IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND AUCKLAND REGISTRY
I TE KŌTI MATUA O AOTEAROA TĀMAKI MAKAURAU ROHE
CIV-2016-404-2896
[2018] NZHC 1191
BETWEEN MICHAELENA MARY TROTT
Plaintiff
AND
DEBORAH JOSEPHINE BARNETT
First Defendant
ELAINE LILLIAN SMITH
Second Defendant
Hearing: 5 March 2018 Appearances:
P T Finnigan for Plaintiff S J Tee for Defendant
Judgment:
25 May 2018
JUDGMENT OF PALMER J
This judgment is delivered by me on 25 May 2018 at 3.00 pm pursuant to r 11.5 of the High Court Rules.
.....................................................
Registrar / Deputy Registrar
Counsel/Solicitors:
P T Finnigan, Barrister, Auckland Foley Hughes Lawyers, Auckland Morton Tee & Co, Auckland
TROTT v BARNETT [2018] NZHC 1191 [25 May 2018]
Summary
[1] Mrs Michaelena Trott, the plaintiff, is engaged in litigation with the daughters of her late husband, the defendants Ms Deborah Barnett and Ms Elaine Smith. Mrs Trott claims Ms Barnett and Ms Smith are unlawfully leasing her a leaky home and seeks compensation. They counterclaim she holds funds on trust for them under their father’s will. Mrs Trott applies to strike out the counterclaim and to require security for costs. I decline the applications because the counterclaim may be tenable on the pleadings and I am not satisfied Ms Barnett and Ms Smith could not pay costs. I make orders for discovery and for costs.
What happened?
[2] Mrs Trott is now 87 years old. Ms Barnett and Ms Smith are the daughters of Mrs Trott’s late husband Mr Bob Trott. In 1997, Mr and Mrs Trott sold a house at Tairua, in the Coromandel, to Ms Barnett and Ms Smith. The sale was subject to a lease giving Mr and Mrs Trott the right to occupy the property for life.
[3]Mr Trott died in 2006. His will provided, amongst other things:
4 I give all my shares in GRAND SLAM HOLDINGS LIMITED (“the company”) which I may own at the date of my death to my trustees UPON TRUST:
(a)To pay and apply all or any income received from the company in respect of the shares first towards taxation and administration and accountancy costs relating to shares, secondly for the benefit of my wife MICHAELENA MARY TROTT (“my wife”) during her lifetime in such sum or sums in each year as my trustees in their absolute and unanimous discretion may determine depending upon my wife’s needs, and circumstances at the time, and thirdly in respect of any income not already paid or applied or appropriated, to a capital fund; and
(b)Upon the death of my wife, if my trustees are themselves directors of the company or if not, to direct the directors of the company, to wind up the company and to pay one-half of the net proceeds to which my estate may be entitled upon the liquidation by virtue of my shareholding together with any capital fund accumulated out of income to my said daughters ELAINE LILLIAN SMITH and DEBORAH JOSEPHINE BARNETT in equal shares and to pay the other half to the sons…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Trott v Barnett and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2018] NZHC 1191
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court addressed the application to strike out the counterclaim. Mrs Trott argued that the defendants’ constructive trust claim was untenable and should be dismissed. She claimed that under the will, she either owned 100 per cent or 50 per cent of the funds in question, and in either case, she could not have had sufficient knowledge to impose liability upon her as a constructive trustee. However, the court found it was premature to strike out the counterclaim, as whether Mrs Trott had sufficient knowledge would depend on interpretation of the will and the circumstances surrounding the shareholders’ account being paid out to Mrs Trott. These matters would depend on the evidence adduced at trial. The court also found that it would be premature to strike out the counterclaim on grounds of limitation.
The court also considered the application for security for costs. Mrs Trott argued that there was reason to believe the defendants would be unable to pay her costs if they were unsuccessful in their counterclaim. However, the court found that the defendants’ affidavits were evidence they were likely to be able to pay the costs if unsuccessful. Therefore, the court declined Mrs Trott's application for security for costs.
Finally, the court granted the defendants’ application for tailored discovery. The defendants sought discovery for their expert witness to complete his enquiry into the status and ownership of shareholders’ account entitlements and/or treatment of capital in GSHL. The court ordered discovery as sought by the defendants.
The court declined Mrs Trott's applications for strike-out and security for costs, granted the defendants' application for tailored discovery, and awarded costs to the defendants on a 2B basis plus disbursements.
Orders
Orders of the court
Full text does not contain this section.
Background
Background to the litigation
Full text does not contain this section.
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Full text does not contain this section.
Decision
Reasons for decision
Full text does not contain this section.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
Full text does not contain this section.