T & S Construction 2015 Limited v Armstrongs Auckland Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 9 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND AUCKLAND REGISTRY

I TE KŌTI MATUA O AOTEAROA TĀMAKI MAKAURAU ROHE

CIV-2023-454-83

[2024] NZHC 3733

BETWEEN

T & S CONSTRUCTION 2015 LIMITED

First Plaintiff

HARMAN IMPEX (NZ) LIMITED
Second Plaintiff

AND

TOYOTA NEW ZEALAND LIMITED

Defendant

CIV-2024-404-467

BETWEEN

T & S CONSTRUCTION 2015 LIMITED
First Plaintiff

AND

HARMAN IMPEX (NZ) LIMITED

Second Plaintiff

YU CAO

Third Plaintiff

Cont’d …

Hearing: On the papers

Appearances:

J S Cooper KC, H Davies, B McKinlay for Plaintiffs T C Weston KC, L C Sizer for Defendant

J Goodall KC, B White and S Coupe for the Defendants in CIV-2024-404-467

Judgment:

9 December 2024


COSTS JUDGMENT OF MUIR J


This judgment was delivered by me on 9 December 2024 at 4 pm, Pursuant to Rule 11.5 of the High Court rules.

Registrar/Deputy Registrar Date: ……………………………

T & S CONSTRUCTION 2015 LIMITED v TOYOTA NEW ZEALAND LIMITED [2024] NZHC 3733

[9 December 2024]

ROSS DAVID BENNETT

Fourth Plaintiff

SHAUN GARTH COUGHLAN

Fifth Plaintiff

ADAM GERALD D’OYLEY STODART

Sixth Plaintiff

ALISON ELIZABETH STODART

Seventh Plaintiff

ASTRID MARY SIMS

Eighth Plaintiff

ALLAN GERALD SIMS

Ninth Plaintiff

KIERAN THOMAS WELSBY

Tenth Plaintiff

DALTON ROBERT REED

Eleventh Plaintiff

NICHOLAS ALEXANDER EYRE

Twelfth Plaintiff

STEVEN MARK HEARD

Thirteenth Plaintiff

DUNSTAN UTHUM FERNANDO

Fourteenth Plaintiff

REHANA FERNANDO

Fifteenth Plaintiff

DUNBLANE FARMS LIMITED

Sixteenth Plaintiff

RICHARD FREDERICK PEET HOWELL

Seventeenth Plaintiff

ROBOTECH CONTRACTORS LIMITED

Eighteenth Plaintiff

JAMES RICHARD WILLIAMS

Nineteenth Plaintiff

ALICIA MAY STYLES

Twentieth Plaintiff

LESLIE DAVID THORN

Twenty First Plaintiff

AND  ARMSTRONGS AUCKLAND LIMITED

Second Defendant

ASHBURTON AUTOMOTIVE LIMITED

Third Defendant

BOWATER MOTORS LIMITED

Fourth Defendant

CENTREPOINT MOTORS LIMITED

Fifth Defendant

COAST CARS AND COMMERCIAL LIMITED

Sixth Defendant

COOKE HOWLISON LIMITED

Seventh Defendant

CROWOOD LIMITED

Eighth Defendant

G W D RUSSELLS LIMITED

Ninth Defendant

HOWARD TRADING LIMITED

Tenth Defendant

MARLBOROUGH AUTOMOTIVE LIMITED

Eleventh Defendant

MILES LIMITED

Twelfth Defendant

MUIR & RICHARDS LIMITED

Thirteenth Defendant

NORTH ALBANY MOTORS LIMITED

Fourteenth Defendant

NORTH OTAGO MOTOR GROUP LIMITED

Fifteenth Defendant

NORTHERN BAYS MOTORS LIMITED

Sixteenth Defendant

PAT PRESCOTT LIMITED

Seventeenth Defendant

RANGIORA AUTOMOTIVE LIMITED

Eighteenth Defendant

RUTHERFORD & BOND LIMITED

Nineteenth Defendant

SCOTT ADAMS LIMITED

Twentieth Defendant

SINCLAIR PRYOR MOTORS LIMITED

Twenty First Defendant

SOUTH CANTERBURY AUTOMOTIVE LIMITED

Twenty Second Defendant

TASMAN AUTOS LIMITED

Twenty Third Defendant

DEBREN ENTERPRISES LIMITED
Twenty Fourth Defendant

WAIKATO MOTORS LIMITED

Twenty Fifth Defendant

Introduction

[1]    On 8 August 2024, I heard applications by the plaintiffs in CIV-2024-404-467 (the dealer proceedings) and CIV-2023-454-83 (the TNZ proceedings) for orders:

(a)adding additional plaintiffs;

(b)substituting the company Debren Enterprises Ltd (DEL) for the existing twenty third defendant, TRC Enterprises Ltd (TRC) in the dealer proceedings; and

(c)consolidating the two sets of proceedings on such terms as the court thought fit.

[2]    Application (a) was resolved on the basis that Toyota New Zealand Ltd (TNZ), and the defendants in the dealer proceedings (together the dealers) did not oppose and therefore abided (with certain reservations acknowledged by the parties and recorded in my judgment).

[3]    Likewise, in respect of application (b), the dealers did not oppose…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read T & S Construction 2015 Limited v Armstrongs Auckland Limite... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] NZHC 3733
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

T & S Construction 2015 Limited and others brought proceedings against Toyota New Zealand Limited and multiple motor vehicle dealers, seeking to add additional plaintiffs and consolidate the proceedings. The High Court of New Zealand considered applications for adding plaintiffs, substituting a defendant, and consolidating the proceedings. The court allowed the addition of plaintiffs and substitution of a defendant but rejected the consolidation of proceedings on the terms that would have removed certain dealers from the case. The defendants sought costs, arguing that the proceedings were complex and significant, warranting a category 3 and band C classification. The plaintiffs argued for a 2B classification and a 50% reduction in costs due to the early resolution of some applications. The court determined that the proceedings were appropriately categorised as category 3 and band C due to their complexity and the novel issues involved. However, the court found that some reduction in costs was warranted, acknowledging the coordinated approach taken by the defendants. The court awarded costs on a 3C basis with a 25% discount on certain steps, resulting in a total award of $24,020.60 for Toyota New Zealand Limited and $18,628.15 for the dealers, inclusive of disbursements.

The court ruled in favour of the defendants, setting out the detailed calculations for the costs awarded, which included specific deductions for certain steps in the proceedings. The court's decision highlighted the complexity of the case and the need for special skill and experience, justifying the higher cost categorisation. The court's ruling provided clarity on the cost implications of the proceedings and the appropriate adjustments based on the outcomes achieved by the plaintiffs.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established