The Queen v Graham Ashley Robert Palmer

Link copied
Case Copied 28 min read
PUBLICATION OF NAMES AND IDENTIFYING PARTICULARS OF COMPLAINANTS PROHIBITED BY S139, CRIMINAL JUSTICE ACT 1985
IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF NEW ZEALAND

CA80/00

THE QUEEN

V

GRAHAM ASHLEY ROBERT PALMER

Hearing: 19 February 2001
Coram: Gault J
Robertson J
Potter J
Appearances: J L Cagney for Appellant
P K Hamlin and E Barrett for Crown
Judgment: 8 March 2001

JUDGMENT OF THE COURT DELIVERED BY GAULT J

  1. After trial before Judge and jury in the High Court at Auckland the appellant was convicted on one representative charge of inducing an indecent act by a girl between the age of 12 and 16 years, two charges of sexual violation by unlawful sexual connection and one charge of doing an indecent act with intent to offend.  He was acquitted on six further charges.

  2. The first three offences of which he was convicted involved the same complainant, a girl whom the Crown claimed the appellant befriended, supplied with alcohol and drugs and induced to stroke his penis until he ejaculated.  The sexual violation offences involved the same complainant and were said to have been committed on the one occasion on 22 January 1999.  He took her to a house in which he had been living until a short time before and there required her to suck his penis before subsequently penetrating her vagina with his finger.

  3. The fourth offence related to another girl or girls in whose presence the appellant was said to have masturbated and to have asked one of them to participate.

  4. Although convicted on 7 October 1999, the appellant was not sentenced until 7 April 2000.  His appeal was filed promptly but there has been further delay in bringing it on for hearing.  The sentence was preventive detention under s75 Criminal Justice Act 1985 and an order for reparation of $5,000.

  5. The appeal is against both conviction and sentence.

  6. Four grounds of appeal against conviction were advanced originally.  At the hearing none of those grounds were pursued.  Instead six different grounds were put forward which were said cumulatively to warrant concern for the safety of the verdicts.

The Background Facts

  1. The evidence at the trial was extensive but that directed to events on the evening of 22 January 1999 is most relevant to the appeal.  The complainant originally told the police that she had been raped that evening by four men in a white car.  She was not believed, and then complained of the events which she described in her evidence at the trial.  She said that the appellant, whom she had known for some months by then, came to her home at about 8.30 to 8.45pm on the evening in question, a Friday.  She said he came to uplift a battery re-charger for a cell phone he had earlier allowed her to use but had taken back.  She said he took her to 52 Churchill Avenue, Manurewa where he had lived and worked and where she had visited him.  There she said the acts of sexual violation occurred.…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read The Queen v Graham Ashley Robert Palmer and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2001] NZCA 84
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The appeal was brought by Graham Ashley Robert Palmer against both his conviction and sentence. Palmer was convicted of inducing an indecent act by a girl aged between 12 and 16 years, two charges of sexual violation by unlawful sexual connection, and one charge of doing an indecent act with intent to offend. Palmer was acquitted on six further charges. The appeal against conviction was based on six grounds, none of which were pursued at the hearing. Instead, six different grounds were put forward, which were said cumulatively to warrant concern for the safety of the verdicts. The appeal against sentence challenged both the appropriateness of preventive detention and the reparation. The Court of Appeal found no merit in any of the grounds of appeal and dismissed both the appeal against conviction and sentence. The Court held that the appellant's extensive criminal history, which included more than 60 convictions in New Zealand, Great Britain, and Australia, demonstrated a real risk of reoffending. The Court found that preventive detention was the only course it could adopt to protect the community. The order for reparation was also upheld, with the Court finding that it was not cumulative but concurrent and clearly contemplated by the Criminal Justice Act 1985.

The Court found that the appellant's criminal history, which included more than 60 convictions in New Zealand, Great Britain, and Australia, demonstrated a real risk of reoffending. The Court held that preventive detention was the only course it could adopt to protect the community. The order for reparation was also upheld, with the Court finding that it was not cumulative but concurrent and clearly contemplated by the Criminal Justice Act 1985. The Court of Appeal dismissed both the appeal against conviction and sentence.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established