TTAH Limited v Koninklijke Ten Cate N.V

Link copied
Case Copied 25 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND AUCKLAND REGISTRY

CIV-2010-404-8250 [2012] NZHC 1402

BETWEEN  TTAH LIMITED First Plaintiff

ANDTT INVESTORS LIMITED Second Plaintiff

AND  KONINKLIJKE TEN CATE N.V.

First Defendant

ANDROYAL TEN CATE USA INC Second Defendant

ANDTEN CATE UK LIMITED Third Defendant

Hearing:         18 June 2012

Counsel:         D Salmon and E D Nilsson for Plaintiffs

G K Holm-Hansen for Defendants

Judgment:      18 June 2012

ORAL JUDGMENT OF ASSOCIATE JUDGE R M BELL

Solicitors:

LeeSalmonLong (D Salmon) P O Box 2026 Auckland 1140, for Plaintiffs

Email:   davey.salmon@lsl.co.nz / Daniel.Nilsson@lsl.co.nz

Simpson Grierson, Private Bag 92518 Auckland 1140, for Defendants

Email:   glen.holm-hansen@simpsongrierson.com

Copy for:

Alan R Galbraith QC, P O Box 4338 Auckland 1140

Email:   argalbraith@shortlandchambers.co.nz

Case Officer:      Peter.Gayaman@justice.govt.nz

TTAH LIMITED V KONINKLIJKE TEN CATE N.V. HC AK CIV-2010-404-8250 [18 June 2012]

[1]      The defendants apply for orders striking out or staying the proceeding.  The plaintiffs oppose and cross-apply for summary judgment.  This decision deals with both applications.  Both applications have been heard in court, as the plaintiffs have applied for summary judgment.

[2]     The plaintiffs started this proceeding in December 2011 but filed their application for summary judgment on 5 June 2012.  Under r 12.4(2), they need leave to apply for summary judgment. The defendants oppose leave being granted.

The acquisition agreement

[3]      The proceeding arises out of an acquisition agreement of 4 February 2009. The plaintiffs are the vendors and the defendants are the purchasers.  The first and second plaintiffs are New Zealand holding companies.   The first defendant is a holding company based in Almelo, The Netherlands.   The second defendant is a Delaware corporation with its offices in Georgia, Atlanta, United States.  The third defendant is a British company based in Hertfordshire, England.  I will refer to the plaintiffs as “TigerTurf” and the defendants as “Ten Cate”.

[4]      Until 31 March 2009 the plaintiffs were 100 per cent owners of shares in various TigerTurf operating companies:  TigerTurf NZ Ltd, a New Zealand company, TigerTurf (UK) Ltd, a company registered in the United Kingdom, and TigerSports Americas Inc, a United States corporation.  TigerTurf NZ Ltd, in turn, owned 100 per cent of the shares in TigerTurf Australia Pty Ltd.   These operating companies were also parties to the acquisition agreement.   Other parties to the acquisition agreement were trustees of the G and H Vivian Family Trust (shareholders of the holding companies) and Graham Vivian and Helen Vivian, directors of the holding companies.

[5]      Up  until  March  2009  the  vendors  and  the  operating  companies  together operated as the TigerTurf Group in New Zealand, Australia, the United Kingdom and

the United States in designing, developing, manufacturing and selling artificial turf products,   including   playing   surfaces   for   sports   fields   and   for   landscaping applications.  Apparently the playing surfaces for sports fields included grounds for American football.

[6]      The acquisition agreement provided for Ten Cate to buy 49 per cent of the shares  in  each  of the issued share  capital  in TigerTurf  NZ, TigerTurf UK,  and TigerSports Americas Inc for the sum of $NZ27,225,000.  The initial settlement…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read TTAH Limited v Koninklijke Ten Cate N.V and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2012] NZHC 1402
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The parties to the proceeding are TTAH Limited and TT Investors Limited, collectively referred to as TigerTurf, and Koninklijke Ten Cate N.V. and others, collectively referred to as Ten Cate. The dispute arises out of an acquisition agreement for the purchase by Ten Cate of shares in various TigerTurf operating companies. The legal issues that the court was required to decide were whether Ten Cate could commence a proceeding for breach of warranty before the expert under the acquisition agreement gives his determination, whether Ten Cate was required to go through the dispute procedure under clause 34 before starting a proceeding for breach of warranty under clause 30, whether Ten Cate was entitled to begin a proceeding for breach of warranty in a court outside New Zealand, whether TigerTurf had a cause of action to require payment, whether TigerTurf could demand payment of the purchase price under Option II before the expert gives his determination under clause 30.4, whether TigerTurf was entitled to bring a proceeding to enforce its claim for payment independently of Ten Cate’s claim against it for breach of warranty, whether TigerTurf was required to go through the dispute procedure in clause 34 before issuing its proceeding, and whether it was fatal to Ten Cate’s case that it would not raise a claim for breach of warranty in this proceeding.

The court held that Ten Cate could commence a proceeding for breach of warranty before the expert gives his determination, that Ten Cate was not required to go through the dispute procedure under clause 34 before starting a proceeding for breach of warranty under clause 30, that Ten Cate was entitled to begin a proceeding for breach of warranty in a court outside New Zealand, that TigerTurf had a cause of action to require payment, that TigerTurf could not demand payment of the purchase price under Option II before the expert gives his determination under clause 30.4, that TigerTurf was entitled to bring a proceeding to enforce its claim for payment independently of Ten Cate’s claim against it for breach of warranty, that TigerTurf was not required to go through the dispute procedure in clause 34 before issuing its proceeding, and that it was not fatal to Ten Cate’s case that it would not raise a claim for breach of warranty in this proceeding.

The court dismissed Ten Cate’s application for strike-out and stay, and ordered Ten Cate to file and serve a statement of defence within 15 working days. The court also adjourned TigerTurf’s application for leave to apply for summary judgment while reserving leave to bring that matter on for hearing, and granted leave to amend that application in the light of further developments under clause 30. The court did not direct any further steps in this proceeding and did not direct a case management conference, but it reserved leave to the parties to seek a case management conference or to apply for further orders. The court made no order as to costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established