IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND PALMERSTON NORTH REGISTRY
I TE KŌTI MATUA O AOTEAROA TE PAPAIOEA ROHE
CRI-2020-054-1143
[2020] NZHC 1932
NATHAN TE TAU v
NEW ZEALAND POLICE
Hearing: 4 August 2020 Appearances:
P A Foster for the Appellant
J J Harvey for the Respondent
Judgment:
4 August 2020
JUDGMENT OF COOKE J
[1] Nathan Te Tau appeals against a sentence of 18 months’ imprisonment and disqualification from driving for 12 months imposed by the District Court.1 This sentence was imposed following his guilty plea to one charge of breach of release conditions, three charges of driving whilst disqualified (third or subsequent), one charge of failing to remain stopped, and one charge of intentionally hindering an authorised person in breach of the COVID-19 requirements imposed during the Level 4 lockdown.2
1 Police v Te Tau [2020] NZDC 9268.
2 Sentencing Act 2002, s 96A (Cat 2, maximum imprisonment 1 year or fine not exceeding $2000); Land Transport Act 1998, ss 32(1)(a) and 32(4) (Cat 3, maximum imprisonment 2 years or fine of
$6,000); Land Transport Act 1998, ss 52A(1)(b) and 114 (Cat 1, Fine of $10,000); and Health Act 1956, s 72(a) (Cat 2, maximum imprisonment 6 months or fine of $4,000).
TE TAU v NEW ZEALAND POLICE [2020] NZHC 1932 [4 August 2020]
Factual background
[2] Mr Te Tau has a number of previous convictions, including convictions for driving related matters. On 19 July 2019 he was sentenced to one year and one month imprisonment for driving while disqualified on a third or subsequent occasion, and he was disqualified from driving for one year. He was released from prison during 2019. He was given a written instruction as part of his release conditions to report to the Foxton Reporting Centre on 10 October 2019, and fortnightly thereafter.
[3] The first of the present offences relate to his failure to report on 10 October 2019, despite reasonable efforts being made to contact him.
[4] On 24 October 2019 he was then found driving whilst disqualified at 2 am in the morning. This resulted in the second charge.
[5] On 28 January 2020 he was pulled over when police were concerned about the condition of the vehicle he was driving. This was at 9.50 am. He was again driving whilst disqualified.
[6] On 25 April 2020 he was again found driving whilst disqualified at 10.40 pm. On this occasion he was also in breach of the COVID-19 requirements which had by then been imposed. This formed the basis for the further charges of driving while disqualified, failing to remain stopped, and breach of the COVID-19 regulations during the Level 4 lockdown. The summary of facts records that after being pulled over, Mr Te Tau told police officers that the police had no business there. He then got back into his car. He was then warned that if he drove away he would be arrested. He then did so. Police undertook a search for his vehicle but it could not…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Te Tau v Police and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2020] NZHC 1932
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The Court first considered whether the explanation for Mr Te Tau’s conduct was not taken into account by the District Court Judge. The Court found that there was no basis to say that the Judge erred in failing to take this into account because the explanation had only been subsequently raised and was inconsistent with the summary of facts on which he pleaded guilty. The Court also found that the explanation was unlikely to have made a difference to the ultimate sentence.
The Court then considered whether there was double-counting. The Court accepted that there was a risk of double-counting, but found that it was not evident from the judgment of the District Court that the sentence was erroneous. The Court noted that the end sentence was within range.
The Court lastly considered whether the end sentence was manifestly excessive. The Court found that the sentence was at the higher end of the available range, but it was not outside that range. The Court held that the District Court was entitled to take a starting point of two years for the driving related charges and appropriately uplifted the sentence because of recidivism and the COVID-19 charge. The Court recognised that there may be a concern that imprisonment is not proving to be an effective tool to prevent Mr Te Tau from further offending, but found that the District Court did not err in imposing a longer period of imprisonment. The appeal was dismissed.
No orders were made as to costs.