Stockman v Health and Disability Commissioner

Link copied
Case Copied 5 min read

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF NEW ZEALAND

I TE KŌTI MANA NUI

 SC 107/2020
 [2021] NZSC 16
BETWEEN

PETER GERARD STOCKMAN
Applicant

AND

HEALTH AND DISABILITY COMMISSIONER
First Respondent

ANTHONY HILL
Second Respondent

MEENAL DUGGAL
Third Respondent

Court:

William Young, Glazebrook and O’Regan JJ

Counsel:

Applicant in person
M S Smith for Respondents
K M Burkhart for Robyn Galvin as Interested Party

Judgment:

3 March 2021

JUDGMENT OF THE COURT

A        The application for leave to appeal is dismissed.

BThe applicant must pay the first respondent costs of    $2,500.

____________________________________________________________________

REASONS

  1. The applicant, Mr Stockman, commenced proceedings in the High Court challenging decisions made by the first respondent, the Health and Disability Commissioner (the Commissioner), in relation to complaints Mr Stockman had made about counselling services provided by the Interested Party, Ms Galvin.  He sought judicial review of a number of decisions and actions taken in the Office of the Commissioner in relation to his complaints and, in particular, the decision to take no further action in relation to his substantive complaint.  He complained that the Office of the Commissioner discriminated against him because he is a man.  He alleged both breach of statutory duty and breach of the New Zealand Bill of Rights Act 1990.  He also sought damages from the Commissioner and both the second respondent, Mr Hill, a former commissioner, and third respondent, Ms Duggal, a former deputy commissioner, for misfeasance in public office.

  2. There were a number of interlocutory matters which came before the High Court for resolution.  In particular, Mr Stockman sought standard and particular discovery and applied for the suppression of the name of a third party associated with the events leading to the complaint.  Both Mr Hill and Ms Duggal applied for an order striking them out as parties to the proceeding or to have the claims against them for misfeasance struck out. 

  3. The High Court Judge declined the applications for discovery, declined the application for name suppression and granted the strike‑out applications by Mr Hill and Ms Duggal.[1]

  4. Mr Stockman appealed as of right against the strike‑out decisions and was granted leave by the High Court to appeal against the other aspects of the High Court decision.[2]

  5. In a judgment dealing with all of Mr Stockman’s challenges to the High Court decision, the Court of Appeal:[3]

    (a)rejected Mr Stockman’s claim that the High Court Judge was biased against him because he was an unrepresented litigant and therefore failed to give him a fair hearing;

    (b)upheld the High Court decision refusing standard discovery;

    (c)upheld the High Court decision refusing discovery of confidential reports;

    (d)upheld the Commissioner’s claim to privilege in relation to certain documents; and

    (e)upheld the striking out of the actions for misfeasance in public office against Mr Hill and Ms Duggal.

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Stockman v Health and Disability Commissioner and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2021] NZSC 16
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the Supreme Court of New Zealand, the applicant, Mr. Stockman, sought leave to appeal the decision of the Court of Appeal in relation to proceedings he had commenced in the High Court against the Health and Disability Commissioner, challenging the decisions made by the Commissioner in relation to complaints he had made about counselling services. He sought judicial review of a number of decisions and actions taken in the Office of the Commissioner in relation to his complaints, in particular the decision to take no further action in relation to his substantive complaint. He also sought damages from the Commissioner and two former employees for misfeasance in public office. The Court of Appeal had rejected Mr. Stockman’s claims that the High Court was biased against him and had upheld the refusals of discovery, the striking out of claims for misfeasance in public office, and the Commissioner’s claim to privilege in relation to certain documents. Mr. Stockman sought leave to appeal to the Supreme Court against all other aspects of the Court of Appeal’s decision.

The issues Mr. Stockman wished to pursue on appeal could be divided into three broad categories: procedural unfairness/bias in the High Court, discovery issues, and misfeasance in public office: strike-out. The Court considered the issues raised by Mr. Stockman. The Court found that the allegations of bias in the High Court were not made out and that the issues raised were fact-specific and did not raise matters of general importance requiring resolution by the Court. The Court was not satisfied that the standard appeal criteria in s 74(2) of the Senior Courts Act 2016 were met, and that it was necessary in the interests of justice for the Court to hear and determine the appeal before the proceeding concerned was concluded. The Court also found that there was no basis for Mr Stockman’s allegation that the Court of Appeal was biased against him and that there was insufficient prospect of success in the arguments the applicant wished to pursue to justify the cost and delay of a further appeal.

The Court dismissed the application for leave and awarded costs of $2,500 to the first respondent. The Court found that none of the points of appeal that the applicant wished to pursue met the criteria for leave to appeal. The application for leave to appeal was dismissed, and the applicant must pay the first respondent costs of $2,500.

Background

Background to the litigation

Peter Gerard Stockman initiated proceedings in the High Court against the Health and Disability Commissioner, challenging decisions made regarding complaints he had lodged about counselling services provided by Ms Robyn Galvin. Stockman alleged discrimination by the Commissioner's office due to his gender and sought judicial review of various decisions and actions taken by the office. He also claimed breaches of statutory duty and the New Zealand Bill of Rights Act 1990. Additionally, Stockman sought damages from the Commissioner, and former Commissioner Anthony Hill and former Deputy Commissioner Meenal Duggal, for misfeasance in public office. The High Court declined Stockman's applications for discovery, name suppression, and granted the strike-out applications by Hill and Duggal. Stockman appealed the High Court's decision to the Court of Appeal, which rejected his claims of bias and upheld the High Court's decisions on discovery, privilege, and striking out the actions for misfeasance.

Stockman initially filed proceedings in the High Court challenging the decisions of the Health and Disability Commissioner. The High Court ruled against Stockman's applications for discovery, name suppression, and granted the strike-out applications by the former Commissioner and Deputy Commissioner. Stockman appealed the High Court's decisions to the Court of Appeal. The Court of Appeal upheld the High Court's decisions on the discovery applications, the Commissioner's claim to privilege, and the striking out of the actions for misfeasance in public office against the former Commissioner and Deputy Commissioner. Stockman sought leave to appeal to the Supreme Court against all other aspects of the Court of Appeal's decision, except the name suppression issue, which was resolved to his satisfaction.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the application for leave to appeal should be granted due to procedural unfairness/bias in the High Court.
2. Whether the application for leave to appeal should be granted on the basis of discovery issues.
3. Whether the application for leave to appeal should be granted concerning the striking out of the actions for misfeasance in public office.

Held
1. The application for leave to appeal was dismissed due to procedural unfairness/bias in the High Court.
2. The application for leave to appeal was dismissed on the basis of discovery issues.
3. The application for leave to appeal was dismissed concerning the striking out of the actions for misfeasance in public office.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Supreme Court of New Zealand considered the application for leave to appeal by Mr. Stockman and found that none of the issues raised met the criteria for appeal under section 74(2) and (4) of the Senior Courts Act 2016. The Court dismissed Mr. Stockman's claims of bias and procedural unfairness against the High Court Judge and the Court of Appeal. The allegations were considered fact-specific and did not raise matters of general importance requiring resolution by the Supreme Court. The Court of Appeal had already carefully considered the substantive issues Mr. Stockman raised in relation to discovery and misfeasance, and the Supreme Court saw no basis for Mr. Stockman's allegation that the Court of Appeal was biased against him.

Regarding the discovery issues, the Supreme Court found that the points Mr. Stockman wished to raise were interlocutory and specific to the factual situation. The Court concluded that these issues did not raise matters of general importance requiring resolution by the Supreme Court. Moreover, the Court did not see any risk of a miscarriage of justice if leave was not granted.

In relation to the misfeasance issue, the Supreme Court found insufficient prospect of success in the arguments Mr. Stockman wished to pursue to justify the cost and delay of a further appeal. The Court of Appeal had already applied an orthodox analysis, and the Supreme Court did not see any basis for a further appeal on this matter.

Based on these considerations, the Supreme Court dismissed the application for leave to appeal and awarded costs of $2,500 to the first respondent, the Health and Disability Commissioner. The ratio decidendi of this decision is that specific, fact-based issues that do not raise matters of general importance are not suitable for appeal under the Senior Courts Act 2016.