IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF NEW ZEALAND
CA42/03
BETWEENDAVID JOHN THIMBLEBY
Appellant
ANDACCIDENT COMPENSATION CORPORATION
Respondent
Hearing:5 February 2004
Coram:Anderson P
Glazebrook J
Chambers JAppearances: J M Miller for Appellant
B A Corkill and N Lawson for Respondent
Judgment:12 May 2004
JUDGMENT OF THE COURT DELIVERED BY CHAMBERS J
A transitional dilemma
[1] This case involves a short point of statutory interpretation. The question is whether s40(2) of the Accident Rehabilitation and Compensation Insurance Act 1992, as inserted by s8 of the Accident Rehabilitation and Compensation Insurance Amendment Act (No 2) 1996, has retrospective effect.
[2] On 5 December 1994, Douglas Thimbleby, a fitter/welder by occupation, injured his back in the course of his employment. He has not been able to work since that time. At the time of his accident, Mr Thimbleby had been employed for only the past 17 weeks in the year immediately preceding his accident. Mr Thimbleby’s entitlement to compensation at that time was governed by s40 of the Accident Rehabilitation and Compensation Insurance Act 1992 (“the 1992 Act”), as originally enacted. Because he had been in employment for only a short time, his entitlement to compensation under the then s40 led to compensation at only a very low level. Indeed, it was so low in fact that it was advantageous for him to transfer to a social welfare benefit, a step he took in April 1995.
[3] In 1996, Parliament passed the Accident Rehabilitation and Compensation Insurance Amendment Act (No 2) 1996 (“the 1996 Act”). That Act amended s40 and, in general terms, improved the lot of employees who had been in paid employment for only a short period before the event making them unable to work. Eventually the Accident Compensation Corporation (“ACC”) recalculated Mr Thimbleby’s entitlement under s40 as amended. There is no dispute now about Mr Thimbleby’s entitlement since the 1996 Act came into force, namely from 2 September 1996.
[4] The question is, however, whether the amended s40 has retrospective effect and whether ACC was bound to recalculate Mr Thimbleby’s entitlement to compensation in the period from his incapacity in 1994 to 2 September 1996.
Question for determination
[5] On 10 December 2001, Judge Willy held that s40 as inserted by the 1996 Act did in essence have retrospective effect and that as a consequence its formula should be applied from 5 December 1994, the date of Mr Thimbleby’s accident. ACC appealed to the High Court from that decision. On 5 August 2002 Goddard J allowed the appeal. She held that s40 as substituted by the 1996 Act did not have retrospective effect. She held that ACC was not bound to recalculate Mr Thimbleby’s entitlement from the date of his accident until the date on which the 1996 Act came into force.
[6] Mr Thimbleby sought leave to appeal against Goddard J’s decision. Goddard J granted leave on 30 September 2002. A case was stated to this court. The question for the determination of this court is in the following…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Thimbleby v Accident Compensation Corporation and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2004] NZCA 62
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The Court of Appeal meticulously examined the legislative intent and the legal principles governing retrospective legislation. It noted that Parliament had carefully considered the commencement dates of various sections in the 1996 Act and had not designated the amended s40 to have retrospective effect. The Court found that the natural and ordinary meaning of the amended section did not imply retrospective application, and that applying such a provision retrospectively would lead to anomalous and unintended consequences, such as reopening closed claims. Furthermore, the Court highlighted that the absence of any provision to recalculate employers' premiums under the new regime further suggested that the amendment was not intended to have retrospective effect.
In concluding, the Court of Appeal upheld the decision of Goddard J, dismissing the appellant's appeal. The Court ruled that the amendment to s40(2) did not allow for the recalculation of the appellant's weekly compensation from the date of his incapacity in 1994 but only from 2 September 1996. The appellant was ordered to pay costs to the respondent unless legally aided.
Orders
Orders of the court
Full text does not contain this section.
Background
Background to the litigation
Full text does not contain this section.
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Full text does not contain this section.
Decision
Reasons for decision
Full text does not contain this section.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
Full text does not contain this section.