Specialised Structures New Zealand Limited v Findlater Construction Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 29 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND BLENHEIM REGISTRY

CIV-2016-406-000011 [2016] NZHC 1340

BETWEEN

SPECIALISED STRUCTURES NEW

ZEALAND LIMITED Plaintiff

AND

FINDLATER CONSTRUCTION LIMITED

First Defendant

AND

RONALD STEVELY FINDLATER Second Defendant

Hearing: 16 June 2016

Appearances:

P B Churchman QC and C M Kenworthy for Plaintiff
T Sissons and S F Gaines for Defendants

Judgment:

21 June 2016

JUDGMENT OF DUNNINGHAM J

[1]      Specialised Structures New Zealand Limited (“SSNZL”) is a building kitset provider specialising in cold rolled steel frame portal buildings.   It has developed software to assist with the design and construction of those buildings.

[2]      Findlater     Construction     Limited     (“FCL”)     was     established     by Mr Ronald Findlater in 2001.   It undertakes a wide range of commercial building work in and around Blenheim.

[3]      In 2005, FCL entered into an agreement with Kiwispan Limited to build steel sheds in the Marlborough district.  However, as a result of an internal dispute within Kiwispan, the company was dissolved in 2011, and SSNZL took over part of the

Kiwispan operation under the new company branded as SSNZL.

SPECIALISED STRUCTURES NEW ZEALAND LIMITED v FINDLATER CONSTRUCTION LIMITED [2016] NZHC 1340 [21 June 2016]

[4]      SSNZL, FCL and its director, Mr Linklater, entered into a contract which governed their relationship.   It gave FCL the exclusive licence to sell SSNZL’s products and services in the Marlborough province and to use its proprietary system. The agreement contained certain obligations in restraint of trade at the termination of that relationship.

[5]      The relationship was terminated in October last year (although the exact date is disputed), and SSNZL claims that the two defendants are in breach of those restraint obligations.   An interim injunction is sought to enforce the contractual restraints.

[6]      There are two main concerns raised by SSNZL:

(a)      it considers the defendants have been involved in building projects, since termination, which use SSNZL’s proprietary systems, or which have been undertaken for a former customer of SSNZL.   Those building projects comprise:

(i)an  extension  for  Marlborough  Gold  Honey  Limited,  its premises in Bristol Street, Blenheim;

(ii)two steel hangars at Koromiko Airfield, near Picton, which was  built  in  conjunction  with  another  competing  business, Fair Dinkum Sheds;

(b)FCL has taken on a dealership with Fair Dinkum Sheds and SSNZL considers this is in clear breach of the restraint against FCL being involved in any business which is similar to, or competitive, or in conflict, with SSNZL’s business.  Buildings which have commenced under this arrangement include the two hangars referred to above, plus

extensions to a warehouse at Liverpool Street, Riverlands.1

1      This last building was brought to the Court’s attention via a memorandum filed subsequent to the

hearing.

[7]      While initially SSNZL sought an injunction requiring the defendants to cease their relationship with Fair Dinkum Sheds, and to cease work on the Marlborough Gold  Honey  extension  building  contract  and  the  Koromiko  Airfield  contracts, SSNZL has since accepted that damages would be a sufficient remedy for FCL’s involvement in the Marlborough Gold Honey extension building, taking into account there was only two…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Specialised Structures New Zealand Limited v Findlater Const... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2016] NZHC 1340
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Specialised Structures New Zealand Limited (SSNZL) sought an interim injunction against Findlater Construction Limited (FCL) and Ronald Stevely Findlater for breach of restraint of trade obligations contained in a contract between the parties. The contract gave FCL an exclusive licence to sell SSNZL’s products and services in the Marlborough province and to use its proprietary system. The agreement contained certain obligations in restraint of trade at the termination of the relationship. The relationship was terminated in October last year (although the exact date is disputed), and SSNZL claims that the two defendants are in breach of those restraint obligations. SSNZL sought an interim injunction requiring the defendants to cease operating as agent, independent contractor or in any other business arrangement with Fair Dinkum Sheds franchise or any other entity similar to, or competitive with, or in conflict with the plaintiff within the Marlborough area. The restraint period was 12 months after termination of the contract. The defendants argued that SSNZL had not attempted to resolve the dispute using the procedure set out in cl 41, and had failed to establish that it or the System would suffer irreparable damage if an injunction was refused. The defendants also argued that FCL has complied with all of the obligations imposed on it by cl 29, which is, among other things, to relinquish all the intellectual property of SSNZL and not use it. The restraint clause relied on is wider than is reasonably necessary to protect the plaintiff’s proprietary interest. The Court rejected the argument that the application for injunctive relief was an abuse of process. The Court was satisfied that there was a serious question to be tried that there has been a breach of an enforceable restraint of trade. The Court also found that the balance of convenience favoured the grant of an interim injunction. The Court considered that the relative strength of SSNZL’s case was a strong factor supporting the grant of an interim injunction. The Court also found that damages would not be an adequate remedy for the loss suffered by SSNZL. The Court found that the effect on innocent third parties did not weigh against the grant of an interim injunction. Finally, the Court found that the conduct of the parties did not weigh against the grant of an interim injunction. The Court granted the interim injunction sought by SSNZL for the balance of the restraint period, excluding certain building projects on the basis that to include them would adversely affect third parties.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established