Terry v Christchurch City Council

Link copied
Case Copied 8 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND CHRISTCHURCH REGISTRY

CRI-2015-409-25 [2015] NZHC 1340

BETWEEN

ROBERT FRANK TERRY

Appellant

AND

CHRISTCHURCH CITY COUNCIL Respondent

Hearing: 9 June 2015

Appearances:

Appellant in Person
S Brookes for Respondent

Judgment:

12 June 2015

JUDGMENT OF MANDER J

[1]      Mr Robert Terry has made an application for leave to appeal the dismissal of a first appeal from a finding that a parking infringement offence had been proven against him.  On his appeal before Judge Garland in the District Court,1  Mr Terry was partially successful. A $140 fine was set aside and, in its place, the sum of $40 substituted.  His appeal was, however, otherwise dismissed.

Background

[2]     On 14 January 2015, Mr Terry parked his vehicle on Montreal Street, Christchurch.   The vehicle was in a “Pay and Display” area, however, Mr Terry failed  to  display  the  required  parking  receipt.    A  parking  warden  noticed  the

omission, and issued an infringement notice.

1      Terry v Police [2015] NZDC 3466.

TERRY v CHRISTCHURCH CITY COUNCIL [2015] NZHC 1340 [12 June 2015]

[3]      Mr Terry sought to defend the matter.  The charge was found proven at what was  to  be  the  first  of  two  hearings  before  Justices  of  the  Peace.    Mr  Terry successfully appealed that decision before Judge Couch, and the matter was referred back for a rehearing.   That resulted in a similar outcome, in respect of which Mr Terry again appealed.  It is against the subsequent dismissal of that appeal by Judge Garland that leave is sought to commence a second appeal.

[4]      Upon Mr Terry’s receipt of the infringement notice, he filed a request to defend the matter.  He was advised by the Christchurch City Council (the council) on

12 May that, in due course, a defended hearing would be allocated, and he would be advised of the details.  On 14 June, Mr Terry wrote to the Mayor of Christchurch.  In that letter, Mr Terry refers to the fact that, on 14 January 2014, he was attending Court, and that he ought not to have received a parking ticket when his presence was required in the Court. The letter was to become a key piece of evidence.

[5]      In allowing Mr Terry’s first appeal, Judge Couch observed that the Justices of the  Peace  had  erred  in  finding  the  charge  proved  when  no  evidence  had  been adduced linking Mr Terry to the illegally parked vehicle.  On his appeal before Judge Garland, Mr Terry maintained that the council had again fallen into the same error, and that, even in its second attempt to prosecute him, the council did not adduce sufficient evidence to link him with the unlawfully parked motor vehicle.

[6]      The letter that Mr Terry wrote to the Mayor was produced as an exhibit at the rehearing of the infringement notice.  This evidence was not challenged by Mr Terry at the time it was produced.  On appeal, Judge Garland considered the letter provided a sufficient nexus between Mr Terry and the illegally parked car.  In that letter,…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Terry v Christchurch City Council and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2015] NZHC 1340
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In this matter, Mr Robert Terry sought leave to appeal the dismissal of his first appeal against a decision by the District Court, which had found that a parking infringement offence had been proven against him. The underlying dispute was that Mr Terry had parked his vehicle in a “Pay and Display” area without displaying the required parking receipt, leading to the issuance of an infringement notice. After two hearings before Justices of the Peace and two appeals, the District Court dismissed Mr Terry's appeal against the second rehearing. The primary legal issues in this case involved the sufficiency of the evidence presented by the Christchurch City Council to link Mr Terry with the unlawfully parked vehicle and whether there were grounds for leave to appeal the decision of the District Court.

The court considered whether the evidence, specifically Mr Terry's letter to the Mayor, was sufficient to establish his connection to the vehicle. The court also examined whether the appeal involved a matter of general or public importance or if a miscarriage of justice might have occurred. Mr Terry argued that the Council's reliance on his letter was improper and that there was insufficient evidence regarding the legal ownership of the vehicle. Conversely, the Council maintained that there was ample evidence, including Mr Terry's letter, to link him to the vehicle.

The Court found that the reliance on Mr Terry's letter was permissible under the Evidence Act 2006, as statements made by a defendant are admissible against them. Additionally, the Court accepted that the typographical errors in the registration number did not constitute a miscarriage of justice. The Court also concluded that the issue Mr Terry sought to raise on a second appeal did not involve a matter of general public importance and there was no reasonably available argument suggesting a miscarriage of justice. Consequently, the Court declined Mr Terry's application for leave to commence a second appeal.

No costs were awarded to Mr Terry as he had already received the benefit of the Court refusing to award costs in favour of the Council at the conclusion of his unsuccessful appeal from the finding against him on the rehearing of the infringement notice.