Tranter v Chief Executive Officer Manawatu Prison

Link copied
Case Copied 13 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND PALMERSTON NORTH REGISTRY

I TE KŌTI MATUA O AOTEAROA TE PAPAIOEA ROHE

CIV-2021-454-043

[2022] NZHC 599

BETWEEN

DAVID STANLEY TRANTER

Applicant

AND

CHIEF EXECUTIVE OFFICER MANAWATU PRISON

First Respondent

AND

W R BENSEMANN

Second Respondent

Hearing: On the papers

Appearances:

Self-represented Applicant

B D Vanderkolk for the First Respondent

Judgment:

29 March 2022


JUDGMENT OF COOKE J


[1]                  In these proceedings Mr Tranter, who is an inmate at Manawatu Prison, seeks judicial review of two decisions made by the respondents relating to the terms of his incarceration. First, on or about 24 May 2021 Mr Tranter was dismissed from his employment as a “messman” at the prison. There is a dispute relating to the reason as to why he was dismissed from this position. Second, on 3 June 2021 the Visiting Justice, who is the second respondent, upheld on appeal Mr Tranter’s conviction for an offence against s 128(1)(a) of the Corrections Act 2004 (the Act). The relevant offence involved a failure to comply with prison rules relating to the taking of medication – in particular that he had failed to swallow pills he had been administered. He was ultimately sentenced to five days confinement (effectively solitary confinement) and 28 days of postponement of privileges.

TRANTER v CHIEF EXECUTIVE OFFICER MANAWATU PRISON [2022] NZHC 599 [29 March 2022]

[2]                  Mr Tranter represented himself in this judicial review and the parties agreed that it would be determined on the basis of the written materials that each had filed. The second defendant abides by the decision of the Court.

[3]                  In addressing the claims advanced by Mr Tranter in his document it seems to me that there are two primary grounds of challenge, namely:

(a)that his removal from employment as a messman was a punishment for his alleged wrongdoing in failing to swallow his pills, and that the subsequent formal punishment was an unlawful second punishment in conflict with his right in s 26 of the New Zealand Bill of Rights Act 1990; and

(b)that the Visiting Judge acted unlawfully in failing to allow Mr Tranter legal representation at the hearing before him, and that the conviction and sentence was unjustified.

First ground of challenge

[4]                  Mr Tranter contends that his dismissal as a messman was a punishment for the alleged misconduct in relation to his medication, and accordingly the subsequent formal penalty imposed was unlawful. In essence, Mr Tranter submits this constituted double jeopardy under s 26 of the New Zealand Bill of Rights Act 1990 as he alleges he was punished for the same offence twice.

[5]                  Mr Vanderkolk argued that employment decisions of this kind are not reviewable. Prisoner employment is generally governed by s 66 of the Act. The Act and regulations are silent as to what sort of conduct may result in dismissal. Section 66(1)(a) gives the prison manager discretion in relation to prisoners’ employment.1 This should be exercised in accordance with the principles of the Act.2


1      Corrections Act…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Tranter v Chief Executive Officer Manawatu Prison and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2022] NZHC 599
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The High Court of New Zealand was asked to review two decisions made by the Chief Executive Officer of Manawatu Prison and the Visiting Justice, regarding the incarceration of Mr David Stanley Tranter, a prisoner at Manawatu Prison. Mr Tranter sought judicial review of the dismissal from his position as a messman, and the subsequent formal punishment for an alleged failure to comply with prison rules relating to the taking of medication. The court was required to decide if the dismissal was a punishment for the alleged wrongdoing and if the subsequent formal punishment was unlawful, as well as if the Visiting Justice acted unlawfully by not allowing Mr Tranter legal representation at the hearing, and if the conviction and sentence were justified.

The court found that the dismissal of Mr Tranter from his employment as a messman was not a punishment for the alleged misconduct in relation to his medication, and the subsequent formal penalty was not unlawful. The court determined that employment decisions of this kind are not reviewable, and that the decision was made before Mr Tranter was charged with the medication offence. The court further found that the Visiting Justice did not make an unlawful decision in declining Mr Tranter's request for legal representation, as the charges were not serious or complex, and could be dealt with by Mr Tranter without legal assistance. However, the court held that the elements of the charge were not properly proved, as there was no evidence of an instruction to swallow the pills, and the findings of the Visiting Justice were not based on a failure to properly open his mouth on a mouth check, but an alleged failure to obey instructions when not swallowing the pills in the first place.

The court quashed the conviction and directed that there is no need for the charges to be reheard, given the comparatively minor nature of the charge, and that Mr Tranter has served any penalty he may be sentenced to.