IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF NEW ZEALAND
CA251/2009
[2009] NZCA 377THE QUEEN
v
ZHEN JIE MA
Hearing:13 August 2009
Court:Baragwanath, Randerson and Panckhurst JJ
Counsel:A D Banbrook for Appellant
F E Guy Kidd for Crown
Judgment:26 August 2009 at 10am
JUDGMENT OF THE COURT
THE APPEAL AGAINST CONVICTION IS DISMISSED.
____________________________________________________________________
REASONS OF THE COURT
(Given by Panckhurst J)
INTRODUCTION
[1] Following a jury trial in the District Court at Auckland the appellant was convicted of two offences of receiving. He was sentenced to community work and ordered to pay reparation. The appeal is against conviction.
[2] In the end result the sole ground of appeal concerned whether the trial Judge erred in summing up because he did not direct the jury that “dishonesty” was a necessary element of the offences and, therefore, a matter to be established by the Crown beyond reasonable doubt.
The offending
[3] The charges of receiving related to Nissan and Mazda motor vehicles alleged to have been received by the appellant in July 2007. He operated a scrap metal business. A mainstay of the business was the purchase of old vehicles for scrap.
[4] At trial it was common ground that the appellant had purchased the Nissan vehicle from a named person for $120. The only question in dispute was whether, at the time of the purchase, the appellant knew that the car had been dishonestly obtained or that he acted recklessly in that regard.
[5] In relation to the Mazda, however, the defence was two-fold. The appellant maintained that he was unaware of the vehicle being in his yard, until the police drew attention to it. Accordingly in this instance there were two issues which required determination by the jury, being whether the accused was in possession of the Mazda and, if so, whether his receipt of it was with the requisite guilty knowledge.
Was a dishonesty direction required?
[6] It is convenient to set out part of the written questionnaire which Judge Gittos gave to the jury. We shall remove reference to count 1 (since the contents of the questionnaire as it related to count 2 are sufficiently illustrative for present purposes):
Not in dispute:
A.Both the Nissan car and the Mazda car were stolen from their true owners and were recovered from the accused’s scrap yard by the Police.
B.The Nissan car was in the possession of the accused having been purchased by him.
COUNT 2 – THE MAZDA CAR
1.Was the accused in possession of the car, i.e.: did he know it was in his yard?
If the answer to 1 is “no” (not sure) find the accused not guilty on count 2.
If the answer is “yes” go to question 2.
2.Are you sure that at the time the accused took possession of the Mazda car the accused either:
(a)Knew that it had been stolen or dishonestly obtained; or
(b)Was aware of the risk or likelihood that the car had been stolen or dishonestly obtained and took…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read The Queen v MA and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2009] NZCA 377
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court examined whether the trial judge's summing up to the jury was deficient in not explicitly stating that dishonesty was a necessary component of the offence. The court considered the statutory definition of receiving under the Crimes Act 1961, which requires the accused to know that the property was stolen or to be reckless as to whether it was stolen. The court found that the trial judge's directions to the jury were adequate because they correctly required the jury to determine whether the appellant knew the cars were stolen or was reckless about that possibility. The court concluded that no additional direction on dishonesty was necessary since the statutory definition and the trial judge's instructions already encompassed the necessary mental element.
The Court of Appeal dismissed the appeal against conviction, holding that the trial judge's directions were appropriate and sufficiently covered the elements of the offence. The court found that the jury's understanding of the need for guilty knowledge was adequately addressed in the questionnaire provided to them. Therefore, the conviction stood, and the appellant's appeal was unsuccessful.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi