Twentieth Century Fox Film Corporation v Dotcom

Link copied
Case Copied 20 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND AUCKLAND REGISTRY

CIV-2014-404-001272 [2016] NZHC 88

BETWEEN

TWENTIETH CENTURY FOX FILM

CORPORATION, DISNEY ENTERPRISES INC, PARAMOUNT PICTURES CORPORATION, UNIVERSAL CITY STUDIOS PRODUCTIONS LLLP, WARNER BROS ENTERTAINMENT INC.

Applicants

AND

KIM DOTCOM First Respondent

intituling cont'd over…

Hearing: 18 December 2015

Appearances:

M C Sumpter and L L Fraser for Applicants
S L Cogan and H Wild for First Respondent
L L C Cooney (excused) for Second Respondent
A R B Barker and A J Steele for Fourth Respondent

D J Boldt and A Dixon for Interested Party (Commissioner) M J Gavin for Recording Industry

J E M Lethbridge for Custodians

Judgment:

5 February 2016

JUDGMENT OF COURTNEY J [Reasons]

TWENTIETH CENTURY FOX FILM CORPORATION & ORS v DOTCOM & ORS [2016] NZHC 88 [5

February 2016]

BRAM VAN DER KOLK Second Respondent

RSV HOLDINGS LIMITED (FORMERLY KNOWN AS MEGASTUFF LIMITED) Third Respondent

COATESVILLE TRUSTEE SERVICES LIMITED

Fourth Respondent

MD CORPORATE TRUSTEE LIMITED Fifth Respondent

MONA DOTCOM Interested Party

COMMISSIONER OF POLICE Interested Party

Introduction

[1]      The applicants in this proceeding are a group of US film studios.   In civil proceedings brought in the United Sates they allege large scale breaches of copyright by Mr Dotcom and others.  In 2015 they obtained a freezing order over Mr Dotcom’s assets  and,  subsequently,  over  the  assets  of  the  Trust  Me  Trust,  alleging  that Mr Dotcom is the beneficial owner of the trust’s assets (the named beneficiaries are Mr Dotcom’s former wife, Mona Dotcom, and their children).

[2]      One of the frozen assets is 5H The Prom, Coatesville, which Mr Dotcom, owns.1   In December 2015 I dismissed Mr Dotcom’s application to vary the freezing order to allow him to use that property as security for personal borrowings that he planned to on-lend to the trustee of the Trust Me Trust, Coatesville Trustee Service Ltd (CTSL).  CTSL is a shareholder in Mega Ltd and need the funds to participate in a rights issue offered by the company.

[3]      In this judgment I give reasons for my decisions (1) rejecting Mr Dotcom’s challenge to the standing of the Commissioner of Police to be heard (2) dismissing Mr Dotcom’s application and (3) refusing to require the studios to give an extended undertaking in favour of CTSL.

Standing of the Commissioner of Police

[4]      The Commissioner originally became an interested party in this proceeding by virtue of an agreement between Mr Dotcom, the studios and the Commissioner; the Commissioner withdrew his application to register a foreign restraining order against Mr Dotcom’s assets under the Mutual Assistance in Criminal Matters Act

1992 on the basis that all Mr Dotcom’s assets would be the subject of the civil freezing order obtained by the studios so that the Commissioner’s interest would be adequately protected.  However, in submissions filed in support of the application to vary the freezing order Mr Dotcom asserted that the Commissioner of Police lacked

standing to oppose the application.  Given the pressure of time, it was agreed that I

1      Under…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Twentieth Century Fox Film Corporation v Dotcom and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2016] NZHC 88
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The applicants in this proceeding are a group of US film studios. In civil proceedings brought in the United States, they allege large-scale breaches of copyright by Mr Dotcom and others. In December 2015, the applicants obtained a freezing order over Mr Dotcom’s assets and, subsequently, over the assets of the Trust Me Trust, alleging that Mr Dotcom is the beneficial owner of the trust’s assets. Mr Dotcom sought to vary the freezing order to allow him to use one of the frozen assets as security for personal borrowings that he planned to on-lend to Coatesville Trustee Service Ltd (CTSL). CTSL is a shareholder in Mega Ltd and needs the funds to participate in a rights issue offered by the company. The court dismissed Mr Dotcom’s application to vary the freezing order and refused to require the studios to give an extended undertaking in favour of CTSL.

The legal issues the court was required to decide included whether the Commissioner of Police had standing to be heard in the proceeding, whether the court should vary the freezing order, and whether the studios should be required to provide an extended undertaking in favour of CTSL. The court rejected Mr Dotcom’s challenge to the standing of the Commissioner of Police to be heard. The court dismissed Mr Dotcom’s application to vary the freezing order on the basis that the risk to the restrained assets was too high to justify varying the order to allow 5H The Prom to be used as security for Mr Dotcom’s proposed borrowing. The court refused to require the studios to give an extended undertaking to CTSL to abide by any court order in respect of damages sustained as a result of the refusal to vary the freezing order. The court held that the undertakings provided at the outset apply to all respondents, including those subsequently joined to the proceeding. The court did not accept CTSL’s complaint that the studios’ position was artificial.

The court's reasoning and outcome were based on the principles of the interests of justice and the purpose of the freezing order. The court held that the power to vary a freezing order is a residual discretion and that any variation should recognise both the purpose of the freezing order and the fact that the jurisdiction is not intended to provide security over the respondent’s assets. The court considered the overall justice of allowing the payment to be made, including the likely consequences of permitting it to be made and if it was not permitted to be made. The court held that the proposed variation was not in the interests of justice because it was so speculative that the borrowed funds were likely to be lost altogether, with the consequent loss of 5H The Prom because neither Mr Dotcom nor CTSL had any other means of repaying the loan. The court refused to require the studios to give an extended undertaking to CTSL because there was no basis on which to require a more extensive undertaking than would usually be given. The court held that CTSL’s risk was the potential loss of value if it could not participate in the rights issue, which was a step that CTSL would be free to undertake if it could do so using its own assets. The court held that the studios’ position was not artificial.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established