Szekely v Muse on Allen Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 29 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND WELLINGTON REGISTRY

CIV 2013-485-9825 [2017] NZHC 703

UNDER s 174 of the Companies Act 1993

IN THE MATTER OF

Muse on Allen Restaurant

BETWEEN

JOZSEF GABOR SZEKELY Plaintiff

AND

MUSE ON ALLEN LIMITED First Defendant

SAMUEL RAYMOND NORTH Second Defendant

DEBBIE VIVIAN NORTH Third Defendant

MALCOLM LESLIE NORTH Fourth Defendant

Hearing: 7 and 8 February 2017

Appearances:

Q S Haines for the Plaintiff
No appearance for the First and Third Defendants
Second and Fourth Defendants appearing in person

Judgment:

11 April 2017

JUDGMENT OF MALLON J

Introduction ....................................................................................................................................... [1] Facts ................................................................................................................................................... [5] Liability ............................................................................................................................................ [37]

Compensation .................................................................................................................................. [42] Mr Rendell’s approach ................................................................................................................. [42] Mr Sutherland’s approach ............................................................................................................ [51] My assessment .............................................................................................................................. [59]

Result ................................................................................................................................................ [75]

SZEKELY v MUSE ON ALLEN LIMITED [2017] NZHC 703 [11 April 2017]

Introduction

[1]      Jozsef Szekely (the plaintiff) and Samuel North (the second defendant) are chefs.   In 2012 they decided to open a restaurant together.   They each invested money in establishing the business.  Money was also invested by Samuel’s parents, Debbie and Malcolm North (the third and fourth defendants) and Samuel’s partner Amabelle Torrejos.   The business was established as a company, Muse on Allen Limited (the first defendant).

[2]      Within a short  period  there was  a serious  breakdown in  the relationship between Jozsef and the Norths.  As a result, Jozsef stopped working at the restaurant and Samuel transferred Jozsef’s shares into his own name.   Jozsef had no further involvement in the business.  The restaurant was unsuccessful and the company is in liquidation.

[3]      Jozsef contends the Norths conducted the company’s affairs in an oppressive, unfairly discriminatory, or unfairly prejudicial manner.  He seeks compensation from the Norths of $97,449.60, together with interest and costs, under s 174 of the Companies Act  1993  (the Act).    The  Norths  contend  they did  not  conduct  the company’s affairs in an oppressive, unfairly discriminatory or unfairly prejudicial manner  because  Jozsef  walked  out  of  the  business  and  left  them  in  a  difficult position.  They also say his shares were worthless at the time his involvement in the business ceased. They therefore contend no compensation should be awarded.

[4]      Relief  against  the  company  or  against  its  property  is  no  longer  sought because  it  is  in  liquidation  and  the  liquidators  have  not  consented  to  litigation seeking such relief.1

Facts

[5]      Jozsef and Samuel were friends who had worked together as chefs.  In 2012, when Jozsef was age 31 and Samuel was 21, they decided to open a restaurant together. They looked for suitable premises. They decided upon premises which had operated  as  a  Malaysian  restaurant,  Satay  Kampong,  located  in  Allen  Street,

Wellington. The owners of Satay Kampong owned the building.

1      Companies Act 1993, s 248(1)(c).

[6]      Satay  Kampong  was  a  different  style  of  restaurant  from  the  fine  dining restaurant Jozsef and Samuel intended to open.  Jozsef and Samuel regarded Allen Street to be a desirable location for their restaurant and for this reason the Satay Kampong premises was suitable.

[7]      On  19  July 2012  they  entered…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Szekely v Muse on Allen Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2017] NZHC 703
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In Szekely v Muse on Allen Limited, the plaintiff, Jozsef Szekely, sought compensation under section 174 of the Companies Act 1993 from the Norths, who were shareholders and directors in the company Muse on Allen Limited, for their conduct which he claimed was oppressive, unfairly discriminatory, or unfairly prejudicial. The Norths argued that they did not conduct the company's affairs in an oppressive, unfairly discriminatory, or unfairly prejudicial manner, and that Szekely's shares were worthless at the time of his exclusion from the business, thus no compensation should be awarded. The court found that Szekely's shares were of no value when he was excluded from the business, and as such, there was no basis for awarding compensation to him. The court also dismissed Szekely's application for relief under section 174 of the Companies Act and directed the Norths to provide information regarding the costs incurred in the proceeding to determine the question of costs.

The central legal issue in this case was whether the Norths' conduct towards Szekely was oppressive, unfairly discriminatory, or unfairly prejudicial, warranting compensation under section 174 of the Companies Act. The court found that Szekely's shares were of no value when he was excluded from the business, and thus, there was no basis for awarding compensation to him. The court also considered the evidence of two experts, Mr Rendell and Mr Sutherland, who provided differing valuations of Szekely's shares. The court ultimately agreed with Mr Sutherland's approach, which took into account the company's liabilities and the loss of goodwill, and concluded that Szekely's shares were of no value when he was excluded from the business.

The outcome of this case reinforces the principle that compensation under section 174 of the Companies Act is not automatic, and the court must consider the fair value of the shares at the time of exclusion, taking into account the company's financial situation and any relevant factors. In this case, the court found that Szekely's shares were of no value, and thus, there was no basis for awarding compensation to him.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.