IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF NEW ZEALAND
CA186/05
THE QUEEN
v
MICHAEL CAVANAGH
Hearing:15 June 2006
Court:Robertson, Priestley and Venning JJ
Counsel:P J Kaye for Appellant
D G Johnstone for Crown
Judgment:20 June 2006
JUDGMENT OF THE COURT
THE APPEAL IS DISMISSED.
____________________________________________________________________
REASONS
(Given by Robertson J)
Introduction
[1] Mr Cavanagh stood trial in the High Court at Auckland during February to April 2005 on an indictment containing 13 counts. A number of the 13 counts were joint charges involving three other persons.
[2] At the conclusion of the Crown case, Mr Cavanagh pleaded guilty to five counts, namely:
(a)possession of a firearm and explosives, namely ammunition, at 105 Burswood Drive on 6 August 2002;
(b)possession of equipment and material for the manufacture of methamphetamine at Unit 204 National Mini Storage between 1 and 7 August 2002;
(c)possession of a firearm and explosives, namely ammunition, at Unit 204 National Mini Storage on 6 August 2002.
(d)possession of equipment and material for the manufacture of methamphetamine at Royal Wolf Storage on 5 November 2003; and,
(e)possession of a pistol and explosives, namely ammunition, at Royal Wolf Storage on 5 November 2003.
[3] The jury returned a verdict of not guilty on a charge of conspiring to supply heroin between June and August 2002 but returned verdicts of guilty on the other seven counts namely:
(a)manufacture of methamphetamine between 6 August 1997 and 6 August 2002;
(b)supply of methamphetamine between 6 August 1997 and 6 August 2002;
(c)possession of equipment and material for the manufacture of methamphetamine between 1-7 August 2002 at Unit 832 Safe Store Public Storage;
(d)supply of methamphetamine between 6 August 2002 and 1 June 2003;
(e)supply of methamphetamine between 30 May 2003 and 5 November 2003;
(f)possession of methamphetamine for the purposes of supply between 1 and 7 August 2002; and,
(g)possession of methamphetamine for supply on or about 16 October 2004
[4] Terms of imprisonment between one and twelve years were imposed in respect of the various counts, all to be served concurrently so the effective sentence was 12 years’ imprisonment.
The appeal
[5] There was initially an appeal against conviction and sentence. The conviction appeal was abandoned and the appeal against sentence was pursued on the following grounds:
(a) the sentence is manifestly excessive given the overall offending;
(b)the imposition of an increase in the length of sentence for post-August 2002 offending compounded the excessiveness of the sentence;
(c)there is disparity between the sentence imposed on the appellant and those imposed on his co-offenders; and,
(d)the appellant received no benefit for pleading guilty to five of the charges. Albeit that the pleas came late, some benefit should have been reflected in the sentence.
The facts
[6] Rodney Hansen J who presided at trial summarised the factual position as follows:
[5] I need now to set out the factual basis for the sentences which I will pass. The charges relating to the period up to and including 6 August 2002 followed the termination on 6…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read THE QUEENvMICHAEL CAVANAGH and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2006] NZCA 136
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi