Trustees Executors Ltd v Perpetual Trust Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 12 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND AUCKLAND REGISTRY

CIV 2012-404-3569 [2012] NZHC 1678

BETWEEN  TRUSTEES EXECUTORS LTD Plaintiff

ANDPERPETUAL TRUST LTD Defendant

Hearing:         12 July 2012

Counsel:         C M Stevens and A L Holloway for Plaintiff

J R Billington QC and S E Fitzgerald for Defendant

Judgment:      12 July 2012

(ORAL) JUDGMENT OF HEATH J

Solicitors:

Russell McVeagh, PO Box 8, Auckland Phillips Fox, PO Box 2791, Wellington Counsel:

J R Billington QC, PO Box4338, Shortland Street, Auckland

Copy to:

Financial Markets Authority, PO Box 1179, Wellington

H Rennie QC, PO Box 10242, Wellington

TRUSTEES EXECUTORS LTD V PERPETUAL TRUST LTD HC AK CIV 2012-404-3569 [12 July 2012]

Introduction

[1]      Trustees  Executors  Ltd  is  the  statutory  supervisor  of  two  participatory securities of which Perpetual Trust Ltd is trustee.   Those funds are known as the Perpetual  Cash  Fund  (the  Cash  Fund)  and  the  Perpetual  Mortgage  Fund  (the Mortgage Fund).

[2]      Trustees Executors has applied for orders under s 49 of the Securities Act

1978 (the Act).  Those orders have been sought because the statutory supervisor has formed an opinion that there is “a significant risk that the interests of the security holders” would be “materially prejudiced” if orders were not made.1

[3]      Two substantive themes emerge.  One relates to confidence.  The other relates to the value of securities, from which moneys repaying a loan to Torchlight Fund No 1 LP (Torchlight) may need to be sourced.

The history of the proceeding

[4]      This application was first listed before me on 26 June 2012, at the same time that I heard an application by the Financial Markets Authority (the Authority) to lift confidentiality orders made in a proceeding that Perpetual had brought against it.  I heard the latter application first.  I discharged the confidentiality orders and directed that the content of my judgment on that application could be published and made an order that the Court file not be searched, copied or inspected, without leave of a

Judge.2    Perpetual appealed against that judgment.   Its appeal was dismissed on 4

July 2012, by the Court of Appeal.3

[5]      At the end of the hearing on 26 June 2012, I gave a series of directions to enable Trustees Executors’ application to be dealt with this week.  I ordered that the Authority be served with any papers filed in this proceeding.  While the Authority

has been served, it did not seek to be heard on today’s application.

1      Securities Act 1978, s 49(1)(a).

2      Perpetual Trust Ltd v Financial Markets Authority [2012] NZHC 1469.

3      Perpetual Trust Ltd v Financial Markets Authority [2012] NZCA 298.

[6]      Today, I have heard from counsel for Trustees Executors and Perpetual on whether it is necessary to make any orders under s 49 “to protect the interests of holders of securities, or members of the public”.4     I do not propose to say much about the issues that have been discussed in Court, as sensible arrangements have now been made for interim orders to…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Trustees Executors Ltd v Perpetual Trust Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2012] NZHC 1678
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Trustees Executors Ltd, the statutory supervisor of the Perpetual Cash Fund and the Perpetual Mortgage Fund, brought an application against Perpetual Trust Ltd, the trustee of the funds, seeking orders under section 49 of the Securities Act 1978 to protect the interests of security holders. The application arose due to concerns about the value of securities and the repayment of a loan to Torchlight Fund No 1 LP. The court had to determine whether it was necessary to make any orders under section 49 to protect the interests of security holders or the public.

The court found that it was necessary to make some orders to protect the interests of security holders and the public. To achieve this, the court appointed Observers to oversee the activities of the Perpetual board, in relation to management of the Cash Fund and the Mortgage Fund. Additionally, the court required independent valuation reports on the properties in respect of which securities had been granted. The cost of the valuation was to be borne by Perpetual out of its own assets, not the assets of either of the funds. The court also made orders to suspend redemption payments to investors in the Perpetual Mortgage Fund for a period of eight weeks, and required Perpetual to give undertakings to the Authority and the statutory supervisor to enhance market confidence.

The court made the following directions in relation to the proceeding: adjourned the proceeding until 10am on 3 August 2012 for further hearing; directed that evidence of valuation of each of the properties over which securities had been granted shall be filed and served by Trustees Executors on or before 25 July 2012; directed that a joint affidavit from the two Observers shall be filed and served on or before 25 July 2012; directed that any further affidavits from Trustees Executors shall be filed and served on or before 27 July 2012; directed that any further affidavits from Perpetual shall be filed and served on or before 30 July 2012; directed that submissions from counsel shall be filed and exchanged contemporaneously, by 3pm on 31 July 2012; directed that counsel for Perpetual shall arrange for an updated bundle of relevant documents to be filed and served by 3pm on 31 July 2012; and directed that all deponents, unless expressly excused by counsel for the opposing party, shall be available for cross-examination at the next hearing on 2 or 3 August 2012.

The court appointed Ms Vivian Fatupaito and Mr Christopher Duffy as Observers until further order of the court. The Observers were entitled to attend Perpetual board meetings, in relation to the Funds; ask questions of board members of Perpetual, regarding the Torchlight advances; have full access to any information provided by Perpetual to its investors and/or its investors’ advisors, with respect to the Torchlight advances; and access any information from Perpetual that was necessary (in their opinion) to identify the flow of cash, in relation to the Torchlight advance from Perpetual, to the ultimate beneficiaries of those moneys. The costs and reasonable expenses incurred by Trustees Executors in commissioning the valuation reports were to be borne by Perpetual out of its own resources, as were the reasonable costs and expenses incurred by Ms Fatupaito and Mr Duffy (or their alternates) as Observers. All questions of costs on the substantive s 49 application were reserved, to be dealt with at the next hearing. The court confirmed that an order previously made, that the Court file not be searched, copied or inspected without leave of a Judge, on notice to the parties, remained in force pending further order of the court.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established