Stiassny v Siemer

Link copied
Case Copied 7 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND AUCKLAND REGISTRY

CIV-2005-404-1808 [2013] NZHC 114

BETWEEN  MICHAEL PETER STIASSNY AND KORDA MENTHA (FORMERLY FERRIER HODGSON) Plaintiffs/Respondents

ANDVINCENT ROSS SIEMER Defendant

Hearing:         7 February 2013

Appearances: DM Salmon for Plaintiffs/Respondents

PJL Hunt for Respondents on the recall/set-aside application
Defendant in person

Judgment:      7 February 2013

ORAL JUDGMENT OF TOOGOOD J [APPLICATION TO HAVE COUNSEL DISQUALIFIED]

D Salmon/ITF Hikaka, Lee Salmon Long, Auckland:  davey.salmon@lsl.co.nz Isaac.hikaka@lsl.co.nz

PJL Hunt, McElroys, Auckland:

V Siemer, 27 Clansman Tce, Guf Harbour:  vsiemer@hotmail.com

STIASSNY & ANOR(FORMERLY FERRIER HODGSON) V SIEMER HC AK CIV-2005-404-1808 [7

February 2013]

[1]      Mr Siemer has filed an application to recall a judgment of Cooper J dated

23 December 2008 in proceedings CIV-2005-404-1808[1]  on the grounds that it was obtained by fraud.  That application is opposed by the plaintiff respondents on three grounds:

[1] Korda Mentha v Siemer HC Auckland CIV-2005-404-1808, 23 December 2008.

(a)      First, that the recall application is an abuse of process in that there is no jurisdiction for the Court to order the recall of the judgment at this stage, some four years after the delivery of the judgment;

(b)Second, that, in any event, there is no justification for recalling the judgment, the grounds not reaching the high threshold required; and

(c)      Third, that the recall application amounts to an attempt to defend the proceedings in which the judgment was given and that Mr Siemer is debarred from so defending that proceeding by an order of Potter J in this Court which remains in force.[2]

[2] Ferrier Hodgson v Siemer HC Auckland CIV-2005-404-1808, 9 July 2007 at [68] and [72].

[2]      The recall application is before me for hearing today.  I am told that Mr Hunt has appeared as counsel throughout the lengthy history of the proceeding, both in the High Court and in the Court of Appeal, and the plaintiffs wish him to appear on the recall application.   Mr Siemer alleges, however, that Mr Hunt is compromised as counsel and should be disqualified.

[3]      That submission is based on an allegation of misconduct by Mr Hunt in relation to an issue of security for costs in respect of which Mr Siemer challenged a decision by the Registrar of the Court of Appeal to require security for costs to be paid by him on an appeal.   It is said that, in the course of resisting Mr Siemer’s application  that  he  should  not  pay  security,  Mr Hunt  told  the  Court  of Appeal incorrectly that Mr Siemer had not paid a single costs award made between the parties.  Mr Siemer says that not only was that a statement which misled the Court of Appeal but it was one on which the Court of Appeal’s decision to require payment of

security for costs was based.  He says that the allegation of misconduct is not denied.

[4]      Mr Siemer  submits  that  having  regard  to  that  allegation  of  misconduct, Mr Hunt’s alleged misconduct is an issue in the proceeding to recall Cooper J’s judgment which I am…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Stiassny v Siemer and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2013] NZHC 114
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Stiassny and Korda Mentha (formerly Ferrier Hodgson) v Siemer, the defendant, Mr Vincent Siemer, applied to recall a judgment delivered by Cooper J on 23 December 2008 in the Auckland Registry of the High Court. The plaintiffs, represented by Mr Salmon, opposed the application on the grounds that it was an abuse of process, the grounds for recall did not meet the required threshold, and Mr Siemer was barred from defending the recall application by a previous order of Potter J. Mr Siemer further sought to disqualify Mr Hunt, who had appeared as counsel for the plaintiffs throughout the proceedings, from continuing to act on the recall application. Mr Siemer alleged that Mr Hunt had misled the Court of Appeal in respect of a security for costs issue in a related appeal.

The court considered whether Mr Hunt's alleged misconduct in the Court of Appeal proceedings was an issue in the recall application and whether it warranted his disqualification under the Lawyers and Conveyancers Act (Lawyers: Conduct and Client Care) Rules 2008. The court found that the alleged misconduct did not occur in the recall application proceedings and did not compromise Mr Hunt's independence and objectivity. The court also noted that Mr Siemer had already complained to the Law Society and that the Supreme Court was likely to consider the issue in a separate appeal. The application to disqualify Mr Hunt was therefore declined.

The court ordered that the plaintiffs were entitled to costs, which would be determined on the papers unless a further hearing was required. The plaintiffs were to file a costs memorandum by 22 February 2013, and Mr Siemer could reply by 8 March 2013. The court would then decide on the costs in respect of the disqualification application.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.