IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF NEW ZEALAND
CA312/2009
[2009] NZCA 574BETWEENTRUSTEES EXECUTORS LIMITED
Appellant
ANDJOSEPH LAWRENCE WOOD TURNBULL
First RespondentANDJOAN TURNBULL
Second Respondent
Hearing:21 October 2009
Court:Arnold, Randerson and Allan JJ
Counsel:G J Toebes and R J Gordon for Appellant
N Cervin for First and Second Respondent
Judgment:8 December 2009 at 3 pm
JUDGMENT OF THE COURT
AThe first and second respondents are granted leave to adduce further evidence.
BThe appeal is dismissed.
C The appellant must pay the first and second respondents costs for a standard appeal on a band A basis.
REASONS OF THE COURT
(Given by Arnold J)
[1] The appellant, Trustees Executors Limited (TEL), sued the first and second respondents, Mr and Mrs Turnbull, for sums outstanding under a loan agreement, which was secured by a mortgage on a commercial property, and sought summary judgment. Associate Judge Sargisson declined to grant summary judgment, on the ground that the Turnbulls had a genuinely arguable defence that it would be unconscionable to enforce the loan agreement: HC AK CIV 2008-404-1511 1 May 2009. TEL now appeals against that refusal.
Factual background
[2] On 18 October 2006 Mr and Mrs Turnbull (then aged 70 and 64 years respectively) signed a loan application addressed to TEL seeking a loan of $4 million for five years on an interest only basis. The application:
(a)Indicated that Mr Turnbull was self-employed and had been engaged in property investment and rental accommodation for seven years, and that Mrs Turnbull was an officer manager who had been working for Work and Income New Zealand for three years.
(b)Stated that the purpose of the loan was to purchase a residential investment property at 74 – 76 Upper Queen Street, Auckland (the Queen Street property).
(c)Identified the purchase price of the Queen Street property as being $5.5 million (against a registered valuation of $5.45 million), and said that the Turnbulls were contributing $1.2 million towards the price and that “other funds” of $300,000 were available, leaving a balance of $4 million to be borrowed.
[3] The details of the Turnbulls’ income and expenditure stated in the loan application included the following:
(a)The gross annual incomes of Mr and Mrs Turnbull were $30,000 and $38,000 respectively.
(b)The annual income from the Queen Street property would be $477,360.
(c)The Turnbulls owned two properties (in addition to the Queen Street property), namely a property on West Coast Road, Glen Eden, worth $1.2 million and one on Cochrane Avenue, Arkles Bay, worth $755,000, vehicles, tools and computers worth $88,000, electronic goods, appliances and personal effects worth $130,000 and deposits of $12,500. Accordingly, the application indicated that the Turnbulls had total assets (including the Queen Street property) of just under $8 million and total liabilities (including the proposed loan) of just under $4 million.
The application identified the Turnbulls’ solicitor as being Ms Hart of Parnell Law.
[4] The application was submitted to TEL by Mr Mayer, who controlled a company called North Star Holdings Limited, which was the…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Trustees Executors Limited v Turnbull and Turnbull and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2009] NZCA 574
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The key issue in the case was whether the Turnbulls had a qualifying disability that made the loan agreement unconscionable, and whether TEL knew or should have known of this disability and took advantage of it. The Turnbulls argued that they had placed complete trust in their son, Simon Turnbull, and did not receive independent legal advice. The court found that there was sufficient doubt about the Turnbulls' understanding of the transaction and the role of their solicitor, Ms Hart, to warrant a refusal to grant summary judgment. The new evidence presented by the Turnbulls raised serious questions about TEL's loan practices and the Turnbulls' capacity to meet their commitments. The Court of Appeal concluded that the Turnbulls' case was not strong, but there was enough doubt to justify a refusal to grant summary judgment.
The Court of Appeal granted the Turnbulls leave to adduce further evidence and dismissed the appeal. TEL was ordered to pay the Turnbulls' costs for a standard appeal on a band A basis and usual disbursements.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi