Stephens v R HC Napier CRI-2011-441-31

Link copied
Case Copied 15 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND NAPIER REGISTRY

CRI-2011-441-31

KURT RONALD STEPHENS

Appellant

v

THE QUEEN

Respondent

Hearing:         28 September 2011

Counsel:         J G Krebs for the Appellant

J Lucas for the Respondent

Judgment:      28 September 2011

(ORAL) JUDGMENT OF WOODHOUSE J

Solicitors:

Mr J G Krebs, Barrister, Napier

Mr J Lucas, Elvidge & Partners, Office of the Crown Solicitor, Napier

STEPHENS V R HC NAP CRI-2011-441-31 28 September 2011

[1]      Mr Stephens appeals against sentences imposed in the District Court for one offence of burglary and one offence of unlawfully getting into a motor vehicle. Cumulative sentences were imposed resulting in an effective sentence of two years and two months imprisonment.

[2]      The appeal is on the grounds that the sentence is manifestly excessive and that there was an error by the Judge in taking into account information not known to the appellant.  I will explain the latter point in due course.

The facts

[3]      On 8 February 2011 a Mazda double-cab trade vehicle was stolen from the premises of a company in Gisborne.  The next day the appellant, and three others, went in this vehicle to a residential property in Napier.  This was during the day on a week day.  The vehicle was driven to the back of the house.  A co-offender broke open the back door causing damage.  The three other co-offenders – other than the appellant – went into the house and began taking items out of it.   The appellant directly assisted by picking up a set of speakers that were put at a door.  Property valued at about $4,000 was taken including a large television screen, jewellery, the speakers, clothing and other items.

[4]      A neighbour alerted the police.  The vehicle was pulled over by police and was then driven away by a co-offender in circumstances which are not relevant to the appellant’s appeal.  When the vehicle was eventually stopped an imitation pistol and a roll of masking tape were found in the vehicle. The stolen property was recovered.

District Court sentencing

[5]      The appellant and his co-offenders were sentenced on the same day, 1 July

2011.  The appellant did not turn up on time because there were transport delays. For this reason he was sentenced later in the day.  (I note that there is no relevant criticism of the appellant for failing to be at  Court at the appointed  time.)    In sentencing the appellant, the Judge relied on the comments he had already made in

sentencing the co-offenders and made further observations relating specifically to the appellant. There are therefore two sentencing notes relating to the appellant.[1]

[1] R v Hemaloto and Ors DC Napier, CRI-2011-041-452, 1 July 2011 (the co-offenders) and R v Stephens DC Napier, CRI-2011-041-1104, 1 July 2011 (the further notes relating specifically to Mr Stephens).

[6]      In sentencing the co-offenders the Judge noted, for the purposes of assessing a starting point for the burglary, the decisions in Senior v Police,[2] R v Southon,[3] R v Columbus[4] and…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Stephens v R HC Napier CRI-2011-441-31 and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2011] NZHC 1258
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the High Court of New Zealand, the case of Stephens v R involves an appeal by the appellant, Kurt Ronald Stephens, against the sentences imposed by the District Court for one count of burglary and one count of unlawfully getting into a motor vehicle. Stephens was sentenced to an effective total of two years and two months imprisonment. The grounds for the appeal are that the sentence is manifestly excessive and that there was an error by the Judge in taking into account information not known to the appellant. The key legal issues revolve around the appropriate starting point for the burglary, the consideration of Inspector Dewhirst's affidavit on the prevalence of burglaries in the Eastern District, and whether the final sentence imposed is manifestly excessive.

The court found that the Judge's reliance on Inspector Dewhirst's affidavit, which was not provided to the appellant's counsel, was unfair and led to an inappropriate starting point for the burglary. The affidavit's lack of detail and particularisation did not meet the requirements set by the Court of Appeal in Christofides v R. The court also noted that the Judge seemed to have assumed the appellant was part of a group of recidivist burglars, a connection that was not tested on behalf of the appellant. Consequently, the court assessed the sentence de novo and determined that the appropriate starting point for the burglary should be 18 months imprisonment, considering the appellant's lesser culpability. For the offence of unlawfully getting into the vehicle, the court decided on a concurrent sentence, uplifted by two months due to the appellant's status under supervision and community work at the time of the offence.

The court concluded that the sentence imposed by the District Court was manifestly excessive and allowed the appeal. The District Court's sentence was quashed, and in its place, the court substituted sentences of 16 months imprisonment for the burglary and one month imprisonment for unlawfully getting into the vehicle, with those sentences to run concurrently.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.