Court of Appeal held that the respondents had infringed the appellant’s copyright in the printed and electronic versions of the report but not in the questionnaire. The court found that the Master had erred in declining to enter summary judgment. The Court of Appeal held that the appellant had demonstrated that the respondents had no defence to the claim that they had infringed its copyright in the subject report, both in the printed and electronic versions. However, the appellant had not shown there was no defence to the claim for copyright in the questionnaire. The court found that the Master had erred in declining to enter summary judgment. The appeal was allowed, and relief was granted to the appellant in the form of a declaration that the respondents had breached the appellant’s copyright and an injunction against the respondents. All remaining matters, including damages, were remitted to the High Court for determination. The appellant was entitled to costs in this court and in the High Court. The Court of Appeal awarded the appellant costs in this court of $6000, together with reasonable disbursements including travel and accommodation costs of two counsel to be agreed by the parties or, failing agreement, to be fixed by the Registrar.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established