Trent v Canterbury Regional Council

Link copied
Case Copied 16 min read

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF NEW ZEALAND

I TE KŌTI PĪRA O AOTEAROA

 CA257/2020
 [2021] NZCA 123

BETWEEN

RUSSELL WILLIAM TRENT
Applicant

AND

CANTERBURY REGIONAL COUNCIL
Respondent

Hearing:

17 March 2021

Court:

French, Ellis and Muir JJ

Counsel:

T J Mackenzie and A L Hollingworth for Applicant
T J McGuigan and V M Sugrue for Respondent

Judgment:

21 April 2021 at 9 am

JUDGMENT OF THE COURT

The application for leave to bring a second appeal is declined.

____________________________________________________________________

REASONS OF THE COURT

(Given by French J)

  1. Mr Trent and his employer Emergent Cold Ltd[1] both pleaded guilty to a charge of discharging a contaminant onto land in circumstances that might result in the contaminant entering water in breach of s 15(1)(b) of the Resource Management Act 1991.  Judge Dwyer imposed a fine of $145,350 on the company and a fine of $97,000 on Mr Trent.[2]

    [1]At the time of the offending, the company was known as Polarcold Ltd.

    [2]Canterbury Regional Council v Emergent Cold Ltd [2019] NZDC 23930 [Sentencing notes].

  2. Mr Trent appealed his sentence to the High Court.  The appeal was dismissed by Nation J.[3]

  3. Dissatisfied with that outcome, Mr Trent now wishes to appeal to this Court.  Because such an appeal would be a second appeal, leave is required.[4]

    [4]Criminal Procedure Act 2011, s 237.

  4. The focus of the proposed appeal is the significance (if any) that should be attributed to the fact that under the Resource Management Act there is a difference between the maximum monetary penalty to which companies and individuals are respectively liable for committing the offence of discharging a contaminant.  For companies, the maximum fine is $600,000.  For individuals, it is $300,000.[5]

Background

The facts of the offending

[5]Resource Management Act 1991, s 339(1).

  1. The company operates a temperature-controlled warehousing and cold storage business.  Mr Trent is employed as its South Island Engineering Manager.  He was a long serving and highly regarded employee.

  2. On 3 April 2018, the company instructed Mr Trent to purge some vintage compressors of ammonia vapours to enable their safe removal to a motor museum.

  3. Mr Trent undertook this task using a purging tank that was situated in close proximity to a gutter.  The gutter directed water into the Christchurch City Council’s storm water system.  The purging process took five hours during which time Mr Trent attempted to control the smell of ammonia by adding more water to the tank to top it up.  As a result, there was an overflow from the tank of ammonia or ammonia contaminated water.  There was no secondary containment system around the base of the purging tank to contain any spillage.  There was also a small leak in the purging line going to the tank which Mr Trent said he fixed.

  4. Section 15(1)(b) of the Resource Management Act relevantly provides that no person may discharge any containment onto land in circumstances which may result in the contaminant entering…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Trent v Canterbury Regional Council and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2021] NZCA 123
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In this case, the applicant, Russell William Trent, appeals against the decision of the High Court dismissing his appeal against his sentence for discharging a contaminant onto land in breach of the Resource Management Act 1991. The respondent, Canterbury Regional Council, opposes the application for leave to appeal. The key issue for the Court of Appeal was whether the sentencing Judge erred in not taking into account the difference between the maximum monetary penalty for corporate offenders and individuals when setting the starting point for Mr Trent's sentence. The Court of Appeal held that there is no tenable basis for an argument that where a company and an individual are being sentenced in respect of the same offending, the starting point must always equate in a proportionate way to the difference in the maximum penalties. The Court concluded that this case does not raise a question of general or public importance which should be submitted for determination to this Court. The Court also found that there was no miscarriage of justice that would warrant a second appeal. Therefore, the application for leave to bring a second appeal is declined.

Background

Background to the litigation

Russell William Trent, employed as the South Island Engineering Manager by Emergent Cold Ltd, was tasked with purging vintage compressors of ammonia vapours to enable their safe removal to a motor museum. On 3 April 2018, Trent undertook this task using a purging tank near a gutter that directed water into the Christchurch City Council’s stormwater system. During the five-hour purging process, Trent attempted to control the smell of ammonia by adding more water to the tank, leading to an overflow of ammonia or ammonia-contaminated water. This overflow, estimated by Trent to be between 200 to 400 litres, flowed into the gutter and eventually into the Kaputone Creek, resulting in a significant fish kill and cultural impact on local iwi. Both Emergent Cold Ltd and Trent were charged with breaching the Resource Management Act by discharging a contaminant onto land in circumstances that might result in the contaminant entering water. They pleaded guilty, and Trent was fined $97,000 by the District Court.

Following the sentencing in the District Court, Trent appealed to the High Court, challenging the fine's appropriateness in relation to the maximum penalties set out in the Resource Management Act. The High Court dismissed the appeal, finding no error in the District Court's sentencing methodology and concluding that the fine was within the range of sentences reasonably available. Dissatisfied with this outcome, Trent sought leave to appeal to the Court of Appeal, arguing that the difference in maximum penalties between corporate and individual offenders should have been taken into account in setting the starting point for his fine.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Does the difference in maximum monetary penalties between corporate and individual offenders require a sentencing judge to necessarily arrive at a monetary starting point that reflects that difference?
2. Can an appeal be based on the argument that a miscarriage of justice may have occurred or may occur unless the appeal is heard?

Held
1. The Court held that the difference in maximum monetary penalties between corporate and individual offenders does not require a sentencing judge to necessarily arrive at a monetary starting point that reflects that difference.
2. The Court held that the application for leave to bring a second appeal is declined, as there was no tenable basis for an argument that a miscarriage of justice may have occurred or may occur unless the appeal is heard.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Court began by noting that sentencing is an exercise in discretion and not a mathematical exercise. It observed that the argument made by Mr Trent's counsel, that the sentencing Judge was required to take the differing maximum penalties into account by incorporating the lower maximum penalty applying to Mr Trent into his starting point, was flawed. The Court held that there is no obligation on the part of a sentencing judge to take the difference in maximum penalties into account in setting a starting point for individual offenders. The Court explained that the maximum penalty for individual offenders for the offence in question is not a fine of $300,000 but rather a term of imprisonment of two years. The Court further held that the argument overlooks that the reason for the higher monetary penalty for companies is that Parliament regarded the need for the Court to be able to impose meaningful penalties that will carry the necessary punitive and deterrent effect on large commercial organisations. The Court found that the decision in Waslander v Southland Regional Council was strongly supported by the legislative materials which led to the enactment of the Resource Management (Simplifying and Streamlining) Amendment Act 2009. The Court concluded that the difference in the maximum monetary penalties does not require a sentencing Judge to necessarily arrive at a monetary starting point which reflects that difference. The Court also held that there was no tenable basis for an argument that a miscarriage of justice may have occurred or may occur unless the appeal is heard. The Court found that the sentence imposed on Mr Trent was within the range of sentences reasonably available to the sentencing Judge and that there was no error in the District Court’s sentencing methodology.