Talwar v New Zealand Police

Link copied
Case Copied 13 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND AUCKLAND REGISTRY

CRI-2012-404-391 [2013] NZHC 315

BETWEEN  PRAVEEN TALWAR Appellant

ANDNEW ZEALAND POLICE Respondent

Hearing:         11 February 2013

Counsel:         RD Mulgan and A Simpson (on instructions from P Winkler) for

Appellant
B Hamlin for Respondent

Judgment:      26 February 2013

JUDGMENT OF BREWER J

This judgment was delivered by me on 26 February 2013 at 3:00 pm pursuant to Rule 11.5 High Court Rules.

Registrar/Deputy Registrar

SOLICITORS/COUNSEL

Patrick Winkler (Auckland) for Appellant

Meredith Connell (Auckland) for Respondent

TALWAR V POLICE HC AK CRI-2012-404-391 [26 February 2013]

Introduction

[1]      The appellant appeals his conviction by Judge DA Burns in the District Court at Auckland on 8 October 2012.  The conviction was on a charge that the appellant drove a motor vehicle on a road while having excess breath alcohol.

[2]      The basis of the appeal is that the District Court Judge should have accepted a “no case to answer” submission made by Mr Mulgan on behalf of the appellant at the close of the prosecution case.  The Judge, in a reserved decision dated 23 April

2012, refused the submission.  Instead, at a further hearing on 26 September 2012, he permitted the prosecution to call further evidence.  The Judge then heard evidence from the appellant.

[3]      My task is to decide if the District Court Judge was right to refuse to acquit the  appellant  at  the  point  at  which  Mr Mulgan  made  the  “no  case  to  answer” submission.

[4]      An  appeal  against  conviction  proceeds  by way  of  rehearing,    In  Austin, Nichols & Co Ltd v Stichting Lodestar, Elias CJ said:1

Those exercising general rights of appeal are entitled to judgment in accordance with the opinion of the appellate court, even where that opinion is an assessment of fact and degree and entails a value judgment.   If the appellate court’s opinion is different from the conclusion of the tribunal appealed from, then the decision under appeal is wrong in the only sense that matters, even if it was a conclusion on which minds might reasonably differ. In such circumstances it is an error for the High Court to defer to the lower Court’s assessment of the acceptability and weight to be accorded to the evidence, rather than forming its own opinion.

[5]      I must, therefore, form my own view of the evidence.

The point at issue

[6]      Section 77(3) of the Land Transport Act 1998 (the Act) provides that the result of a positive evidential breath test is not admissible in evidence if the person

who underwent the test is not advised by an enforcement officer (without delay after

1      Austin, Nichols & Co Ltd v Stichting Lodestar [2008] 2 NZLR 141 at [16].

the result of the test is ascertained) that the test was positive and what the consequences for the person will be if he does not request a blood test within

10 minutes.

[7]      This requirement is subject to s 64(2) of the Act.   Strict compliance is not required so long as there…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Talwar v New Zealand Police and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2013] NZHC 315
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In this case, Praveen Talwar appealed his conviction for driving with excess breath alcohol. The appeal centered on the District Court Judge's refusal to accept a "no case to answer" submission made by Talwar's counsel at the close of the prosecution case. Talwar's counsel argued that the District Court Judge should have accepted the submission because the prosecution failed to provide a reasonable explanation for a 10-minute delay in advising Talwar of the consequences of not requesting a blood test within 10 minutes. The District Court Judge, however, refused the submission and allowed the prosecution to call further evidence.

The primary legal issue was whether the District Court Judge was correct in refusing the "no case to answer" submission. The court had to determine whether the prosecution adequately met its burden of proving the breath test evidence was admissible under section 77(3) of the Land Transport Act 1998, which requires advice to be given "without delay" after a positive result is ascertained. The court also needed to assess whether the failure to explain the delay rendered the breath test evidence inadmissible.

The High Court held that the District Court Judge erred in his approach. The Judge incorrectly based his decision on the argument that Talwar's counsel should have cross-examined the police officer on the delay. The court clarified that section 92 of the Evidence Act imposes a duty to cross-examine a witness if the evidence contradicts the witness's statement, but it does not require defence counsel to cross-examine on defects in the prosecution's case. The court found that the prosecution's failure to provide an explanation for the 10-minute delay meant the requirement to provide advice "without delay" had not been met. As a result, the breath test evidence should have been ruled inadmissible, and there was no case to answer.

The appeal was allowed, and Talwar's conviction was quashed. The court did not direct a rehearing, considering that allowing one would dilute the policy consideration that the police must adequately prove their case.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established