The King v Ahere Gillies Isiah Buchannan

Link copied
Case Copied 4 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND NAPIER REGISTRY

I TE KŌTI MATUA O AOTEAROA AHURIRI ROHE

CRI-2024-020-000640

[2024] NZHC 2858

THE KING

v

AHERE GILLIES ISIAH BUCHANNAN

On the papers:

Counsel:

S B Manning for Crown

E J Forster for Defendant Gillies
T M Cooper KC and S J Bird for Defendant Buchannan

Judgment:

2 October 2024


JUDGMENT OF GRAU J

[Crown application to lead hearsay evidence]


[1]    The defendants are charged with the murder of Javon Aranui. It is alleged that they took part on a joint attack on him by kicking, stomping, and punching him, including to his head. Two neighbours witnessed the attack, one of whom called 111 while the attack was ongoing. Mr Aranui got to his feet after the attack ended, and Police saw and spoke to him a short distance from the scene. He did not want to discuss what happened or make a statement. He told Police the incident happened at a different location.

[2]    Ambulance officers then arrived and spoke to Mr Aranui, who told them he had been riding his bike home from Havelock North when he was jumped by two people. He told the ambulance officers he had received multiple blows and punches

R v GILLIES & ANOR [2024] NZHC 2858 [2 October 2024]

to his face and, when he was on the ground, he was kicked in the head. His condition then deteriorated rapidly on the way to hospital and he subsequently died from his head injuries.

[3]    The Crown has filed a hearsay notice pursuant to s 22 of the Evidence Act 2006 as it seeks to offer the hearsay statements of what Mr Aranui told the ambulance officers.

[4]    Counsel for each defendant have advised that there is no opposition to the Crown hearsay notice.

[5]    Having reviewed the application and the evidence, I considered the defence concessions were responsibly made and there was no need for the scheduled hearing of the Crown’s application. My brief reasons for that conclusion follow.

[6]    The statements the Crown seek to adduce fall in the category of hearsay as defined in s 4 of the Evidence Act, given they are statements made by a person other than a witness and are sought to be offered in evidence to prove the truth of their contents.

[7]    Hearsay statements are admissible in the circumstances set out in s 17 of the Evidence Act; relevantly, they are admissible under s 18 when the maker of the statement is unavailable as a witness and the circumstances relating to the statement provide reasonable assurance that the statement is reliable.

[8]    The statements in this case are made by a deceased person who is clearly unavailable.

[9]    I agree with the Crown’s submission that the circumstances relating to the statements provide reasonable assurance the statements are reliable. They are statements made by Mr Aranui in answer to questions by the ambulance officers, where it would have been clear they were relevant to the treatment Mr…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read The King v Ahere Gillies Isiah Buchannan and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] NZHC 2858
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the High Court of New Zealand, Napier Registry, the case of The King v Ahere Gillies Isiah Buchannan addresses the admissibility of hearsay evidence in relation to the alleged murder of Javon Aranui. The defendants are charged with participating in a violent attack on Mr Aranui, which resulted in his death. Two neighbours witnessed the attack, and one called emergency services while it was ongoing. Mr Aranui, despite his injuries, managed to get to his feet before being found by police. Despite being given the opportunity, Mr Aranui did not provide a statement to the police and instead gave conflicting information about the location and nature of the attack. Paramedics who attended to Mr Aranui shortly after the attack recorded his statements, which the Crown seeks to introduce as evidence in the trial.

The legal issue before the court was whether the statements made by Mr Aranui to the paramedics, which are hearsay, could be admitted as evidence under the Evidence Act 2006. The court had to determine if the hearsay exception under section 18 of the Act applied, considering that Mr Aranui was unavailable as a witness due to his death and whether the circumstances surrounding the statements provided reasonable assurance of their reliability. Additionally, the court had to balance the probative value of the hearsay statements against any prejudicial effect on the defendants' right to a fair trial.

In granting the Crown’s application, the court found that the statements made by Mr Aranui to the paramedics were reliable as they were made shortly after the incident, were relevant to his treatment, and were consistent with the accounts provided by the eyewitnesses. The court held that the probative value of the statements significantly outweighed any prejudicial effect they might have, especially given that the jury would also hear from the eyewitnesses. The court concluded that the statements were admissible as they provided direct evidence of the events leading to Mr Aranui's death.

The court ordered that the hearsay evidence of Mr Aranui’s statements to the paramedics, as recorded by Paul Goodwin and Ella Merchant, be admitted in the trial. Furthermore, the court agreed that the statements Mr Aranui made to the police officers would also be admissible, albeit not to prove the truth of their contents but to provide a comprehensive account of his statements post-attack.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established