Thurlow Consulting Engineers & Surveyors Ltd v Auckland Council

Link copied
Case Copied 36 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND AUCKLAND REGISTRY

CIV 2013-404-3034

[2013] NZHC 2468

UNDER the Resource Management Act 1991

BETWEEN

THURLOW CONSULTING ENGINEERS & SURVEYORS LTD

Appellant

AND

AUCKLAND COUNCIL

Respondent

Hearing: 17 September 2013

Counsel:

M E Casey QC for Appellant

G C Lanning and W M Bangma for Respondent

Judgment:

20 September 2013

JUDGMENT OF HEATH J

This judgment was delivered by me on 20 September 2013 at 3.00pm pursuant to Rule 11.5 of the High Court Rules

Registrar/Deputy Registrar

Solicitors:

Cooper Rapley, Palmerston North Simpson Grierson, Auckland Counsel:

M E Casey QC, Auckland

THURLOW CONSULTING ENGINEERS & SURVEYORS LTD v AUCKLAND COUNCIL [2013] NZHC

2468 [20 September 2013]

The appeal

[1]   Thurlow Consulting Engineers & Surveyors Ltd (Thurlow) appeals against the amount of an order for costs made in its favour, in the Environment Court.1

[2] Following a successful appeal2 against a plan change to the North Shore District Plan, Thurlow applied to the Environment Court for costs. The Court ordered the Auckland Council (the Council)3 to pay costs of $30,000 to Thurlow.

[3] Thurlow seeks to increase that award. It contends that the Environment Court ought to have awarded indemnity costs of $269,566.28; this sum is a combination of costs rendered by lawyers and experts. As well as opposing Thurlow’s appeal, the Council cross-appeals, on the grounds that no order for costs ought to have been made.

Background

[4]     By Plan Change 32, the Council sought to increase the development potential in two low-density residential areas, comprised within the Albany Structure Plan Area. To do that, it was necessary to reduce the minimum lot size. During the consultation period, it became clear to the Council that the roading network in the surrounding area was not adequate to fulfil the expected needs of the additional development. In its decision, the Council, considering the roading issue to  be critical, introduced a rule designed to prevent development until appropriate roading was available. This was called the “trigger rule”.

[5] The intention of the trigger rule was to suspend permitted additional development until such time as a road had been built to accommodate anticipated traffic flows. To achieve that end, the Council had nominated a “preferred road” that crossed land owned by North Eastern Investments Ltd (NEIL). While NEIL’s land was outside of the Plan Change 32 area, it did not know, at the time the plan change

1       Thurlow Consulting Engineers & Surveyors Ltd v Auckland Council [2012] NZEnvC 97 (Judge Harland).

2       Thurlow Consulting Engineers & Surveyors Ltd v Auckland Council [2012] NZEnvC 82 (Judge Harland, Commissioner Howie and Commissioner Oliver).

3       Although the Plan Change had been undertaken by the North Shore City Council, by the time of the appeal to the Environment Court the new Auckland Council had taken over its functions.

was proposed, that its interests would be affected. As Thurlow performs consultancy services for NEIL, the latter was able to use Thurlow’s challenge to the plan change as a means of…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Thurlow Consulting Engineers & Surveyors Ltd v Auckland Coun... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2013] NZHC 2468
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Thurlow Consulting Engineers & Surveyors Ltd appealed the amount of an order for costs made in its favour, in the Environment Court. Thurlow sought to increase that award. The Auckland Council cross-appealed, on the grounds that no order for costs ought to have been made. The substantive appeal related to a plan change to the North Shore District Plan, which sought to increase the development potential in two low density residential areas. Thurlow challenged that plan change, on the basis that the roading issue had not been adequately assessed. The Environment Court accepted that the plan change had not been adequately assessed. It also accepted that the trigger rule was too uncertain and not the most appropriate method to implement the policies and achieve the objectives of the Plan. Thurlow sought indemnity costs of $269,566.28. The Environment Court ordered the Council to pay costs of $30,000 to Thurlow. In the High Court, the issues were whether there was a question of law on which the appeal could be heard, whether the Environment Court gave sufficient reasons for its decision on the amount to be ordered as costs, whether the Environment Court erred in its approach to assessment of the costs and witness expenses claimed and whether the Environment Court took into account an irrelevant consideration; namely, the funding position as disclosed to it at the time that the costs application was heard. It was held that three points were questions of law, for the purposes of s 299 of the Act. They were: (a) Whether the Environment Court gave sufficient reasons for its decision on the amount to be ordered as costs. (b) Whether the Environment Court erred in its approach to assessment of the costs and witness expenses claimed. (c) Whether the Environment Court took into account an irrelevant consideration; namely, the funding position as disclosed to it at the time that the costs application was heard. The appeal was allowed and the cross-appeal was dismissed. The award of costs in favour of Thurlow was set aside. The question of costs was remitted for rehearing before the Environment Court.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established