The Queen v Donaldson; The Queen v Chapman

Link copied
Case Copied 19 min read

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF NEW ZEALAND

CA227/06
CA233/06

THE QUEEN

v

JORDAN PATRICK DONALDSON
SCOTT DAVID CHAPMAN

Hearing:30 August 2006

Court:William Young P, Panckhurst and Ronald Young JJ

Appearances:  G M Lynch for Mr Donaldson


M J Callaghan for Mr Chapman
P J Shamy and A R McRae for Crown

Judgment:2 October 2006 at 2.15pm

JUDGMENT OF THE COURT

AThe appeals against sentences of 15 months imprisonment (Mr Donaldson) and 18 months imprisonment (Mr Chapman) are dismissed.

BThe appeals against reparation orders of $21,508.99 (Mr Donaldson) and $22,694.26 (Mr Chapman) are allowed.  Orders in the amounts of $10,000 and $6,000, respectively, are substituted.

____________________________________________________________________

REASONS OF THE COURT

(Given by Panckhurst J)

A spate of burglaries

[1]       A group of young men were responsible for a spate of burglaries committed in Rolleston.  Their ages at the time ranged from 16 years to 20 years.  There were four offenders in all, although not all four were involved in every offence.

[2]       The offending occurred in February and March 2005 at a local school, the rugby clubrooms, the community centre and three commercial premises.  Typically little property was taken, but some degree of damage was caused to the premises which had been entered.

[3]       However, in the course of the burglary of the Rolleston Rugby Clubrooms a fire was started which destroyed the interior contents, and extensively damaged the building itself.  The extent of the loss was quantified at $59,982.75.  By contrast, the total loss caused in the other five burglaries was of the order of $8,000.

[4]       For his involvement in four of the six burglaries Mr Donaldson was sentenced to 15 months imprisonment, with leave granted to apply for release on home detention.  Mr Chapman’s involvement in all six burglaries saw him receive a sentence of 18 months imprisonment, also with leave.  The appellants were ordered to pay reparation in the sums of $21,508.99 and $22,694.26, respectively.  Of these amounts, $19,994.18 was on account of the damage to the rugby clubrooms.  There were four offenders involved in this crime.  Reparation was calculated on the basis of quarter shares.

The three appeal issues

[5]       The appellants challenge both the duration of their prison sentences and the reparation orders, at least in relation to the component of $19,994.18 payable on account of the rugby clubroom loss.  The underlying basis to their challenge is that, although the appellants were involved in the burglary, they were not implicated in lighting the fire and hence they should not share any responsibility for the loss which resulted. 

[6]       The appellants defended two of the burglary charges, including that of the rugby clubrooms.  In the indictment they were also charged with arson of the clubrooms, along with a third offender.  In relation to this count Judge Erber granted a discharge pursuant to s 347 of the Crimes Act 1961 in the course of trial.  The Judge held that because recklessness was an element of the offence, it was incumbent upon the Crown to “exclude…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read The Queen v Donaldson; The Queen v Chapman and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2006] NZCA 279
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The appellants, Jordan Patrick Donaldson and Scott David Chapman, appealed against their sentences and reparation orders imposed by Judge Erber. The appellants participated in a series of burglaries in Rolleston, including the burglary of the Rolleston Rugby Clubrooms where a fire was lit causing extensive damage. Donaldson was sentenced to 15 months imprisonment and Chapman to 18 months, with both having leave granted to apply for release on home detention. They were ordered to pay reparation in the sums of $21,508.99 and $22,694.26, respectively, with $19,994.18 being on account of the damage to the rugby clubrooms. The appellants challenged both the duration of their prison sentences and the reparation orders, arguing that they should not be held responsible for the fire damage as they were not implicated in lighting the fire.

The Court of Appeal considered whether the fire damage was an aggravating feature of the burglary, whether the sentences were clearly excessive, and whether the reparation orders were appropriate. The Court held that the fire was part and parcel of the burglary and an aggravating feature of it, despite the appellants being discharged during trial in relation to the arson count. The Court also found that the sentences of 15 and 18 months were not susceptible to challenge, and that reparation for the fire damage was payable in this case pursuant to s 32(1)(a) of the Sentencing Act. However, the reparation orders were not appropriate having regard to the financial capacity of the appellants. The Court reduced the reparation orders to $10,000 (Donaldson) and $6,000 (Chapman), in light of their respective financial situations.

The appeals against sentences of 15 months imprisonment (Donaldson) and 18 months imprisonment (Chapman) were dismissed. The appeals against reparation orders of $21,508.99 (Donaldson) and $22,694.26 (Chapman) were allowed, with orders in the amounts of $10,000 and $6,000, respectively, being substituted.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.